Back
There’s a difference between having NFL tools and knowing how to use them. Sam Leavitt still has the arm and mobility that made me believe in his pairing with Lane Kiffin, but after watching him swing from forcing throws to passing up opportunities, I’m stepping back until the tape gives me a reason to reconsider.
Elsewhere, the tape is giving me plenty to get excited about. Charlie Becker is firmly in my top four, Boubacar Traore has moved ahead of Yhonzae Pierre, and Ty Benefield is making a push in a tight race at safety.
Below, I’ll get into who’s rising—and falling—in my latest Stock Five (plus two) scouting notebook.
I’m out on Sam Leavitt as an NFL prospect for now. And I say that as someone who wanted the Lane Kiffin pairing to work.
I’ve had my eye on Leavitt since he took Arizona State to the playoff in his first year as a starter. He’s a dynamic runner who can extend plays, and he has that loose, elastic arm that lets him snap the ball into tight windows or drive it downfield. After what we saw from Jaxson Dart and Trinidad Chambliss, I thought two years with Kiffin could turn Leavitt into a high NFL draft pick.
Early in the season, his legs covered up how quickly his eyes would drop. Too often, it was one read and go. When a lower-body injury forced him to play more from the pocket, I started to see some patience. In back-to-back wins over Mississippi State and Auburn, he completed 63 of 83 passes (75.9 percent) for 676 yards, seven touchdowns, and no interceptions. He was seeing the field more clearly, getting the ball out, and making better decisions. That was the version I thought Kiffin could build on.
Since then, it’s felt like watching a marriage fall apart one Saturday at a time. Against Alabama, the old habits crept back. Against Texas, two of his three picks came from trying to force something that wasn’t there.
He entered the Tennessee game with five red-zone interceptions. But in Knoxville, the pendulum swung the other way. He looked like a quarterback afraid to make the next mistake. He completed 27 of 39 passes for 222 yards, one touchdown, and no picks, but took eight sacks in a 27-13 loss. The protection had its problems, but on too many snaps, Leavitt had a chance to let it rip and instead held the ball until the pressure arrived.
Some of watching Leavitt reminds me of the frustration I felt watching Will Levis. The arm and mobility make you want to keep betting on the upside, but when does Leavitt learn which chances are worth taking, when to protect himself, and when the play is over? I needed to see that judgment consistently from him. Based on my conversations with people around Baton Rouge, I’d be surprised if this pairing lasted another year.
I took a little Carson Beck hiatus before his play at Miami brought me back. I’m taking one with Leavitt. A fresh start could help, and I’ll reconsider when the tape gives me a reason to.
In the meantime, I’d rather spend my time on LaNorris Sellers fighting against Georgia, Darian Mensah making big-time throws against Virginia Tech, and what CJ Carr and Drew Mestemaker have shown this season.
Can we just give Jeremiah Smith the Heisman already? My no. 1 prospect went for six catches, 165 yards (which accounted for 64 percent of Ohio State’s passing yards), and two touchdowns at Nebraska.
Then Charlie Becker went out in the late-afternoon window and made me wonder whether we’d already seen the two best prospects in this class before the night games even kicked off. Becker finished with six catches for 167 yards and a 74-yard touchdown in Indiana’s overtime loss to Washington. Despite the final result, it was another statement game for Becker in what’s become a statement season.