Back
The San Francisco Giants should go as high as two years and $36 million guaranteed for Nick Martinez. That’s $18 million per season for a starter who can slot behind Logan Webb and Landen Roupp. A third guaranteed year would extend the deal through Martinez’s age-38 season.
ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel projected one year and $17.5 million for Martinez on Nov. 3. On Nov. 4, Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly predicted two years and $36 million with the Giants. The estimates differ by just $500,000 per season, so the decision hinges on whether to guarantee the second year.
The best argument for topping $36 million is how few proven innings the Giants have behind Webb and Roupp. Adrian Houser is coming off a flexor strain, and the Giants’ rotation plan could leave the fifth spot to a spring competition. Martinez threw 165.2 innings for Cincinnati in 2025 and 180 over 31 starts for Tampa Bay in 2026. He walked just 26 batters in his first All-Star season.
That workload is worth paying for even if his ERA rises. Martinez posted a 4.45 ERA in 2025 before lowering it to 3.10 last year, when he struck out 15.1% of opposing hitters. With so few strikeouts, any drop in his command would put more pressure on the defense. The Giants can pay for a dependable turn in the rotation and leave room for his run prevention to settle somewhere between those two seasons.
Start with an $18 million salary in 2027, an $18 million club option for 2028 and a $2 million buyout. That would guarantee Martinez $20 million at signing. San Francisco could offer $1 million apiece for reaching 150 and 170 innings in 2027, giving him a path to earn more for staying in the rotation.
2028 Club Option |
Total Before Incentives |
Total With Both Bonuses |
|---|---|---|
Decline |
$20 million |
$22 million |
Exercise |
$36 million |
$38 million |
If Martinez can secure two guaranteed years, the Giants can match Kelly’s $36 million projection. Above that guarantee, or if bidding reaches a guaranteed third year, San Francisco should move on. In his Nov. 3 projections, McDaniel put left-hander Foster Griffin at two years and $30 million. Griffin threw 172 2/3 innings last season, and the lower $15 million annual average would leave more room for late-inning help.
McDaniel projected two years and $42 million for Sonny Gray. At $21 million a season, Gray would cost more than Martinez, with a stronger strikeout track record to justify the difference. He struck out 149 in 169 innings for Boston last season, 40 more strikeouts than Martinez in 11 fewer innings.