Back
Besides the announcement of the new James Bond and the launch of a new GTA franchise game this week, there is one more thing hitting the headlines, and that’s the possible plan to remove the three o’clock blackout on a Saturday, which forbids any domestic football shown live on a Saturday at that time. So would Carlisle benefit from such a move?
Let’s have a look at the rule to start with. Introduced in 1960 to be later agreed upon in 1964, the rule means between 2:45pm and 5:15pm on Saturdays that domestic matches in that zone can not be televised, enforced by Article 48 of the UEFA Statutes and imposed by the English and Scottish football associations; however, it is only enforced if 50% of fixtures in the top two divisions are scheduled to kick off at 3pm.
That is why in international breaks you are able to watch League One, League Two, National League, the National League North/South and so on in that time zone. As the top two divisions don’t play.
The only exception is the FA Cup final and the 2019–20 and 2020–21 seasons when the global pandemic coronavirus led to lockdowns and long-term restrictions on mass crowds.
The law was championed by Bob Lord, the chairman of Burnley FC at the time. His concerns and many others’ concerns at the time were what was going to happen to the club’s income. Remember, lower division clubs at that time had next to no sponsorship revenue, no broadcasting deals and no merchandise sales, just matchgoing supporters, so the idea of the biggest clubs getting richer and richer aswell as taking away matchgoing fans and plonking them in front of a TV was a serious scare.
The first TV deal came in the summer of 1983; the BBC and ITV struck a joint two-year deal worth £5.2 million (£2.6m per season) to broadcast 10 live matches a season (five per channel) across the entire 92-club Football League, and after administrative cuts, each First Division club received roughly £35,000 to £40,000 per year, while Fourth Division sides got a fraction of that. In today’s money that’s worth roughly £141,919 for each top division club
Now let’s look at all current TV deals
Now these deals don’t even cover cup competitions, or at least not all, and just stop for a moment and look at the figures again and look at what the deals mean. The Premier League is generating £6.7 billion in domestic rights, and they don’t even show all the fixtures; it’s crazy!
Now what would you expect, a dip in attendance or an increase? Well, when you look at average attendances, it points to an increase. Take the fifth and sixth tiers, for example; the national league pre-covid averaged just over 1,900 and now averages 2,860, and the national league north/south now averages over 1,300 compared to pre-covid, where they were looking at 850.
However, many could point the finger at the fact some big clubs have fallen into the national league in recent years, like Southend, York and Carlisle United bringing the average attendance across the board up, but let’s look at Carlisle’s attendances when televised at home and when not.
The blues have been televised nine times this season at home, three of which were 3pm kick-offs. Here’s the list with the numbers.
*3pm Kickoffs
Now I know that some might read that and say, ‘So what’s the big deal? A few hundred don’t bother turning up; Carlisle can handle that.”Well, that may be, but smaller clubs on average lose 30 to 40% of gate receipts when televised for a standard league game; just think about that. Just take a moment to think about the financial consequences for small clubs like Barrow.
Now I know there are plenty more talking points, but I don’t want to drag on numbers for too long; perhaps on another piece
So where do I stand on this debate? Well, the reality is this: it’s inevitable that the 3pm blackout will be scrapped. Why? They can’t even punish the biggest cheats in English football history in Manchester City, so why should I trust the integrity of rich men in suits who pretend to care about the football pyrimaid? In fact, a book I’ve been reading recently put it perfectly: “The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.” – George Orwell, Animal Farm.
To anyone who doesn’t understand why I’ve used that quote here, it is, when you look at who’s in charge of English football or football in general and its divisions, what do you see? Do you see hard-working fans with a pint and pie in either hand with a scrolled-up programme in their pocket, or do you see a grinning, suited and booted, bought-out businessman controlled by foreign “investment” pretending to care about others? I know what I see.
Now I don’t mean to generalise all businessmen and women involved in football, and no, I don’t think having your average Joe running a football division is a good idea, but when I hear directors, CEOs, chairmen and so on coming out all guns and blazing just to never mention the issue again, it just fills me with disappointment, and I think you’re all the same
Look at when they changed the FA Cup a few seasons ago; every club outside the Premier League came out in “disgust”. What happened? Ermm, let me think… Yeah, nothing. Why? Because money talks, and the monopoly empire these people have over these smaller clubs leaves no choice but to give into the money-grabbing, self-entitled racketeers
That’s why it ultimately doesn’t matter what I, you and others think; the decision will be made when the money is presented and the classic “where showcasing smaller clubs to a wider network” statement comes out.
So do I think Carlisle would benefit? Well, yes, obviously they would; the extra income would make the club richer, of course, but for me it’s the smaller clubs that average 800 to 1,000 crowds I fear, for most of them are there because their favourite prem team isn’t on TV and they have nothing much to do at 3pm on a Saturday. These clubs simply can’t afford to lose 200 – 300 fans
So here’s a thought to leave you with: how about the rich who Let’s be honest, make things worse most of the time, stop lining their pockets with every penny they can get from the public, and LEAVE OUR GAME ALONE!