flag
back Back
Fans decide if Arsenal trading Arsene Wenger’s joy for Mikel Arteta’s results is worth the price
Arsene Wenger looks on from the bench during Arsenal v Burnley in the 2017/18 Premier League season and Mikel Arteta applauds fans after the Arsenal v Hull City game in the 2026/27 Premier League 2026/27 season
Credit: Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC/Julian Finney via Getty Images

TalkingPoints users have issued a clear verdict on the growing debate surrounding whether Mikel Arteta’s pragmatic approach to delivering trophies is worth Arsenal abandoning Arsene Wenger’s brand of football.

Wenger was renowned throughout the footballing world for bringing a hugely entertaining style of play to north London during his 22 years in charge of the Gunners. The Frenchman also led Arsenal to vast success in the early phase of his reign, but that success did not follow the club’s move to Emirates Stadium in 2006.

It took until the 2025/26 season with Arteta at the helm for Arsenal to win the Premier League for the first time since Wenger oversaw the legendary Invincibles during 2003/04. Wenger won a total of three Premier League titles with Arsenal, along with seven FA Cup winners’ medals – the most of any manager in history.

TalkingPoints

Which style of football do you prefer watching? Mikel Arteta’s more cautious approach or Arsene Wenger’s attacking style?

Give us your thoughts…

The FA Cup was the first trophy that Arteta won in charge of Arsenal in 2019/20 after he replaced Wenger’s successor Unai Emery in December 2019. But it took Arteta years to finally get Arsenal over the Premier League hurdle, during which he changed their style of football to favour pragmatism to get the job done.

Rival fans and pundits have since taken to frequently accusing Arsenal of being a team that favours trying to win free-kicks and corners to exploit their set-piece expertise. Arteta and his coaching team have also made Arsenal one of the best teams defensively in Europe, with the Gunners conceding a league-low 27 goals en route to the 2025/26 Premier League title and five goals through the first 10 games of the 2026/27 season.

Arteta’s methods have also seen Arsenal win nine of their opening 10 Premier League games, and only their 2-2 draw away to German giant Bayern Munich prevents the north Londoners from matching PSG and Real Madrid on points at the top of the Champions League 2026/27 league phase table after the first four games.

And yet the success that Arteta has brought back to north London has not been met with praise. Instead, a debate rages over how Arteta’s Arsenal play what many brand ‘boring’ football, with some football pundits and rival fans even calling the Gunners ‘unwatchable’ given their ability to grind out 1-0 wins when needed.

The situation in N5 has thus sparked the broader debate over whether Arteta’s pragmatic football is worth Arsenal abandoning the free-flowing attacking play that Wenger won the praise of neutrals for. For many TalkingPoints users, the answer would be no, albeit with the caveat that Arteta’s style is winning trophies.

Mikel Arteta yells instructions during the Arsenal v Hull City game in the Premier League 2026/27 season
Photo by Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC via Getty Images

In a recent Talk Arsenal post on TalkingPoints discussing what approach fans would prefer between Arteta’s more cautious approach and Wenger’s attacking style, many highlighted how the latter was “obviously” the approach they would prefer to watch. Even neutral fans enjoyed watching Arsenal under Wenger, especially when compared to Arteta’s style, but they also concede that it was not necessarily a successful approach.

One TalkingPoints user wrote: “It depends on what you want really! Wenger’s team was box office, but they could also lose 6-0 on a really bad day.” Another TalkingPoints user also said: “Wenger’s, obviously. Nobody enjoys Arteta’s football, but it wins football matches.”

The struggle between Arsenal playing enjoyable football and winning is not lost on neutral fans, with one noting: “Wenger’s, for sure, but that’s coming from a neutral. If I were an Arsenal fan, I would prefer to win games more regularly, as Arteta is doing, regardless of the playing style.”

One even claimed: “Wenger, obviously. I’m not watching an Arsenal game under Arteta for fun. But if I were an Arsenal fan, I would pick whatever gets wins.”

It is not only neutral fans who accept that Arteta is having to abandon playing attractive football more regularly to win Arsenal titles. An Arsenal fan on TalkingPoints also suggested: “Wenger’s, of course. But at the same time, I don’t miss the days of being bullied and battered every time we came up against a big side.”

TalkingPoints

Mikel Arteta was reportedly close to becoming Newcastle boss in 2019… where do YOU think Arsenal would be if he chose St James' Park? 🤔

Focusing only on the Premier League, Wenger enjoyed a strong record against Chelsea in his early years with Arsenal, after going unbeaten in 17 games from 1997 until 2005. But Wenger only then beat Chelsea home or away five times throughout his subsequent 28 meetings with the Blues between 2004 and 2018.

From 2004 until Wenger’s retirement in 2018, he also only oversaw six wins in 29 Premier League matches against Manchester United and 10 wins in 29 matches against Liverpool. Following Manchester City’s cash-laden rise to top, Wenger’s Arsenal also only beat the Cityzens three times in 15 games from 2011 to 2018.

Arteta also initially struggled against top teams as he rebuilt Arsenal, but has since made the Gunners one of the toughest nuts to crack in the Premier League. The Spaniard boasts nine wins and four draws from 15 top-flight games against Chelsea, and suffered his only defeats to the west London outfit in 2019 and 2021.

Similarly, Arteta has overseen eight wins and two draws from 13 Premier League games against Manchester United, with his Arsenal players only losing to the Red Devils in 2021, 2022 and 2026 (in what was an upset at Emirates Stadium).

Arteta only boasts four wins and five draws from 14 Premier League matches against Liverpool, but he has only suffered one defeat through Arsenal’s past nine games against the Reds since the start of the 2022/23 season.

Manchester City remain Arteta’s toughest top-tier domestic opponent, however, with just two wins and three draws to seven defeats in 12 Premier League games against Cityzens. That said, Manchester City have only beaten Arteta’s Arsenal once in their last six top-flight meetings, showing the strength of the Spaniard’s approach to getting the Gunners results a more attractive style of play may not produce.

You may like

Mikel Arteta confirms his dream next Arsenal agreement

footballtransfers.com 2 days ago

Arsenal made me miserable and didn’t value me - it hurt to leave

football.london 1 day ago

Mikel Arteta sends firm instructions to Newcastle fans about Bruno Guimaraes

football365.com 2 days ago

5 managers Watford FC must eye up ASAP after Dionisi sack ft ex-Arsenal coach

footballleagueworld.co.uk 1 hour ago

What Mikel Arteta really thinks about Mauricio Pochettino taking the Man Utd job

football.london 1 day ago

Mikel Arteta provides David Raya injury update after Arsenal’s 2-2 draw with Newcastle

arsenalinsider.com 18 hours ago

FPL notes: Raya + Hall injury latest, Saliba unused again

fantasyfootballscout.co.uk 16 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE: Alex Scott to Arsenal transfer claim dismissed as ‘so far off the mark’

footballtransfers.com 1 day ago

Fabrizio Romano reports whether ‘Arsenal are open to selling’ Martin Zubimendi to Chelsea

teamtalk.com 2 days ago

Arsenal set for 'record-breaking' deal for next South American wonderkid: report

fourfourtwo.com 2 days ago