Back
Spare a thought for the Kiwi radio host who had a meltdown on air a week ago, branding New Zealand’s loss to Wales the ‘worst performance in All Black history’.
“In a sporting sense it feels like a death in the family,” spat Mark Watson, not one to understate a point. “I feel embarrassed, I feel humiliated. Lose to England and rugby is dead and buried.”
It had just passed 5 o’clock in the morning in Auckland when the final whistle blew on England’s 37-12 victory at Allianz Stadium.
More than 11,000 miles from home New Zealand had suffered its heaviest ever loss to northern hemisphere opposition; their performance significantly worse than at the Principality.
“We actually didn’t play that badly against Wales,” Sean Fitzpatrick, the shellshocked All Blacks legend, considered. “This time we didn’t really fire a shot.”
In New Zealand and South Africa, where rugby is king, extreme reactions to defeat are not uncommon. Look at Rassie last week and his response to a two-point loss to France.
In the game’s two top-ranked countries defeats are met with mourning and inquisitions. The markets tank, questions are asked in parliament. ‘It’s because rugby here is a religion,’ we are told.
What these super powers of the sport sometimes forget is that the southern hemisphere does not hold a monopoly on emotion and passion when it comes to the oval ball.
A week ago France responded to the 11th anniversary of the Paris terrorist atrocities in quite brilliant fashion. Here, England stepped up and delivered for a stricken comrade.
Lewis Moody is one of the nation’s favourite rugby sons. There was not a dry eye anywhere when he was diagnosed with motor neurone disease towards the end of last year.
So it was that England chose their marquee fixture, the visit of the All Blacks, to throw an arm round a mate and let him know how much they love him.
First, they invited him to present the jerseys to the team. Then, as the sides ran onto the pitch, they asked him to deliver the match ball.
England players, to a man, wore boots dedicated to him and the MND cause he is campaigning so heroically for. Then, when the All Blacks lined up to perform the Haka, came the moment to send shivers up the spine.
Moody was beckoned to join the England team and stand at the tip of an arrow formation to greet the traditional Maori challenge.
As the New Zealanders took up their positions, the arrow became a V-formation, just as it had before England won the 2019 World Cup semi-final between the two nations in Yokohama.
Twickenham exploded with noise, at which point the All Blacks knew what was coming. Because the moment reminded them of themselves, in Johannesburg in August.
You remember the occasion, Ellis Park at the start of the Greatest Rivalry series, all of South Africa rooting against the men in black.
Ardie Savea pulled ‘flag-bearer’ Fitzpatrick into the All Black line for the anthems, wrapping an arm around the legend’s shoulders. It was an iconic moment which super-charged the All Blacks. Five tries to one later they had the most emphatic of wins.
Wind forward to Twickenham on a bright November afternoon and much the same unfolded.
From first minute to last England plugged into that emotional charge, dominating New Zealand physically, led by Ben Earl and his world record 32 carries for 146 yards. The number eight was also England’s leading tackler.
A team that stank out the Six Nations, delivering the country’s worst campaign for 50 years, did not merely win its fifth straight match, it took apart the ‘mighty’ ABs.
“We were complacent, we were arrogant and we were stupid,” the radio host had complained after Wales. What then of this? Only once before (in 1998) had New Zealand lost five times in a calendar year. This was the fifth of 2026.
“We were miles off, well short,” All Blacks boss Dave Rennie admitted. “If you look at the stats, well beaten in almost every number. I’m not going to hide from then fact we weren’t good enough and I’m a big part of that.
“Against Wales, the only thing we lacked was our finish. I said we let the country down. But we were way worse tonight. We need to work out why.”
If one moment summed up this lop-sided contest it was three minutes from time when Scott Barrett carried the ball and was hit with such velocity by Ollie Chessum that he was lifted off both feet and driven back before being dumped on the turf.
New Zealand were all over the shop. Scrappy, sloppy, uncharacteristically inaccurate. As a way to mark Beauden Barrett’s 150th Test cap it was, frankly, lamentable.
Will Jordan, the nation’s record try-scorer, didn’t touch the ball for 26 minutes then dropped his first pass. Tupou Vaa’i ran into contact and tamely coughed up the pill.
By half-time New Zealand had made four times more handling errors than their opponents. By the 68-minute mark they had coughed up 12 turnovers. For a long time Earl had more carrying metres than their entire team.
This is what pressure from shock jocks and an over-expectant public can do. In good times a nation’s support is invaluable, when the going gets tough even more so.
Rennie and his players have another week in London before they return to the scene of this horror show for another go. “This will be a really tough week for them,” said Fitzpatrick, rather stating the obvious.
For England, this is the best of times. They again started fast, just as they had against Australia and Japan, and kept their foot down right to the end.
They were ahead on five minutes, had their bonus point on 42 and, by the time their Pom Squad arrived – the likes of Ellis Genge and George Martin – they were operating at a different level.
Players who have not always brought their best to the international environment are suddenly firing. Henry Slade played with such poise and control, Cadan Murley, a late replacement for Tommy Freeman, was everywhere. To name just two.
England even got their post-match messaging right, leaving no opportunity for accusations of arrogance.
“Were you expecting more from New Zealand after Cardiff?” Fitzpatrick asked Genge, pitch side, on ITV. The big prop paused and cracked a smile.
“You don’t want to sound like a helmet,” he said.
England are content to leave the sound bites to others, particularly that bloke with the mic in Auckland who, about now, is almost certain to be self-combusting.