flag
back Back
The ten worst new Premier League signings so far this season - including Aston Villa & Sunderland flops

'I always chose to be here' - Bruno...

'No chance!' - Mainoo unimpressed by...

Comms Cam: Carra and Nev’s best bits...

Comms Cam: Carra and Nev react to Yoro...

FULL INTERVIEW: Man Utd CEO Omar...

Nev and Carra: Can Pochettino buck the...

Carra and Neville's preferred XI's

'What are you going to find?' - Poch...

Five things we learned from Poch's...

Soccer Saturday panel baffled by...

How has Fernandez's role impacted Man...

'It's been an incredible journey!' -...

Ranking the 10 worst new signings of the Premier League season so far - featuring bad buys from Aston Villa, Manchester United and Spurs.

Last week, to pass some time during the international break, we ranked the 10 best new signings of the Premier League season after the first 10 games - but while there were plenty of brilliant buys this summer, there were also quite a few very bad deals indeed.

Getty Images

Today, then, we’re going to rank the 10 worst signings of the 2026 summer transfer window so far. By the time you read this, some teams will have played their 11th match already - which slightly spoils the neatness of the title, and may well leave us with some egg on our faces if one of the players we’ve shamed below ends up putting in a brilliant performance on Saturday. But none of these players have worried us too much on that score so far.

We decided against including players who were signed more for their potential than their ability to impact results immediately – although a few of these players are still quite young – and we expect several of these signings to look rather better by the end of the campaign. For now, however, these are the 10 players who have struggled the most since their summer moves.

10. Caleb Yirenkyi – Coventry City (£25.5m from Nordsjælland)

We’ll start with a player we expected to perform far better after Coventry signed him for what was briefly a club record fee back in August. The Ghanaian midfielder is one of the most promising young prospects in African football, acquitted himself well at the World Cup, and it looked like the Sky Blues had pull off a coup when they snapped him up.

Yirenkyi has yet to find his feet, however, and has put in several error-strewn performances while struggling to handle the technical quality of opposing midfielders at this level. At just 20 years of age, we expect him to settle in and improve as time goes by, but he hasn’t made the step up so far.

9. Promise David – Brighton & Hove Albion (loan to buy for £22m from Union SG)

Getty Images

The good news for Brighton is that they’re only obligated to buy David if certain targets are met – and given that he’s made just four substitute appearances for them so far, it seems like they’re pretty conscious of that fact.

It may seem cruel to include him in this list if we’ve barely seen anything of him, but it’s probably worth wondering why the Canadian, who scored 37 goals over the past two seasons in Belgium, wasn’t even getting minutes while a number of attacking players were sidelined through injury. We can only assume that Fabian Hürzeler has not been impressed.

8. Taiwo Awoniyi – Coventry City (£9m from Nottingham Forest)

Awoniyi was signed as a proven Premier League player who could lead the line and chip in with the goals required to avoid relegation. Instead, he’s managing a shot on target at a rate of less than once every second game and has only hit the back of the net on a single, solitary occasion, in a 3-1 win over Sunderland. He’s being bullied by opposing markers and looks like a blunt instrument in the penalty area – Coventry sorely need him to find his form if they’re going to survive.

7. Andrey Santos – Manchester United (£50m from Chelsea)

Getty Images

To be honest, Santos hasn’t been that bad. Statistically, he’s been solid enough, if not necessarily inspiring. But he definitely hasn’t looked like a player worth spending £50m on, or like the cornerstone of a much-hyped midfield rebuild. He’s looked like a middling player worth half as much, which, incidentally, is how much Chelsea though he was worth – this was a massive overpay for a mediocre asset, albeit one with time to improve.

6. Daizen Maeda – Ipswich Town (£10m from Celtic)

If you want an indication of how large the gap between the Scottish Premiership and the Premier League has grown, just look at Maeda. Quite brilliant across the last couple of seasons at Celtic, Maeda has been miles out of his depth in England – a player who scored 35 and assisted 19 goals over the past two years has managed just one goal and no assists since signing for Ipswich, and hasn’t looked remotely likely to pump those numbers up any time soon. On a technical level, he just doesn’t look to be up to the task.

5. Kevin Danso – Sunderland (loan to buy for £22.5m from Spurs)

Getty Images

Prior to the first international break, Danso looked to have been a decent enough signing. Over the last month or two, however, his form has collapsed, culminating in the worst individual performance of any player all year – against Bournemouth, when he gifted a goal after five minutes and got himself a red card barely more than 10 minutes later. He was terrible in admittedly tricky fixtures against Manchester City and Brighton immediately before that, too, and Sunderland need to pray that this is just a blip.

4. Carl Rushworth – Coventry City (£30m from Brighton)

A third (and mercifully final) entry for Coventry, whose summer transfer business doesn’t look great so far. Rushworth was excellent on loan in the Championship and we can’t blame them for breaking their transfer record to sign him permanently, but their first-choice goalkeeper has found it much harder in the Premier League – his 54% save percentage is the worst in the top flight, and his post-shot xG prevented of -5.2 (a nerdy stat but more telling than save percentage) is also rock bottom. Simply put, Rushworth has been the worst number one in the league after 10 matches, and it isn’t that close.

3. Omar Marmoush – Tottenham Hotspur (loan to buy for £60m from Man City)

Getty Images

The good news for any Spurs fans who are getting a little worried about Marmoush, who is looking pretty overpriced after managing just one goal in his first 11 appearances for the club, is that some of his struggles can be explained away by a lack of service – he’s only been given 1.05xG’s worth of chances in the Premier League so far, and that’s not entirely his fault.

We saw not entirely, because the best forwards create their own chances and Marmoush hasn’t been doing that at all. He’s struggling to beat defenders one-on-one or to find space, and that’s been a major part of the problem. We though that Sávio was the problematic half of the deal with Manchester City. So far, we admit we were wrong.

2. Evann Guessand – Crystal Palace (loan to buy for £28m from Aston Villa)

Some outlets report that the purchase clause is obligatory, others that it’s an option. We hope for Crystal Palace’s sake that it’s the latter, because Guessand has offered nothing to a struggling side and has only played 131 minutes of football so far. What makes this such a bad signing is how predictable it was – Guessand wasn’t much better on loan from Aston Villa last season and has looked like a fish out of water ever since he arrived in the Premier League. This is a well that we can’t understand going back to.

1. Alejandro Garnacho – Aston Villa (loan to buy for £43m from Chelsea)

Getty Images

Another predictable disaster. The Argentine has cut a frustrated, stroppy and utterly ineffective figure at three consecutive clubs now, and while we acknowledge that there is at least talent in there (somewhere deep down), one has to wonder why Aston Villa would gamble so much money on a player who has been so poor in recent years, especially in the middle of a crucial rebuild.

The good news is that Villa definitely won’t be forced to sign him permanently at the end of the season, and they otherwise bought very well indeed. The bad news is that Garnacho is still stinking the place out for now. After the Harvey Elliott farce of last season, this is a club who should perhaps review their loan policy.

You may like

English Journalist Ranks 25 Greatest Footballers He’s Seen Live - Cristiano Ronaldo 3rd

givemesport.com 4 hours ago

The three players that surpassed 12km during Leeds United’s win over Chelsea

leedsunited.news 20 minutes ago

TRANSFER INTEREST: Arsenal and Liverpool linked with Stuttgart defender Finn Jeltsch

uknip.co.uk 5 hours ago

Why Keane is furious with Neville’s reaction to Man Utd defeat

unitedinfocus.com 1 hour ago

Arsenal's next five fixtures compared to Man City as Premier League title race takes crucial turn

football.london 10 hours ago

Arsenal receive new asking price in battle for striker wanted all over Europe

footballtransfers.com 5 hours ago

Rio Ferdinand Named 3 Liverpool Players He 'Hated' on the Pitch

givemesport.com 9 hours ago

Premier League release official statement on Leny Yoro red card against Liverpool

centredevils.co.uk 3 hours ago

Liverpool become third club to reach 700 Premier League wins

besoccer.com 1 hour ago

Nottingham Forest have an obvious replacement for Matz Sels in the Premier League

nottinghamforest.news 4 hours ago