Back
Hanyani Shimange has defended Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu ahead of the Ireland clash amid criticism of the fly-half’s performances.
The playmaker has been the go-to selection in the starting line-up for Rassie Erasmus after recovering from injury to feature in the Test match against Argentina prior to Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry Series.
Since then, he has started all but one of South Africa’s Test matches – the defeat to the Wallabies in Perth – but his performances have come under scrutiny this year after a blockbuster international season in 2025.
Legendary England scrum-half Ben Youngs is one of the pundits who has criticised his performances, particularly after an underwhelming shift in the defeat to France, where he was guilty of numerous errors with ball in hand. That display came off the back of a stunning showing in the 66-7 victory over Italy.
“I feel like with Sacha, there’s been so much chat and hype around him. I just don’t see it. I don’t see it at the level that people have hyped him up at. It’s the new shiny toy and everyone’s, ‘Oh wow, it’s amazing’,” Youngs said on the For the Love of Rugby podcast.
“He is when you play against Italy or a team like that, but I’ve yet to see it. Even in the Greatest Rivalry, there wasn’t a game where he dominated. There wasn’t a game where I was like, ‘Wow.’”
Fellow former England star Dan Cole argued that South Africa don’t need a superstar number 10 to dominate a match with the ‘well-oiled’ Springboks forward pack machine doing that job.
Shimange, AKA Shimmy, has responded to the criticism of Feinberg-Mngomezulu on the Verdict show, stating that this weekend’s Nations Championship clash against Ireland was a big opportunity for the playmaker to respond.
“I don’t know why he gets so much heat. This guy, he was untouchable last year, he’s been good this year,” he remarked.
“He is our number one 10, and because you get the ball a lot at 10, there might be one or two mistakes, but I suppose that’s the nature of the beast; he is the hero one day and he’ll learn from it.
“One thing about Sacha is he’ll recover quickly and learn from it and this is another massive opportunity for him this weekend.”
Reflecting on the defeat to Les Bleus in Paris, Shimmy believed that if the game were to be replayed, South Africa wouldn’t lose again.
“They would definitely win that game, and hopefully we meet France again,” he said, referencing a possible rematch on Finals Weekend at the Allianz Stadium in Twickenham next week.
“But a game of what-ifs for the Springboks. We lost the game; they won; they showed heart; they showed passion, but still the game of the week was Wales against New Zealand.”
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
One of the what-ifs for South Africa was Manie Libbok’s missed conversion after he replaced Feinberg-Mngomezulu in the latter stages of the second half, which would have levelled the scores. Libbok has subsequently been omitted from the matchday 23 for this weekend’s clash against the Irish, with Feinberg-Mngomezulu lining up across from Sam Prendergast after the Ireland fly-half was cleared to feature against the Springboks, having been cited for a hip-drop tackle on Fiji’s Peceli Yato – an outcome that Rassie Erasmus predicted in his explosive press conference that led to his six-match suspension.
The fly-half will be tasked with orchestrating another win in Dublin, a venue that hasn’t been a happy hunting ground for the men in Green and Gold as last year’s win at the ground was the first of its kind in 13 years.