Back
There is something I want to make absolutely clear following Celtic’s latest game: Martin O’Neill has every right to make his own decisions about team selection, substitutions and the management of his squad.
He is the manager, after all. He sees the players every day, understands their physical condition and knows what he wants from individual footballers. I am not questioning his authority.
However, I am questioning his judgement when it comes to the wider consequences of certain decisions, particularly at a time when Celtic desperately need stability.
At the end of the game, Martin O’Neill was asked about the absence of Haissem Hassan from the squad and the rather curious decision not to introduce Kasper Høgh, even during the closing stages. His explanation was that both players would get their opportunity on Thursday.
Good. At least he has clarified the situation. But I cannot help wondering why we needed this clarification in the first place.
Let me explain.
Celtic are currently operating in an environment where absolutely everything surrounding the club is being scrutinised, dissected and, quite often, deliberately misrepresented.
There is chatter, speculation, rumours and plenty of people apparently desperate to discover the next internal crisis.
Some of it may have a basis in reality; some of it is nothing more than football gossip dressed up as inside information. And this is precisely why Martin O’Neill needs to be particularly careful.
We have already witnessed the ridiculous suggestion that Kasper Høgh was supposedly “raging” because he was not introduced from the bench. Based on what, exactly? What evidence was presented? As far as I can see, absolutely nothing substantial.
One person’s opinion suddenly becomes a talking point, and before long, people are discussing a supposedly unhappy player as though somebody has confirmed an actual dressing-room problem.
This is how these stories develop.
A decision is made, somebody invents an interpretation, another person repeats it, and suddenly we have an entirely different narrative surrounding Celtic. I am not prepared to accept every piece of gossip as fact. Nor should anybody else.
However, I also believe that the manager must understand the atmosphere surrounding his club. When there is already chatter about certain players, leaving them out of the squad without a convincing explanation creates unnecessary questions.
It gives people opportunities to join dots, whether those dots actually belong together or not. And that brings me to Hassan.
I genuinely find the decision to leave him out of Saturday’s squad particularly questionable, especially considering the discussions and speculation preceding the game. Rumours about what O’Neill did and didn’t say at a corporate event continue to swirl.
I am not suggesting that every player must be selected simply because supporters or journalists expect it or because people are talking. That would be ridiculous. But football management is about much more than choosing eleven starters and a few substitutes.
It is also about managing relationships, expectations, confidence and the overall atmosphere within the dressing room.
Sometimes a decision can be perfectly understandable from a footballing perspective but incredibly damaging from a communication perspective. That is something an experienced manager should recognise.
Martin O’Neill cannot afford to be naive about the media environment surrounding Celtic.
I have enormous respect for Martin, of course.
His experience, his history in football and his understanding of Celtic should be beyond question. He has been around this game long enough to know precisely how stories are manufactured, how certain journalists operate and how quickly a relatively insignificant incident can become a headline.
The media vultures do not need much encouragement. Give them a little opening and they will happily turn it into an entire narrative. A player is not selected? There must be a problem. A player remains on the bench? He must be unhappy. A substitution does not happen? Something must be going on behind the scenes.
And before we know it, we are discussing dressing-room unrest rather than Celtic’s football.
I am not suggesting that the manager should select players to keep journalists happy. Absolutely not! That would be an absurd way to run a football club. But there is a considerable difference between making independent footballing decisions and unnecessarily creating situations that invite speculation.
Celtic have enough problems to address without supplying the media with fresh ammunition.
What worries me most is the timing. We have been through enough uncertainty, managerial changes, disappointing performances and discussions about the direction of the club.
We do not need another unnecessary distraction. We need players concentrating on football, supporters concentrating on supporting the team and a manager providing clarity and direction.
We certainly do not need a situation where every omission becomes a potential indication of another internal disagreement.
That is why Thursday matters.
Martin has publicly indicated that Hassan and Kasper Høgh will get their opportunity. I expect him to follow through. Not because the media have demanded it, not because somebody has started a ridiculous rumour, but because he himself has raised expectations by explaining the situation in that way.
He cannot afford to make the same mistake twice.
If there are legitimate footballing reasons why either player could not feature yesterday, that is cool. But if they are available and ready, then I want to see them involved. These are not just players, they are multi-million pound assets and if we’re writing them off because of dressing room politics or whatever then this club is in more trouble than we think.
Celtic need their squad players to feel valued, trusted and part of the project. Competition for places is healthy; unnecessary uncertainty is not. And let me make another point: I do not want Martin O’Neill to become so preoccupied with avoiding criticism that he stops making brave decisions.
That is not what I am asking for.
But he is experienced enough a manager to understand that every decision has consequences, both on and off the pitch. There is a difference between being decisive and being careless about the message your decisions send.
For me, Celtic are at a stage where we need calm leadership, clear communication and a united dressing room. We cannot afford to let outside noise become another problem inside the club. The manager must protect his players, protect the atmosphere around the team and, above all, protect Celtic’s interests.
The media will always look for a story. That is their business. Some will report responsibly, while others will happily turn speculation into sensationalism. We cannot control what they write, but we can certainly avoid making their job easier.
My message to Martin O’Neill is straightforward: make your footballing decisions, stand by them and explain them when necessary.
But think carefully about the wider implications.
You are experienced enough to know that Celtic are never simply another football club in the eyes of the media. Everything is magnified, every omission is questioned and every little incident can become another opportunity to manufacture controversy.
We have enough battles to fight. I want to see Hassan and Kasper Høgh involved on Thursday. I want to see the players concentrating on football, and I want to see Martin O’Neill taking control of the narrative rather than allowing unnecessary questions to dominate the conversation.
Celtic need leadership, not another self-inflicted distraction. And Martin O’Neill, of all people, should know better than to give the media vultures an open goal.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News