khune and da cruz reignite penalty debate at kaizer chiefs as sundowns semi-final approaches

amakhosi supporters face a difficult question: who should be trusted with the responsibility if their upcoming carling knockout showdown against mamelodi sundowns is decided by penalties?

JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA — 10 NOVEMBER 2026

The penalty-taking situation at Kaizer Chiefs has become one of the biggest talking points among supporters following the club's dramatic qualification for the Carling Knockout semi-finals.

Former Amakhosi goalkeeper and club legend Itumeleng Khune has shared his opinion on the matter, while current head coach Fernando Da Cruz has also explained how penalty responsibilities are handled within his squad.

The debate comes after Chiefs defeated Siwelele FC 2-1 at the New Peter Mokaba Stadium on Sunday, November 8, to secure their place in the last four of the competition.

However, the victory was not without drama, particularly when it came to penalties.

Mduduzi Shabalala missed an important spot-kick in the first half, sending his effort over the crossbar when Chiefs had an opportunity to equalise.

The midfielder later won another penalty, but this time Wandile Duba stepped forward and successfully converted to bring Amakhosi level before the break.

Khune subsequently questioned the decision to allow Shabalala to take the first penalty, suggesting that Duba should have been trusted with both opportunities because of his impressive scoring form and confidence.

Duba had previously scored a hat-trick against TS Galaxy, making him one of the club's most dangerous attacking players at the moment.

However, Da Cruz has defended Shabalala, insisting that missing penalties is part of football and that players should never allow such moments to destroy their confidence.

The French tactician also explained that his team has several designated penalty takers, although the final decision can depend on the players' feelings and circumstances during a match.

With Chiefs now preparing for a difficult semi-final encounter against Mamelodi Sundowns, the penalty conversation has become even more interesting.

Sundowns are a formidable opponent, and the possibility of a penalty shootout cannot be completely ruled out.

For Chiefs, choosing five reliable penalty takers could make a significant difference in their pursuit of a place in the final.

Wandile Duba, Mduduzi Shabalala, Pule Mmodi, Mfundo Vilakazi and Elias Mokwana are among the names supporters could consider, depending on availability and match fitness.

THE BIG QUESTION: If Kaizer Chiefs face Mamelodi Sundowns in a penalty shootout, which five players would you trust to take responsibility?

Amakhosi supporters have an opportunity to share their selections and explain why those players deserve the responsibility.

Source https://x.com/KickOffMagazine/status/2120145378594980054