sundowns face transfer dilemma as allende's possible exit raises big question about his replacement

soft headline: cardoso faces a difficult task as supporters debate whether the brazilians should find allende's successor in the psl or look overseas

JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA — 10 NOVEMBER 2026

Mamelodi Sundowns could face a significant challenge in the upcoming transfer window if Marcelo Allende decides against extending his contract at Chloorkop, with questions already being raised about who could possibly replace the influential Chilean midfielder.

Allende has established himself as one of the most important players in the Sundowns midfield since arriving from Uruguayan club Montevideo City Torque in August 2022.

His technical ability, intelligent movement, passing accuracy, work rate and composure under pressure have made him a valuable member of Miguel Cardoso's squad.

The 27-year-old's contract is approaching its conclusion in June 2027, meaning Sundowns could risk losing him without receiving a transfer fee if an agreement is not reached.

Recent reports have linked Egyptian giants Al Ahly and Pyramids with the midfielder, while other overseas opportunities could also emerge.

However, Cardoso has made it clear that retaining Allende remains a priority for the Tshwane giants.

The Sundowns coach previously described him as a maestro and praised his professionalism, consistency and influence on teammates. Cardoso also highlighted his incredible physical contribution, revealing that he regularly covers approximately 12 kilometres per match.

Replacing such a player would require careful consideration.

One possible internal solution could be Bathusi Aubaas, who has received praise from Cardoso for his performances while Teboho Mokoena has been unavailable.

Nevertheless, Aubaas and Allende offer different qualities, meaning Sundowns might still need to recruit another creative midfielder.

The domestic market could also provide interesting possibilities. Orlando Pirates midfielder Thalente Mbatha is among the players supporters could consider when discussing energetic and technically capable midfield options.

However, whether he would be the right tactical fit for Cardoso's system remains a separate question.

Sundowns could alternatively explore the international market, particularly South America, where the club has previously identified players capable of adapting to its football philosophy.

For a club competing for the Betway Premiership title and continental honours, replacing Allende cannot simply be about signing another midfielder. The successor must possess the mentality, consistency and technical qualities required to perform under pressure.

For now, Sundowns will hope to convince their Chilean star to remain at Chloorkop rather than begin a complete rebuilding process in midfield.

THE BIG QUESTION: If Marcelo Allende leaves Mamelodi Sundowns, who would you bring in as his replacement? Is there a suitable midfielder already playing in the Betway Premiership, or must Masandawana search outside South Africa?

Source https://x.com/Soccer_Laduma/status/2120124954729447886