Back
Manchester City supporters have been questioning the wisdom of some of their summer business after a poor run of form under Enzo Maresca.
The Sky Blues spent heavily in a bid to wrestle back the Premier League title after two seasons of missing out, but not all of their market decisions have had a positive impact.
One of the most questionable was choosing to sell James Trafford and continue with Gianluigi Donnarumma between the sticks. On paper, recouping £45m for a back-up goalkeeper was really good business, but after Trafford shone for England during the international break – and Donnarumma made another high-profile error – it looks as though City may have made a blunder which will continue to haunt them.
TalkingPoints
10 games into the Enzo Maresca era, where do you see Man City finishing this season?
Trafford’s move to Leeds United was not necessarily seen as being a big problem for City after the deal was done in July. However, Donnarumma has been poor so far this season, while the younger keeper continues to impress.
His best moment so far came on Sunday evening, when his heroics kept England in front as they defeated world champions Spain.
The 24-year-old made six saves in total, including a quite brilliant double stop to deny the Spanish an equaliser right at the end of the game.
With Jordan Pickford watching on from the bench, the performance underlined Trafford’s status as England’s long-term No. 1, and for as long as he holds that office, City’s decision to move him on will look like a mistake.
Clearly, something had to be done this summer after the academy graduate sat on the bench all last season. In that respect, the mistake can be traced back to Donnarumma’s arrival in the summer of 2025. Trafford may not have been quite ready then, but his was always a long-term project, and had Pep Guardiola kept faith in the Englishman, City would be reaping the rewards right now.
There is still a very strong argument that Donnarumma is a better goalkeeper than Trafford, and there will be plenty of City fans who would rather have the Italian in goal for the time being.
However, it is fairly clear that he is currently making too many errors. After some clangers for City this season, the 27-year-old made another on Thursday, as he gifted the ball straight to Michael Olise during Italy’s win over France.
The Azzurri may have come back to take the points from Les Bleus, but Donnarumma made them work for it after playing a pass to Olise just outside the area after only 10 minutes.
All goalkeepers make mistakes, and it should be pointed out that Trafford did a similar thing when laying the ball to Evalison to score during Leeds’ defeat against Bournemouth in October. But the younger keeper is on a real upward trajectory, while, despite being young for a goalkeeper, Donnarumma may already have peaked.
The smart move in 2025 was to give Trafford time to grow into the No. 1 position and accept that he may not be perfect right away. Instead, City look set to miss out on his peak years and may end up having to replace Donnarumma in the near future too.
Trafford may still return when that happens, and he will most likely be looking to move upwards from Leeds if he does cement himself as England’s No. 1. But having been now stung at the Etihad once, why would he be in a rush to return for a third stint? Whichever way you slice it, this was a bad decision by City.