Manchester United is facing increased scrutiny over their choice to keep Michael Carrick as manager, especially with Marco Silva being suggested as a potential alternative who might have provided more stability and potentially helped avoid the costs linked to another managerial change.

A report from GiveMeSport on October 17, 2026, indicates that United's tough start to the Premier League season has amplified doubts regarding their management decisions, particularly as Carrick has been unable to produce consistent results.

The team has reportedly secured only one win in their initial league matches, raising alarm about their overall performance and the rationale behind retaining the former midfielder. Their recent Champions League loss to Atletico Madrid has heightened the pressure as they prepare for a challenging match against Leeds United.

While Carrick had a strong run last season, his recent struggles have reignited discussions about Manchester United's pattern of hiring former players in hopes of revitalizing the club’s fortunes. Previous managers, like Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, have led to debates about whether familiarity with the club is sufficient for success.

Silva was reportedly one of the managers United could have explored over the summer. The Portuguese coach left Fulham after a successful stint in the Premier League before taking over at Benfica, where he has started off well.

Having managed numerous English teams like Fulham, Everton, Watford, and Hull City, Silva’s experience in the Premier League could have made him an appealing choice for a club in search of tactical stability and improved results.

Pep Guardiola, the manager of Manchester City, has praised Silva’s coaching abilities, expressing confidence that he is destined to become one of football’s top coaches.

"Marco is one of the top, top, top managers I face. Destined to be one of the top in a few years for sure," Guardiola remarked in February.

The report states that Silva achieved 12 wins in his first 16 matches at Benfica, suffering only two defeats during that time. These successes have bolstered arguments that United may have missed out on a viable candidate.

Additionally, Brighton manager Fabian Hürzeler has reportedly surfaced as another potential option should Manchester United opt to replace Carrick.

While another managerial change could lead to additional compensation payments and recruitment costs, Silva’s past achievements do not guarantee he would replicate that success at Old Trafford, leaving United's decision a contentious topic.