flag
back Back
Manchester City are no longer the team everyone fears – and the statistics prove it
Enzo Maresca and Phil Foden shake hands.
Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images

Manchester City under Pep Guardiola saw opposing teams beaten before they’d even stepped off the team bus; such was the intimidating nature of a winning machine.

City often ensured an air of inevitability, with the club dominating under Guardiola with his style of play suffocating teams, depriving them of the ball until their resistance folded like a cheap deckchair!

TalkingPoints

What have you made of Iliman Ndiaye’s start at Man City? 👀

That aura of invincibility seemingly departed with the legendary Spaniard. Following Guardiola’s summer exit after a decade in charge, the transition to Enzo Maresca is now proving turbulent after a positive start.

The psychological stranglehold that City once exerted over English football has loosened. Opponents no longer set up to limit the damage, they arrive believing City are fragile and can be rattled, as Forest, Brighton and Aston Villa have proved in recent weeks.

The underlying data tells the full story and highlights why City have some big work to do if they’re to stamp their authority on the Premier League once again.

From 100 points to vulnerability: Comparing City’s eras

To understand what has changed in the blue half of Manchester, it’s important to measure the current situation against the benchmarks set during the club’s dominant phase.

Between 2017 and 2024, City set the standards to win the Premier League on a consistent basis, breaking the 90-point barrier four times and becoming the first men’s team in English top-flight history to win four successive titles.

In contrast, the closing stages of Guardiola’s time at the club reveal a significant drop-off in points. The team came third in 2024/25 and second in 2025/26 with 71 and 78 points, respectively.

Season Manager League Finish Points (PPG) Win % Goals Conceded (Per Game) Clean Sheets
2017/18 (Centurions) Pep Guardiola 1st 100 (2.63) 84.2% 27 (0.71) 18
2018/19 (Fourmidables) Pep Guardiola 1st 98 (2.58) 84.2% 23 (0.61) 20
2022/23 (Treble Winners) Pep Guardiola 1st 89 (2.34) 73.7% 33 (0.87) 13
2023/24 (Four-in-a-Row) Pep Guardiola 1st 91 (2.39) 73.7% 34 (0.89) 13
2024/25 Pep Guardiola 3rd 71 (1.87) 55.3% 44 (1.16) 13
2025/26 Pep Guardiola 2nd 78 (2.05) 60.5% 29 (0.76) 15
2026/27 (First 10 Games) Enzo Maresca 3rd 21 (2.10) 70.0% 13 (1.30) 3

The numbers show a clear structural shift. During the 2017-2019 peak, City averaged over 2.58 points per game and won more than four out of every five league fixtures.

Across 2024/25 and 2025/26, Guardiola experienced consecutive league seasons without lifting a title for the first time in his managerial career, with points-per-game dipping around the 1.87-2.05 mark.

Fast forward to this season, and City’s 70% win rate keeps them in the top three, a trio of defeats in their opening ten league matches – with the 3-1 loss to Forest the latest – highlight a side that now drops points with relative ease rather than coming once in a blue moon – no pun intended!

Control and defensive security are lacking

City’s greatest defensive asset was never their back four – it was their ability to prevent transitions before they even started. At their peak, City defended with the ball, averaging close to 70% possession while executing an aggressive counter-press that pinned opponents inside their own final third.

Here is how that particular trait of the winning machine has steadily degraded over the last three seasons:

  • Vulnerability in transition: During the 2020/21 campaign, City conceded just 0.2 shots per match from opposition counter-attacks. By 2024/25, that figure had quadrupled to 1.2 shots per match on the break, with City matches becoming far more stretched.
  • A leakier backline: In 2017/18 and 2018/19, when City won league titles, they conceded just 0.71 and 0.61 goals per game, keeping 38 clean sheets across 76 matches. In 2024/25, they shipped 44 goals (1.16 per game), and through the first ten matches of 2026/26, they are conceding 1.30 goals per match, with just 30% of the matches seeing City claim a clean sheet.
  • A more pragmatic approach: Even during Guardiola’s last season in 2025/26, tactical analysts noted a shift towards a more pragmatic approach – sacrificing relentless high pressing for a more compact mid-block and quicker vertical passes to Erling Haaland. Under Maresca, City still averages 66% possession, yet that no longer guarantees insulation from danger. Opponents are generating over 1.15 expected goals per match against them.

The exodus of leaders and a different squad profile

Statistics do not exist in a vacuum. However, they do reflect a massive turnover in personnel and leadership. Over the past 24 months, Manchester City have dismantled their spine, and although they’ve tried to rebuild it, the club have lost some seriously talented players who led them through a decade of glory.

Departure / Loss Role in Peak City Current Status (2026/27)
Kevin De Bruyne Primary creative engine, big-game match-winner Departed for Napoli
Rodri Tactical anchor, tempo-setter, transition-stopper Departed for Barcelona
Kyle Walker Recovery pace defending high line, club captain Departed for Burnley
Ederson Press-resistant distributor, sweeper-keeper Departed for Fenerbahçe
Bernardo Silva Pressing trigger, big-game versatility, vice-captain Departed for Real Madrid
John Stones Hybrid defender-midfielder, build-up composure Departed for Inter Milan after 10 years

Replacing that collective Premier League know-how and footballing IQ is impossible to achieve in one transfer window. City have invested in younger players who bring a more dynamic core, and the squad’s profile has changed.

The likes of Elliot Anderson, Enzo Fernandez, Rayan Cherki and Rayan Ait-Nouri all bring something to the squad, and so too does Marc Guehi. However, they all operate in key areas of the squad, and that’s going to take time to become more coherent on the pitch.

City are now more athletic, direct and individual-driven, with Haaland’s ruthless finishing and Jeremy Doku’s dribbling key to how successful this current City team can be. However, they possess far fewer players who can dictate the tempo, the likes of Bernardo Silva, Ilkay Gundogan and Rodri, who just knew instantly when to slow things down with 30 minutes remaining.

Temporary decline or the end of an era?

Whether or not this is actually the end of an era could be decided away from the football pitch and inside the courtroom instead. Declaring City as ‘finished’, however, would be wide of the mark.

A side averaging 2.10 points per game and boasting arguably the most devastating striker in world football will always remain in title conversations and win silverware – much like they did in the final chapters of Guardiola’s time at the club.

However, in the broader, more historical sense, an era of some sorts has undoubtedly drawn to a close. The version of Manchester City that treated 90-point seasons as par for the course, dominated opponents and turned the Premier League title race into nothing more than a procession has now been consigned to history.

Under Maresca, City are becoming a different sort of contender. They’re explosive, dangerous and can beat anyone on any given day. There is just something about them at the moment, however, that suggests every team now has a bit of a blueprint on how to beat them and no longer feel defeated or intimidated before a game has even kicked off.

You may like

The most overrated player in the Premier League named and shamed

express.co.uk 17 hours ago

Why do Chelsea and Tottenham hate each other?

standard.co.uk 3 weeks ago

Man United crisis opens up new job opportunity for Guardiola

pulse.ng 4 days ago

'He has killed football'- UEFA vice-president Boniek slams Guardiola

dailypost.ng 16 hours ago

We needed Mourinho — Real Madrid star explains how 'Special One' changed from Chelsea days

pulse.ng 4 days ago

England vs Spain was Raheem Sterling at his very best - his decline was sad, steep and rapid

mirror.co.uk 2 days ago