Back
Manchester United’s decision to sign Youri Tielemans from Aston Villa has so far failed to deliver the expected benefits for either side, according to Daily Mail journalist Tom Collomosse. The Belgian midfielder is still adjusting to life at Old Trafford, while Villa have struggled to find an adequate replacement for his influence in midfield.
According to a report by FootballTransfers on Sunday, November 22, 2026, United secured Tielemans last summer after activating his reported €41 million (£35 million) release clause. However, his early performances in Manchester have been below expectations, while Aston Villa have endured a difficult spell, going five consecutive matches across all competitions without a victory.
Collomosse believes Villa have particularly felt the absence of the midfielder's composure, intelligence and ability to distribute the ball effectively. His contribution to the team's midfield structure made him an important figure under Unai Emery, and replacing those qualities has proved more difficult than anticipated.
Since his departure, Emery has attempted to reorganise the midfield by relying on Leon Goretzka, João Gomes and Ross Barkley. Nevertheless, none of the three has managed to reproduce the level of control and passing quality that Tielemans previously offered.
Consequently, Villa could consider strengthening their central midfield options when the January transfer window opens. Bringing in another player with the ability to dictate the tempo and improve their creativity could help address the problems that have emerged since the Belgian's exit.
At Manchester United, meanwhile, concerns have been raised about Tielemans' physical attributes, with some questioning whether he possesses the athleticism required for the demands of the Premier League. However, his technical qualities and ability to control possession remain valuable strengths that could eventually make him an important member of the squad.
The arrival of Mauricio Pochettino as head coach provides the midfielder with an opportunity to establish himself under a new manager. The Argentine will have the chance to evaluate his qualities and determine how best to incorporate him into United's tactical plans.
Tielemans will therefore be hoping to secure a starting position when Manchester United travel to Anfield to face Liverpool. The encounter represents an important opportunity for him to demonstrate his value, particularly as it will be Pochettino's first match in charge.
Pochettino was appointed on November 12, replacing Michael Carrick after signing a two-and-a-half-year contract. He faces the immediate challenge of improving a struggling team that currently occupies 19th position in the Premier League standings.
Manchester United are six points behind Aston Villa, who sit 11th, highlighting the difficulties both clubs have experienced this season. Despite their poor league position, United can draw some encouragement from their recent record at Anfield, having avoided defeat in their last three visits, with one victory and two draws.
For Tielemans, the Liverpool fixture could provide an early opportunity to convince Pochettino that he deserves a regular place in the starting lineup.