As the Sundowns semifinal draws near, Khune and Da Cruz renew the penalty argument at Kaizer Chiefs.

Supporters of the Amakhosi confront a challenging dilemma: if the outcome of their impending carling knockout match against the Mamelodi Sundowns is determined by penalties, then who should be trusted with the responsibility?

November 10, 2026, Johannesburg, South Africa

Following the team's thrilling qualification for the Carling Knockout semi-finals, one of the main topics of conversation among fans is the penalty-taking issue at Kaizer Chiefs.

Itumeleng Khune, a former Amakhosi custodian and club star, has expressed his thoughts on the subject, while current head coach Fernando Da Cruz has also described how his team handles penalty duties.

The discussion follows Chiefs' 2-1 victory over Siwelele FC at the New Peter Mokaba Stadium on Sunday, November 8, which guarantyd them a spot in the competition's final four.

But there was some drama involved in the win, especially with regard to penalties.

When the Chiefs had a chance to equalise in the first half, Mduduzi Shabalala squandered a crucial penalty kick, shooting his attempt over the crossbar.

Later, the midfielder was awarded another penalty, but this time, Amakhosi was tied before halftime thanks to a successful conversion by Wandile Duba.

Khune later questioned the choice to give Shabalala the first penalty, arguing that Duba should have been given both chances due to his strong scoring record and self-assurance.

Duba is currently one of the team's most dangerous offensive players after scoring a hat-trick against TS Galaxy.

Da Cruz, on the other hand, has stood up for Shabalala, saying that players should never let missed penalties undermine their confidence because they are a necessary part of the game.

The French tactician added that while his side has multiple designated penalty takers, the ultimate choice may be influenced by the players' emotions and the situation during a game.

The topic of penalties has grown even more intriguing as Chiefs get ready for a challenging semi-final matchup with Mamelodi Sundowns.

Given Sundowns' strength, a penalty shootout is not entirely out of the question.

Selecting five dependable penalty takers might have a big impact on the Chiefs' chances of making it to the championship game.

Depending on availability and match fitness, fans may want to consider Wandile Duba, Mduduzi Shabalala, Pule Mmodi, Mfundo Vilakazi, and Elias Mokwana.

THE BIG QUESTION: Which five players would you trust to take charge in a penalty shootout between Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns?

Supporters of Amakhosi have the chance to express their choices and justify why those players should be in charge.

Source https://x.com/KickOffMagazine/status/2120145378594980054