flag
back Back
Celtic win and it’s a crisis – Rangers grind out results and it’s genius? The punditry double standard
Celtic win and it’s a crisis – Rangers grind out results and it’s genius? The punditry double standard

Barry Ferguson has just handed Celtic supporters a remarkable argument against the endless crisis narrative surrounding Martin O’Neill’s side.

Writing in Saturday’s Daily Record, the former Rangers captain argued that Derek McInnes does not need beautiful football. He needs results.

Meanwhile, Kris Boyd has been warning about a possible Celtic crisis despite the champions leading the Premiership.

Apparently, grinding out victories is an admirable quality at Ibrox. At Celtic Park, similar performances can become evidence of impending disaster.

Who exactly decides these standards?

Ferguson’s remarkable defence of Rangers

Ferguson’s latest column praises McInnes for understanding football’s fundamentals.

He believes Rangers should prioritise hard work, organisation and three points, even when their performances lack entertainment.

Fair enough.

There is nothing particularly controversial about a manager finding different ways to win.

However, why does that same understanding appear so difficult to extend to Celtic?

O’Neill has been navigating injuries, European commitments and demanding domestic fixtures while keeping his side at the summit.

Yet the criticism has been relentless.

Ferguson’s argument effectively confirms what Celtic supporters have been saying: winning matters, even when performances are imperfect.

It should not suddenly become a different sport when the team wears green and white.

Boyd’s crisis narrative deserves serious scrutiny

On 12 November, GlasgowWorld reported Kris Boyd’s assessment of Celtic’s title defence.

Boyd claimed a crisis seemed perpetually close and suggested the champions were making matches unnecessarily difficult.

He acknowledged their league lead. Nevertheless, his overall argument emphasised vulnerability and the encouragement Rangers could take.

Compare that with Ferguson’s message about the Ibrox club.

Rangers can scrap, battle, defend and take their opportunities. That represents sensible management.

Celtic can overcome difficult matches, remain top and collect points. Suddenly, we are discussing crisis management.

These are two different pundits, not one man contradicting himself. However, their contrasting messages demonstrate why supporters should scrutinise the standards applied to each club.

Celtic answered the critics on the pitch

Saturday’s 4-1 victory over St Mirren provided another useful reminder.

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain, Camilo Durán, Luke McCowan and Callum McGregor all scored as Celtic produced some excellent attacking football.

O’Neill’s side moved seven points clear before Rangers played Motherwell.

That advantage did not settle the title race, especially with Rangers holding games in hand.

But it was real.

Unlike the imagined trophies awarded for momentum, favourable fixtures and optimistic predictions.

Why Scottish football’s media should answer these questions

The Daily Record publishes Ferguson’s views. Sky Sports provides Boyd with a prominent platform.

Both are entitled to their opinions. Both are also entitled to challenge Celtic.

But their arguments deserve challenge in return.

The Daily Record, Scottish Sun, BBC Scotland, Sportscene, Sportsound and Clyde 1 Superscoreboard are influential parts of Scottish football’s media landscape. Their journalists and presenters do not all share one opinion.

Nevertheless, supporters are perfectly entitled to ask whether equivalent performances receive equivalent scrutiny.

A proper examination would compare headlines, pundit reactions and post-match assessments across both clubs.

It would also recognise that Boyd has criticised Rangers themselves. This is a criticism of the particular contrast in these comments, not proof that every broadcaster favours Rangers.

Celtic are not beyond criticism – far from it

There are legitimate questions surrounding Celtic’s recruitment, European performances and boardroom leadership.

Those issues deserve serious investigation.

However, demanding accountability from Celtic should never mean accepting a distorted picture of the title race.

McInnes deserves credit for improving Rangers.

Equally, O’Neill deserves recognition for keeping Celtic ahead while negotiating considerable challenges.

It is perfectly reasonable to criticise the quality of a victory. What is unreasonable is treating the same basic achievement as determination for one club and desperation for another without explaining the difference.

Ferguson wants Rangers judged by results.

Fine.

Then apply that principle to Celtic.

Because the league table does not award points for favourable punditry, imaginary momentum or newspaper optimism.

It awards them for winning football matches.

And, as Saturday’s result demonstrated, Celtic are still doing precisely that.

Key takeaways

  • Barry Ferguson argued that Rangers should prioritise winning over attractive football.
  • Kris Boyd previously highlighted Celtic’s vulnerability despite their league lead.
  • Celtic defeated St Mirren 4-1 and moved seven points clear before Rangers’ Saturday fixture.
  • The contrasting arguments raise legitimate questions about consistency in punditry.
  • Celtic’s genuine problems deserve scrutiny, but equivalent standards must apply to Rangers.

You may like

Rangers fans treated awfully as new image emerges from Fir Park ahead of Motherwell clash

rangersnews.uk 20 hours ago

Why Kevin Kelsy is not starting for Rangers vs Motherwell

rangersnews.uk 20 hours ago

BBC Sportscene pundit blasts Rangers as ‘awful’ milestone emerges vs Motherwell

rangersnews.uk 4 hours ago