Back
Manchester City are up sh*t creek after being found guilty on 114 of 115 charges for breaches of the Premier League’s Financial Fair Play regulations.
City say their supposed ‘irrefutable evidence’ will prove their innocence, but it is hard to see this happening after the initial verdict went so badly against them, and the appeal is reportedly expected to have a pretty similar outcome.
The findings against Man City are as damning as you could imagine, with their ‘sham’ deals worth around £900m in revenue putting an asterisk against everything they have achieved since 2009.
It is also fair to say that Pep Guardiola‘s era of domination would not have been possible without this systematic cheating, with players and clubs in the Premier League, Football League and Europe having memories, opportunities, medals and wealth stolen.
So it is hardly surprising that rival clubs reportedly want the book thrown at Man City, and this could happen…
The unprecedented nature of this case makes extreme sanctions possible, including a huge fine, transfer ban, points deduction, expulsion and/or the stripping of Premier League titles.
Unless City find a way to kick this can down the road *again*, this sorry saga should finally conclude early in 2027, when the appeal should have been finalised.
The latest information suggests Man City’s expected punishment is a colossal 75-point deduction, which would make relegation to the Championship certain this season (or next term if the process drags on).
And were this to happen, there would be further damaging knock-on effects for Man City…
Rival clubs could sue, and board members could be forced out, but an inevitable consequence of relegation to the Championship would be a mass player exodus.
Man City will hope to be suitably recompensed for some of their bigger stars, but some could swerve the Championship by leaving on loan, and it has even been suggested that players would be within their rights to rip up their contracts and leave for nothing in the event of relegation.
So, with Man City’s starting XI bound to look very, very different next season, here is how they could look when they potentially target promotion back to the Premier League, based only on players currently contracted to them.
Pierce Charles is doing a fine job on loan at Championship side QPR and would be an obvious choice to become No.1 once Gianluigi Donnarumma presumably heads back to Italy.
Another returning loanee could be in the back four, with Burnley starter Max Alleyne primed to come in after Guardiola previously gave him a sniff of first-team action.
Man City would ideally want more experience around Alleyne, but this would be hard to come by with Marc Guehi, Josko Gvardiol and Ruben Dias set to move on.
Of Man City’s current senior centre-backs, Abdukodir Khusanov seems the most likely to give the club a year in the Championship, so he could slot in alongside Alleyne.
At full-back, homegrown talents Nico O’Reilly and Rico Lewis may well go against the grain by showing there is still some loyalty in football and standing by their boyhood club, and Phil Foden could follow suit and occupy the No.10 role with a host of youngsters and one forgotten man around him.
There would be few winners from relegation at Man City, but their up-and-coming talents would certainly benefit from dropping a division.
And an elder statesman could also profit, with relegation to the Championship exactly what Kalvin Phillips needs to reignite his Man City career after his loan at Sheffield United ends.
Phillips really isn’t a joke inclusion because he still has real quality at this level and the necessary experience, with future star Sverre Nypan to learn from the England international.
On the flanks and up front, Man City actually have a surfeit of exciting young talents who could step up, with Allan and Jeremy Monga potentially starters ahead of Ryan McAidoo and Mathys Detourbet on the wings.
Up top, Floyd Samba could forge a career for himself as a striker after he moved there from midfield and scored a brace in the recent Carabao Cup win vs Norwich City.
This is not quite the €1bn+ Man City XI they could field this season, but it could still be enough to get promoted back to the Premier League.