Back
One year on from the greatest night Hampden has witnessed, there’s little appetite for wallowing in nostalgia.
Scotland’s 4-2 win against Denmark on November 18, 2025, will always feel like more than a football match.
It was a life-affirming event for those fortunate enough to have been there and those who watched on in disbelief from every corner of the globe.
On a night of jaw-dropping drama, after six failures to qualify for the World Cup, the Tartan Army were in seventh heaven.
While there was a suspicion at the time that it could not and would not get any better than that, few, truthfully, suspected that matters would nosedive quite as they have done over 12 months.
After another underwhelming show at a major tournament, there was broad agreement that Steve Clarke’s time was up. The feeling was that the whole thing needed a fresh face with new ideas and energy.
Although appointing a manager with such little experience as Sebastien Pocognoli wasn’t what most had in mind, there was a willingness to give it a go.
Just 13 weeks after his unveiling, though, there are alarm bells going off all over the place.
Apparently wedded to a 3-4-2-1 formation, there’s scant evidence that the Belgian’s approach is best suited to the resources at his disposal.
Promised they would see Scotland suffocate the opposition with a high defensive line and an aggressive high press, the Tartan Army are beginning to feel like they’ve been sold a pup. The team is soft, vulnerable and thoroughly unconvincing.
While it escaped no one’s notice that many of the performances in the World Cup qualifying campaign were patchy, the side under Clarke did have a happy knack of striking at the right moments. That covered a multitude of sins.
But the ice in the veins is seemingly no more. One of the many reasons why the team has regressed is that, in both boxes, the players are going weak at the knees when it counts.
‘We need to get back to having those big moments,’ said Kieran Tierney, the scorer of a spectacular third against the Danes. ‘That night was amazing. It was one of the greatest nights of our careers — everyone involved would say that.
‘We want to get back to special moments like that. In this camp we’ve had a win and a loss which isn’t great. We probably need a game like that Denmark one to turn things for us.
‘We’ve all been in situations with club and country when things aren’t going your way. Switzerland were clinical on Monday night and that’s why it’s a sore one.’
You think back a year ago, to Scott McTominay’s outrageous overhead, to Tierney’s howitzer and to Kenny McLean’s ridiculous chip from the halfway line. Big players stepping up and delivering in game-defining moments.
On Friday night against North Macedonia, Billy Gilmour missed a chance he should have scored with his eyes closed before McTominay lost his man at a corner.
In St Gallen, Lewis Ferguson’s unfathomable own goal undid Scotland’s promising start at a stroke.
These are individual errors, but they are adding up to a team which looks decidedly unsure of itself.
When the Swiss struck early in the second half, it stemmed from Ferguson turning the ball over.
The third goal felt only a matter of time. It arrived, typically, five minutes later after a slip from Nathan Patterson.
When goals are conceded in pairs, it does not say much for the side’s mentality.
‘Usually in football, when you concede, the other team will have momentum,’ Tierney explained. ‘That’s definitely something we need to work on.
‘We have to be more solid when we concede. We need to be better in both boxes.
‘Early in the second half, there were two very quick goals which just killed the game for us. There was no way back after 3-0, so there’s definitely stuff to work on.’
There is, however, just no time to do that now. And that’s the main concern about where all of this is going. Because while Pocognoli’s plan unquestionably has merit, it is a radical departure from the Clarke era.
Across pre-season and regular training sessions, the manager of a club side has sufficient time to shape a team. An international manager doesn’t have the same opportunity.
You don’t doubt that the players want to adapt. You do doubt if there’s the capacity to do so.
‘When you’re used to something for seven years, it’s going to take time,’ Tierney stressed. ‘But all of us here believe in it. On Monday night there was some good stuff but, to be honest, nobody cares about that. It’s the result that matter.
‘We’re the same as players. We want to be winning these games and competing at a much better level.
‘It’s a sore one to take and because we don’t meet up until March now. There’s time to reflect on it.’
Tierney is a rarity in the sense that the role he’s being asked to fill on the left-side of defence isn’t alien to him.
Like the other senior players who were asked about the manager in the past week, he’s also not shy to talk him up. Whatever else may be wrong behind the scenes, there appears to be mutual respect.
‘I love playing as a left centre-back in a three,’ said the Celtic man. ‘So, I think it does suit my game well. I’ve played for Scotland in a three and had a lot of success before.
‘I’ve also played in a four with success. It’s easy to look at the formation, but there’s a lot more that goes into it than that.
‘It’s been good for me personally. This is my first seven or eight days with him and it’s newer to me because most of the boys had a couple of weeks with him last month. But I’ve enjoyed it. I enjoy playing in the system and the trust he’s got in me.’
Although some have already called for the Scottish Football Association to press the ejector button after just six matches, the majority of supporters seem willing to give Pocognoli time. But even the most patient among them are increasingly concerned about the direction of travel.
Now set to be in pot three when the Euro 2028 draw is made next month, right now, the prospect of tackling two big hitters holds about as much appeal as a course of root canal treatment. That storied night against Denmark now feels like ancient history.