flag
back Back
Former SFA official reacts to James Penrice controversy as Rangers beat Aberdeen in Premier Sports Cup
Glasgow Rangers v St. Johnstone - William Hill Premiership 2026/27
Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images

TalkingPoints

Hampden Hero ๐Ÿ˜Ž Give us your reaction as Rangers leave it late to break Aberdonian hearts ๐Ÿ‘‡ The final awaits ๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜

Des Roache believes Rangers should have been down to ten men vs Aberdeen

Former SFA referee Des Roache is of the view that James Penrice deserved a red card against Aberdeen. Rangers ended the game with 11 players rather than 10, which played a major role in their victory.

Penrice, who started in a different position than he is normally used to, had a tough evening at Hampden Park. Surprisingly, he was the one who ended up providing the assist for Ryan Naderiโ€™s winner.

However, he would not have been on the pitch had the on-field referee Ryan Lee made the right call, according to Roache. In his view, both Lee as well as John Beaton, the VAR, got it wrong, and it was a poor first half from them.

โ€œA red card would be absolutely warranted. Poor first half from Ryan Lee and John Beaton.โ€

What exactly did James Penrice do against Aberdeen?

Penrice and Afeez Aremu both contested for the ball in the first half of the game and the Gers man actually lifted his foot high and found himself making contact with the midriff of the Aberdeen man with his studs facing him. While the stills will make the incident a lot worse, the Scotsman knows that heโ€™s lucky to avoid a sending-off.

Had this decision gone against Rangers, fans would have been furious and rightly so, as it was hard to argue against a sending-off. However, games can be won and lost by moments like these, and McInnes will be delighted that fortune favoured his side on the night.

You may like

Rangers fans will surely not like what Andy Burnham has just said about Celtic

rangersnews.uk 1 day ago

Rangers obligation met amid eyebrow-raising decision as Aberdeen give manager stay of execution

scotsman.com 55 minutes ago

Celtic slam Rangers 'false equivalence' as SFA rejects stadium closure appeal

belfastlive.co.uk 1 day ago

Exclusive: Rangers man parts ways with club for good after moving to Ibrox in 2023

rangersnews.uk 1 day ago

I was totally blown away by playing Rangers at Ibrox - I'd made it

glasgowtimes.co.uk 1 day ago

Graeme Souness reveals how he nearly signed former Leeds United and Liverpool midfielder at Rangers

rangersnews.uk 11 hours ago

Federico Chiesa should only have one option as bold Liverpool transfer claim made

liverpool.com 2 hours ago

Rangersโ€™ Connor Barron Loan Nightmare Gets Worse as Middlesbrough Situation Remains Unresolved

ibroxnoise.co.uk 11 hours ago

Inside Rangers dressing debrief from Tynecastle escape act as rollercoaster could still go either...

Daily Record 17 hours ago

Daniel Sturridge names two Chelsea stars who could become โ€˜eliteโ€™ after Man Utd victory

thechelseachronicle.com 4 hours ago