flag
back Back
Nick Mallett’s theory for Rassie’s rant: World Rugby must find a ‘better way’ for coaches to vent frustrations
Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus and an inset of former coach Nick Mallett.
Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus and an inset of former coach Nick Mallett.

Nick Mallett has offered a theory on Rassie Erasmus’ rant, saying that the Springboks coach’s frustrations with World Rugby had been ‘building up’ before it finally burst.

Erasmus went on a circa five-minute rant about the officiating in South Africa’s defeat to France and questioned whether it reached the point of match-fixing while he also criticised the disciplinary processes, claiming that the Northern Hemisphere nations are treated differently.

Those comments have led to a third ban since 2021 for the head coach, which means he will not be allowed to take part in any matchday activities for the next six Springboks matches.

Nick Mallett: “World Rugby aren’t providing answers quickly enough”

Mallett did not excuse Erasmus’ remarks but did express his sympathy for his former back-rower, who he believes is frustrated with World Rugby and the lack of transparency and brevity of the feedback coaches receive.

The game’s governing body only allows for coaches to meet with matchday officials in the build-up to Test matches if both nations’ head coaches are present, while they have reduced the number of clips coaches can submit for review after a match to just five. This, plus the contrast in Tadhg Furlong and Jan-Hendrik Wessels’ bans, is another source of frustration, according to Mallett.

“What we’ve got to do is we’ve got to look at the reasons first of all and how can the situation be improved from a coaching perspective, because obviously it’s like a bubble bursting; it’s a frustration that’s built up over other issues,” the ex-Springboks boss said on the Talking Boks podcast.

“The issue with Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Tadhg Furlong, and that frustrated Rassie. So World Rugby must understand that what they’re requiring the coaches to do is not satisfactory – not in a professional era like this.

“The coaches need to have answers as quickly as possible so that they can then transfer that opinion from World Rugby of a referee’s decision to the players in that week and make sure that they don’t do it again in the following game so that they give away fewer penalties.

“What is incredibly frustrating for a coach is if you are coaching the right way, like for example, our scrum issues, I’ve very seldom seen Rassie get as frustrated as he was at that conference when he said: ‘We don’t F-ing walk around’ because he knows how much work has been put into that and we are trying to coach our players to play within the laws.”

Not the first time the bubble has burst

It’s not the first time that the bubble has burst for Erasmus with Mallett citing the unpunished high tackle by Owen Farrell in the defeat to England back in 2018. He believes that World Rugby aren’t providing a good enough platform or channel for the coaches to get answers or clarity on the officiating which has led to these outbursts.

“Remember that high tackle by Farrell, when Gardner was the referee, and Rassie did that video with Andre Esterhuizen and the tackle bag… he was taking the mickey out of World Rugby and the disciplinary situation,” the former coach continued.

“So what I think has to happen is that there has got to be a better way in which the coaches can vent frustration without necessarily hanging the referees out to dry.

“That was what they were able to do by sending a lot of clips in after every game and obviously the referee manager then has to reply to all those clips. It does require a lot of work, but Rassie is someone who does an enormous amount of work. So if he has all these clips and he sends them to World Rugby, he wants a reply from it and when he doesn’t get a reply in the Lions series, he is so frustrated that then the bubble bursts and he has one of these vents.

“So it seems to be the process, World Rugby’s process of allowing coaches to get an answer and to admit that ‘we got this wrong’. If someone says that, at least the coach can go back to his players and say: ‘They’re not going to mess it up next time, guys, we lost that game because they didn’t spot these knee-drop tackles and it’s going to be cleared up next time’.”

He added: “But I think that Rassie doesn’t feel that there is that ability to get to World Rugby, to get to their referees. To explain this has been an unfair situation, and that bubbles over. It is so frustrating for him that he just says it as it is.”

If he says 16, there were 16

Erasmus’ biggest complaint was the 16/17 knee-drop tackles by French players at the Stade de France and Mallett is certain that the number the current head coach cited is accurate.

“If Rassie says there are 16, there are 16; you don’t need to see them. Of 16, maybe five or six will be simultaneous to the tackle… That’s what the referee was saying,” he argued.

Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.

“He said: ‘I thought it was simultaneous,’ but I’ve seen a number of clips already, four or five in that game, where the guy’s already on his knee prior to making the tackle. So Rassie is dead right.

“He’s right about what he says, but he’s wrong about the inference of match-fixing and missing things on purpose.”

You may like

Winter success for Spalding duo

spaldingvoice.co.uk 7 hours ago

Why Damian McKenzie has become a vital cog in the All Blacks' attack

rugbypass.com 1 hour ago

Jasper Wiese banned by World Rugby with immediate effect

ruck.co.uk 1 day ago

Cameron Bancroft’s turn now. Looks like seven more Australia players will be getting 12-month bans

kingcricket.co.uk 1 day ago

England Under-15s walk off pitch against Ireland in World Cup after racism allegation

The Guardian 3 weeks ago

Eccles leaves London Broncos after 14 years

BBC 7 hours ago

Brian O’Driscoll admits Rassie Erasmus has a point

ruck.co.uk 4 hours ago

Malcolm Marx faces potential ban as France incident emerges

ruck.co.uk 11 hours ago