flag
back Back
Man Utd: Carrick’s Future Remains Uncertain With Howe and Conte on Manager Shortlist
REUTERS/Phil Noble

Nov 9, 2026, 12:17 PM GMT

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account

Michael Carrick’s position at Manchester United remains uncertain following the 4-4 draw against Aston Villa on Sunday, GIVEMESPORT understands.

Man United considered sacking Carrick after they lost 4-1 to Como and 3-0 at home to Bournemouth in successive games, before deciding to give him until the international break to show an upturn in form.

United have since lost 2-0 at Chelsea in the Premier League, before they came from 2-0 down to beat Roma 3-2 in the Champions League on Tuesday, in what Carrick would have been hoping was a turning point.

The Red Devils got off to the worst possible start when they hosted Aston Villa at Old Trafford on Sunday, finding themselves 2-0 down after four minutes, and then 4-2 down after 53 minutes, but they twice reacted well to salvage a point in the dying seconds of the game.

Still, United have won just one Premier League match all season and lie in the relegation zone, with further boardroom talks now expected before they play again against Liverpool at Anfield a week on Sunday.

It has been calm at Carrington since the draw at Villa, but talks will take place to discuss the future of Carrick.

Should club chiefs decide that a change in the dugout doesn't need to be made, then GMS understands that one option is to add to the 45-year-old's coaching staff.

A Bar Chart Depicting Man Utd Under Carrick 202627 Record Including Won, Drawn and Lost

Aaron Danks is appreciated by the club, but he is also unlikely to leave Bayern Munich mid-season.

Danks worked under Carrick at Middlesbrough and is currently in charge of Bayern while Vincent Kompany recovers after collapsing, while he also had a two-game spell in caretaker charge of Aston Villa previously.

GMS also understands that United are unlikely to appoint another interim manager if they do decide to make a change during the international break, despite the success of Carrick in that role last term.

Which Managers Are in Contention to Replace Carrick if he Leaves?

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe looks on glumly

Eddie Howe is one of the leading contenders, with the out-of-work manager available to start the role immediately having decided to part ways with Newcastle United in the summer.

Julian Nagelsmann is also appreciated by people at the club and, like Howe, is available after leaving his role as Germany manager in the summer.

A Bar Chart Depicting Career Win % in Previous Jobs Including Conte, Nagelsmann and Howe

Meanwhile, Unai Emery looks set to sign a new deal at Aston Villa having had his admirers on the United board, while GMS understands Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler doesn't want to leave, and his contract has no release clause.

And former Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino was considered prior to Ruben Amorim’s appointment, but has since signed a new deal with the USMNT.

Premier League Era Before or After

Did it happen before or after?

Round 1 of 9

Other options include Antonio Conte and Simone Inzaghi, who is the current head coach of Saudi Pro League club Al-Hilal.

Man United will only need to make that decision if they choose to sack Carrick, with the upcoming talks during the break crucial to what happens next.

You may like

Man Utd: January move for ‘the answer’ to defensive woes gathers pace – personal terms ‘not an is...

teamtalk.com 1 hour ago

Micah Richards puts Kobbie Mainoo in seven-player Man Utd tier

unitedinfocus.com 3 hours ago

Roy Keane’s daughter makes rare trip to Old Trafford… to cheer on Aston Villa against her Man Utd...

The Sun 3 hours ago

Aston Villa eye audacious January move for Barcelona star

managingbarca.com 3 hours ago

Man Utd ‘fools’ for considering new manager plan as ‘new favourite’ emerges amid ‘post-match antics’

football365.com 2 hours ago

Aston Villa 2.0 have made progress under Emery – but the Man United collapse exposed what’s missing

astonvilla.news 22 minutes ago

Goalkeeper displayed highest IQ ever to let indirect free-kick go straight in

sportbible.com 3 hours ago

Arsenal flying start after 10 games ranks among best ever in Premier League history

football365.com 3 hours ago

Who would buy Man Utd and for how much if the Glazers decide to sell?

football365.com 6 hours ago