flag
back Back
The 3 Man Utd Starting XI Changes Carrick Must Make to Save his Job vs Leeds
Action Images via Reuters/Lee Smith

Oct 17, 2026, 1:16 PM GMT+1

Jamie is a Welsh football journalist based in Valencia, Spain. 

He studied journalism at the University of South Wales and published a football book, named Bluebird Heaven, around the same time with Pitch Publishing.

Since then, Jamie has continued to specialise in football journalism, PR and football-related Spanish translation. He has worked with a number of media companies, including Reach PCL, Iconic Group and many more over a decade-long career.

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account

Manchester United head into Sunday's Premier League clash with Leeds United desperate for a win, and Michael Carrick's job may yet depend on it. The Red Devils were beaten by Atletico Madrid in the Champions League during the week to continue their disappointing start to the season, and Carrick is already on the brink.

There is already talk of Carrick being replaced should his side suffer a defeat this weekend, with Brighton boss Fabian Hürzeler emerging as an apparent target. United have just one win in their first six league games, and they are desperate to avoid the season getting away from them.

Leeds have three points more at this stage, but United need to be winning at Elland Road if they have hope of repeating last season's relative success of finishing inside the top three. Defeat could see United's season spiral, and it could spell the end for Carrick, so what changes does the current Red Devils boss need to make to save his job? Here we take a look based on the starting XI from Tuesday night's defeat to Atletico, and we will leave the poorly performing Diogo Dalot out because of United's problems at right-back, limiting Carrick's options.

Get Bruno back in his best position

Bruno Fernandes
Action Images via Reuters

Carrick needs to get Bruno Fernandes back to his best position in the attacking midfield after playing him wide against Atletico. Fernandes is not in the best form, but he remains the club's best player, so put him in his best position and give him time to rediscover his form from last season.

Carrick is trying too hard to shoehorn players into positions, and when that means moving Fernandes, it crosses a line. United are also struggling to get good services to their strikers, and it's another reason why Fernandes simply has to play that number 10 role. It's not as though Youri Tielemans is playing well there in any case.

Tielemans could drop into midfield for Andrey Santos or drop out altogether. Neither would be a particularly questionable decision.

Fees correct prior to summer 2026

All 10 found — excellent!

Cunha for Rashford

This isn't another attack on Rashford because there are worse-performing players in this team, whether United fans like it or not. But the winger is too easy to read, and until he shows he can offer something different, he needs to be coming off the bench.

Matheus Cunha looked sharper after coming off the bench against Atletico, and he needs to come in for Rashford, albeit he will likely play as the striker and with Bryan Mbeumo as the winger. Either way, the attack needs something different.

Martinez needs a game on the bench

Manchester United's Lisandro Martinez staring

This has nothing to do with his outburst during the week, which Carrick says has been dealt with. The issue is Martinez's performances. He has been a liability too often, and United are going to need to be physically stronger at Elland Road, and that means the reintroduction of Harry Maguire.

Leny Yoro may have been sent off during the week, but he played well up until that point. Let's see Maguire and Yoro play together to give United a balance of strength and speed without the sacrifice of height and aerial dominance, which is also going to be important against Dominic Calvert-Lewin, who is agile on the ground and in the air.

You may like

Chelsea player ratings vs Everton: 8/10 sends Xabi Alonso message with new signings up for fight

standard.co.uk 35 minutes ago

Why does everyone hate Arsenal?

fourfourtwo.com 1 day ago

30 Players with Most Match-Winning Goals in Premier League History

givemesport.com 1 week ago

LIV-ING LIFE: Brentford vs Liverpool LIVE: Reds look to get back to Premier League winning ways a...

the-sun.com 58 minutes ago

Everton 0-2 Chelsea: Pedro Neto scores twice after Morgan Rogers escapes red card in Premier Leag...

skysports.com 43 minutes ago

Lisandro Martinez: Man Utd defender told Ratcliffe to sign Chelsea star, NOT Senne Lammens

teamtalk.com 2 days ago

Why Pep Chavarria dropped out of Chelsea team at Everton after making trip

standard.co.uk 3 hours ago

‘I Won 3 Premier League Titles With Man Utd - Here’s Why I Wouldn’t Sign Erling Haaland’

givemesport.com 6 hours ago

Rio Ferdinand branded a 'disgrace' after hitting out at Man Utd influencer in 'fat-shaming' row

mirror.co.uk 1 hour ago