Super Eagles goalkeeper Maduka Okoye produced a sensational penalty save to rescue a point for Udinese against Parma. The masterclass has completely divided Nigerian fans, with many demanding he instantly dethrones Stanley Nwabali.

Maduka Okoye had waited three months for a clean sheet, when it finally arrived, he did more than keep the opposition out.

He reignited one of Nigerian football's most divisive debates: Should Okoye be the Super Eagles' first-choice goalkeeper ahead of Stanley Nwabali?

Since August 15, the Udinese goalkeeper had gone nine matches without a clean sheet. That frustrating run finally ended on Wednesday night against Parma, but not before the Nigerian had to earn it the hard way.

Despite Udinese's dominance, the struggling Italian side needed Okoye to step up when it mattered most. The 27-year-old delivered.

Okoye saved a second-half penalty, made another save during the match and walked away with the Man of the Match award.

It was the kind of performance that reminded everyone of his ability between the sticks. And, naturally, Nigerians had plenty to say.

For some supporters, Okoye's club performances make his continued absence from the starting lineup difficult to understand.

One Nigerian fan questioned why a goalkeeper performing at a high level in one of Europe's top leagues was not getting the same opportunities with the national team.

Another went further, arguing that Okoye was superior to Nwabali across the attributes expected of a goalkeeper. But not everyone was convinced.

Some supporters pointed to Okoye's previous Super Eagles performances, arguing that Nwabali had earned the No. 1 position through his displays for Nigeria.

Another fan offered a more nuanced view, acknowledging Okoye's quality while questioning whether his attitude and body language with the national team matched his performances at club level.

That is where the debate gets interesting.

Okoye's latest performance is a reminder of what he can offer. Saving a penalty under pressure and earning Man of the Match recognition are achievements worth celebrating.

But the Super Eagles' goalkeeping debate cannot be settled by one clean sheet or one impressive performance.

Club form matters. So does consistency, and performances for the national team must count in the selection discussion.

For Okoye, the challenge is to turn his club performances into a compelling case for more opportunities with Nigeria.

For Nwabali, the challenge is to maintain the standard that helped him establish himself as a leading contender for the position.

And for Eric Chelle, it is a welcome selection headache.

With another international window approaching, has Okoye done enough to challenge Nwabali for the Super Eagles' No. 1 shirt? Nigerians certainly have opinions.