Back
France will meet South Africa in the Nations Championship final at Allianz Stadium next Sunday, a repeat of their meeting in Paris a week or so ago, the day after England and New Zealand go again for second place, and both rematches arrive with the old order between North and South turned upside down in the style of rugby they play.
The great Schalk Burger didn’t dress it up when speaking after South Africa’s 20-17 defeat to Ireland in Dublin on Saturday, a week on from losing 21-19 in Paris. The former Springbok flanker said “we’ve only got a maul and a scrum at the minute”, and he’s absolutely right; both Springbok tries at the Aviva came from the set piece, Morné van den Berg’s off a scrum and Malcolm Marx’s off a powerful driving maul, and the world champions have now lost back-to-back Tests for the first time since November 2022, when, of all sides, it was Ireland in Dublin and then France in Marseille.
Next Sunday they’ll be relishing another go at Les Bleus, this time in the final at Allianz Stadium, with England and New Zealand meeting for second place the day before. The Springboks, powered by outrage at perceived slights, will be revving up their engines like a bakkie on a dirt road.
What’s so striking about both rematches is how far the North and South hemispheres have swapped roles, because France and South Africa now sit at opposite ends of the rugby evolutionary scale and, unfortunately, neither side is particularly complete, but one of them has more than one fatal weakness.
For some time the common wisdom was that the North kicked, mauled and squeezed whilst the South ran it from everywhere. South Africa, of course, have always been the South’s great set-piece side and France the North’s great entertainers, but now both have been pushed into polarised extremes; the Springboks have a pack of continental proportions and no backline to speak of, whilst Les Bleus have a glorious backline that flows like an ocean but sits behind a tight five about as robust as a wet baguette, one that Argentina shoved all around the Stade de France on Saturday night.
And then there’s England. They beat New Zealand 37-12 yesterday, five tries to two, recording the biggest winning margin in the history of the fixture, with 64 per cent of the possession, twice as many carries, 100 to 50, and 551 metres to the 267 made by the All Blacks. That’s a northern side beating the All Blacks at what used to be the hallmark of their own brilliant game.
It’s a shame for many reasons that England were just short, because you want the two best sides in the tournament in the final and, putting my love of France to one side, England really have been one of them, especially in the last three weeks. They finished with the better points difference by a distance, but France’s try bonus point took them to 26, a point clear of England on 25.
England have the cattle and the forward game to put the Boks under real pressure and give their pack a few creaks; Ben Earl, brilliant off the base yesterday, carried 32 times, and a side that owns the ball and the game like that can take on the Springboks on their own physical terms. It would have been phenomenal to see Twickenham host South Africa in a final with England in it, but France’s second-half rally put paid to that.
Instead England get the All Blacks again on Saturday. Two wins on the bounce equals England’s longest winning run against New Zealand, and a third victory would be a first, at which point England are moving into the land of euphoria. Dave Rennie’s side need to stand up and make a statement after consecutive defeats to Wales and England, and it’s fair to say they haven’t shown anything like the best version of themselves on this tour.
As for the Boks, Burger’s diagnosis is about attacking fluency, and the numbers back him up completely; South Africa have made the second-most handling errors in the competition, and in one passage in Paris he counted nine forward carries in 11 phases. When the Boks are at their best there’s a connection between the lead carrier and the fly-half, with runners arriving at different angles and the 10 picking the hole the defence hasn’t covered, but against France and Ireland it was continual one-off runners lumbering into a set line, which never commits a second defender, so the men outside get no space and the attack becomes painfully narrow.
The harsh truth is there’s really no direction at 10, 12 and 13 right now. There’s plenty of talent in Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, and Damian de Allende and Jesse Kriel are both world-class performers, but with Rassie Erasmus out of the coaches’ box more of the game management falls on the fly-half than ever before. The midfield hasn’t found a shape to play off him, nor has he taken the right options, and South Africa win territory and then don’t know what to do with it, which is quite a turnaround for a side that ran in 81 tries last season under Tony Brown.
They’ll come back, have no doubt about that. Three defeats on the bounce would be almost unheard of for this group, the last time being in the 2021 Rugby Championship bio-bubble. Erasmus is banned from matchday rather than the selection meeting, though, and given the way South Africa are playing and what winning this trophy means to him, we wouldn’t put it beyond his sense of humour to pick a side with nine or ten props in it, just because it’s South Africa and we know how much he loves entertaining us with his little ruses.
Les Bleus, meanwhile, were miraculous at times against Argentina at the Stade de France last night, especially in the second half, but everything tight was borderline diabolical. Kalvin Gourgues was player of the match, with two tries and five conversions, as France opened the taps in the back division and scored five tries after the break to win 45-17.
But Argentina had 62 per cent of first-half possession and twice turned down shots at goal to scrummage again because they were melting France there. They beasted France on the floor, with François Cros, France’s ruck specialist, rested, and won seven turnovers, whilst the French maul, appalling against Fiji, was once again far too high and stalled repeatedly against the Argentinian defence. It was only when the scrums went uncontested late on, after Mayco Vivas’ red card, that France looked as if they had a scrum, which is ironic given nobody was pushing. Make no mistake, maul, breakdown and scrum are precisely the areas the Springboks excel in, and they’ll have a laser focus on them next Sunday.
Which is why this week is all about Jean-Baptiste Gros. The Toulon loosehead, one of the few world-class props France have, withdrew before the Argentina game amid reports that he’d miss the rest of the tournament, and whilst word is he might just make it back for the final, it’s far from certain. With Wilco Louw and Thomas du Toit to face, after a night when Rodrigue Neti was crumpled in half more than once by Los Pumas, Gros is the player Les Bleus can least afford to be without. Cros, too, surely has to come back into the side to own the collisions and sweep up after the horrendous ruck mess of Saturday night.
There’s thinking to do at fly-half as well. Matthieu Jalibert was really good in parts on Saturday night, but he wasn’t quite the razor-sharp, precision attacking laser we’ve seen for both Bordeaux and France over the last couple of years, and it would be optimistic to expect him to get up to speed so quickly after two months out with a serious thigh injury. It wouldn’t surprise us if Galthié started Maxime Lucu at 10 again, as he did in Paris, and used Jalibert as a bench option; that wouldn’t even cost France their 6-2 split, because Jalibert would simply take the replacement scrum-half’s slot, with Lucu able to drop back to nine, and Émilien Gailleton would stay on as the three-quarter cover.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
That brings us to the word exposure, because that’s precisely what informs next Sunday. You can mitigate attacking frailties and stop them being exposed; you can kick for territory, play to your strengths with your forwards and a very simple one-out running game, and get through a Test with a misfiring backline, which is more or less what the Springboks have done in losing by only two points in Paris and three in Dublin.
But in the primary set pieces and on the floor there’s no mitigation and nowhere to hide; the scrum, the maul and the breakdown are tested every single time they happen, and in the red-hot pressure of the Test cauldron, against a side that kicks for the corner and takes the maul or scrum option as often as South Africa do, those weaknesses will be exposed like nothing we’ve seen in this tournament. Get eviscerated there and France have no chance whatsoever against South Africa.
Nika Amashukeli won’t be making it any easier for France either. We understand he’ll referee the final, with the appointment to be confirmed on Monday, and he’s exacting about the technical detail at scrum and maul time; he knows his stuff when it comes to the tight. Georgians revere the scrum the way the French revere wine, so a French front row folding in front of him will go down just about as well as a bottle of Black Tower Riesling at a Bordeaux vintage wine tasting.
So France need to do some serious thinking if they’re going to repeat the win in Paris. Everything had to go right for them that night and it did; Antoine Dupont put in the performance of his career, Les Bleus won the aerial battle and they just about held on at the scrum despite conceding eight penalties. They were helped, too, by the Springboks playing some really dumb rugby at times, and they still only won by two. If Paris was the perfect storm for France, next Sunday night just might be a South African cyclone.
If France get Gros back and play for 80 minutes rather than the 40 they managed against Argentina, they might just survive it. But if they play like they did last night, they may as well not turn up, because South Africa will absolutely mince them, and all the rancour of the previous match in Paris will be forgotten forever.