flag
back Back
Worse than Kilman: £36m West Ham flop will never wear the shirt again

Angus is an experienced football journalist at Football FanCast, specialising in Premier League reporting, opinion writing and in-depth football analysis. Since graduating from Southampton Solent University in 2022, he has developed extensive experience covering the English game, producing thousands of articles across a wide range of clubs and competitions.  

Before joining Football FanCast, Angus led VAVEL's Brighton & Hove Albion department, gaining valuable experience in club-specific reporting and editorial leadership. He subsequently joined Football FanCast through Snack Media's academy, now part of Valnet, and has progressed into the publication's Opinions and Features team.
 

As one of Football FanCast's longest-serving writers, Angus has covered numerous major developments across the Premier League, combining breaking news experience with detailed features and considered opinions. His work draws on years of reporting to provide context behind performances, transfer activity and the wider issues shaping English football.

Max Kilman of West Ham United

West Ham United are at the start of a new chapter under Scott Parker, who has one objective in mind at the helm of the London Stadium side this season.

Before a ball was kicked this season, the Hammers were head and shoulders above their rivals in the Championship, tipped to win the title - or at the very least, confidently return to the big time.

However, Nuno Espírito Santo struggled to find balance in midfield and establish a secure defensive base. West Ham have the fiercest attack in the division, but they find themselves ninth, outside the play-off zone, after 15 games.

nuno-west-ham-premier-league (2)

At the back, something needs to change, and as skipper, Max Kilman needs to take responsibility.

Max Kilman's West Ham struggles

Kilman cost a pretty penny two years ago, the ball-playing defender signed from Wolverhampton Wanderers for a hefty £40m.

West Ham have put plenty of effort into strengthening their outfit over the years, but there's no question that the departure of David Moyes has created a landslide in form and a deterioration of culture which has thrown the Hammers into the Championship.

max-kilman-west-ham
REUTERS/Jason Cairnduff

Kilman is a talented defender, but he hasn't been in fine fettle this season. The 29-year-old lacked clarity and composure in the duel last season, and he has been less than convincing in front of Mads Hermansen's goal this term.

There's no question that Kilman and co haven't looked convincing at the London Stadium this season, but there's a strong case to be made that the lack of a reliable and robust midfield has been the crux of this stuttering Irons season.

Indeed, he is talented enough that he might turn things around under Parker's wing and become a focal defensive presence at the London Stadium once again.

The same can't be said for another big-money West Ham centre-back, though. This star needs axeing once and for all.

West Ham flop must never wear the shirt again

West Ham might have the most ferocious frontline in the Championship, but there's no question that they lacked the kind of balance needed under Nuno's wing to leap back into the big time.

Top-scoring Teams in the Championship

Club

League Position

Goals Scored

West Ham

9th

37

Norwich

12th

32

Middlesbrough

2nd

30

Southampton

7th

29

Birmingham

1st

28

Well, while Parker has been tasked with rebuilding the culture in east London and striking a kind of balance from head to toe that hasn't been seen at the London Stadium for over a year now, it's clear that West Ham must not recall those currently playing out on loan, with Jean-Clair Todibo surely finished in the English capital as he struggles out on loan with Lens.

Todibo, 26, joined West Ham from OGC Nice for £36m in 2025 and failed to establish himself as a convincing defender in the Premier League efore sliding with his team into the second tier.

Hot-headed and lacking the kind of clarity that West Ham needed as they fought and failed to stave off the threat of relegation last season, Todibo was loaned out after falling out of favour under Nuno's wing.

Todibo is six games into a loan spell with Lens back in Ligue 1 which has thus far left plenty to be desired; six games in, he has lost 56% of his ground battles and there have already been whispers that the French side hope to cancel his short-term stint in January - albeit that's something they have refuted.

Jean-Clair Todibo for West Ham

In any case, Todibo does not have a part to play at West Ham this season, and there's no question that he should not be reintegrated if the Londoners do manage to work their way back into the Premier League in time for the new campaign.

At least Kilman is maintaining a semblance of control at the back with West Ham this season, diligently and duitfully rolling up his sleeves and helping the outfit back up.

Under Parker's wing, they need to wipe the slate clean.

You may like

Premier League winner suddenly thought 'what am I doing?' midway through playing in match

sportbible.com 2 hours ago

Sky Sports select and move Premier League Arsenal v Newcastle United match

themag.co.uk 4 hours ago

Italy legend reveals he would’ve loved to have played for Man Utd

unitedinfocus.com 2 hours ago

Arsenal consensus reached over £162m January transfers as two players wanted

football.london 7 hours ago

Ashley Young names Premier League star he wants Man Utd to sign

unitedinfocus.com 4 hours ago

Premier League sent clear 'justice' warning over Man City appeal after sponsor threat

Mirror 2 hours ago

Three Brentford fixtures selected for Sky Sports coverage

brentfordfc.com 4 hours ago

Sources: Premier League clubs alerted to Rudiger's Real Madrid contract situation

tribalfootball.com 3 hours ago