Back
What makes a club to be well-run remains something up for debate; whether it be a team that consistently challenges for trophies and aspires for glory in a sustainable enough manner or one that repeatedly punches above its weight.
The riches of the Premier League has seen many clubs take a gamble in terms of their finances to try and win that lottery; often to detrimental effect.
That is balanced by more forward-thinking and progressive clubs creating sustainable models that slowly build towards becoming top-flight stalwarts, notably Brentford and Brighton and Hove Albion.
Ambition is one thing but folly is another and working out how well run a club is can be difficult but we have consulted AI chatbot ChatGPT to determine the top 25 best-run clubs in England.
Sneaking into 25th on AI’s list of the 25 best run clubs in English football are Rotherham United with what ChatGPT describes as as a result of a ‘sensible financial approach’ and investment into the infrastructure. Tony Stewart too over as owner and chairman of The Millers in 2008 and, while they struggle in League Two this season, has overseen a promotion from League Two as well as three promotions to the Championship during his tenure. Stewart remains chairman albeit his son, Richard, is now more involved.
Next on the list sees us go from League Two and to the Premier League with Sunderland. The Black Cats are in the UEFA Europa League this season after finishing seventh in their first season back in the top-flight last year. The core of their promotion-winning side came through the academy and that is reason for ChatGPT to laud them with their strong academy providing a base for the club to kick on commercially, as it states, with a large fanbase under the ownership of Kyril Louis-Dreyfus and Juan Sartori.
Now we head all the way out of the EFL for 23rd on the list of ChatGPT’s ranking with Bath City, who reside in the Southern League Premier Division South after their relegation from the National League South last season. Credited for their fan ownership, owned by Bath City Supporters’ Society and, naturally, engagement with the local area has marked Bath out as a club in the top 25 of this list.
Next up are League One outfit Notts County. The Magpies’ ownership changed hands in 2019 with Christoffer and Alexander Reedtz. They initially oversaw a couple of promotion challenges in the National League and have now helped Notts County return to League One in recent years with what ChatGPT describes as a ‘clear identity’ and ‘ambition’ in their ‘development’ of the club.
Once a team that were an example of a crisis club as they plummeted from the Premier League to League Two with financial ruin, Portsmouth are now 21st on the list of the best run clubs in England according to AI. With a strong identity in the fanbase and involvement with the community, as outlined by ChatGPT, Pompey have benefitted from the ownership of former Walt Disney CEO Michael Eisner.
‘Intelligent recruitment’ was used by ChatGPT as the description for AFC Bournemouth’s processes to mark them out as 20th on the list. The Cherries, with an excellent squad and having proven they can sell high but replace and improve, are thriving in the UEFA Europa League and continuing to push on in the Premier League as a part of the Black Knight Group alongside Lorient and Auckland.
Stockport County may have cut the budget somewhat this summer after a League One play-off final defeat but Jimmy McNulty has replaced Dave Challinor with aplomb as the exciting Hatters again challenge for promotion with a fun style of football. Blessed with some wealth in the lower leagues, the modernisation of the club and general recruitment were given as reasons for being such a well run club by AI.
Surprisingly, ChatGPT suggested that ‘strong finances’, at least comparative to others in League Two, mark Newport County out as the 18th best run club in English leagues. The Welsh outfit have strong community links, as also mentioned by AI, and their punching above of their weight puts them in the ranking.
Cheltenham Town have been described as being ‘historically financially sensible’ as they sit 17th on the list of the 25 best run clubs in England. The Robins were taken over in 2025 by former Burnley chairman Mike Garlick, with the supporters’ trust maintaining 16% ownership of the club. Garlick is also the owner of Gibraltarian outfit St Joseph’s and Antequera CF in the lower leagues of Spain.
Tranmere Rovers are next on the list according to AI with ChatGPT suggesting that the Merseysiders’ ‘stronger finances for League Two’ marks them out as one of the best run clubs. Mark Palios is the chairman and co-owner alongside his wide Nicola. Palios, a former Tranmere player and the former CEO of the FA, has been suggested to be open to selling in recent years with celebrities such as ASAP Rocky linked back in October 2024.