Back
Gregor Townsend has conceded that a top-two finish in the Nations Championship’s Northern Hemisphere table now looks beyond Scotland which means they will likely play either Australia (again) or Argentina at Twickenham on Finals Weekend at the end of the month.
Before that, they host Japan at Murrayfield this Saturday, a fixture that will see Townsend face old foe Eddie Jones for the first time since the latter coached England.
Scotland have won three and lost two in the new Nations Championship which sees Europe’s best take on their Southern Hemisphere counterparts.
Summer wins over Argentina and Fiji and a defeat by South Africa left Townsend’s side second in the northern standings ahead of the tournament’s autumn resumption. However, Scotland are now fourth following a heavy loss to New Zealand and Sunday’s narrow win over Australia.
The Japan game is the Scots’ final pool match and the result will determine who they will meet on Finals Weekend in London where each northern team will face off against the southern side which finishes in their equivalent position in the standings.
The games will take place across three days, with the final on the evening of Sunday, November 29. Scotland could be the warm-up act, with the match for fourth-placed teams scheduled for 1.10pm that day.
Scotland cannot catch Northern Hemisphere leaders France who are on 21 points, six clear of the Scots. Second-placed England are on 20 match points and have a points differential of +134 and it would take a huge points swing for Townsend’s team to overhaul them. England’s final pool game is at home to New Zealand on Saturday.
Ireland, in third place, are just about catchable. They also have 20 match points but have a significantly lower points differential of +57.
Scotland, who have 15 match points and a points differential of -8, would need to beat Japan with a bonus point and hope Ireland lose to South Africa without a bonus point if they are to have any hope of catching Andy Farrell’s men. That in itself would not be enough as the Scots also need a points swing of 66 points.
England beat Japan 78-15 at the weekend so they are vulnerable but fourth place would seem a more likely placing for Scotland.
“It's probably out of our hands in terms of, if the other teams that are sitting above us go well, there's nothing we can do,” said Townsend.
“It's unlikely we're going to be in the top two anymore. But it's now about just building on that performance [against Australia]. We feel that over the last few months we have been more than competitive.
“The only teams that have beaten us are South Africa and New Zealand. We want to make sure that's the case as we finish off this year.”
New Zealand lead the Southern Hemisphere standings despite their shock defeat by Wales on Saturday. The All Blacks are on 22 points, one clear of second-placed South Africa who lost to France in Paris on Friday night. The likelihood is that France will face New Zealand in the inaugural Nations Championship final.
Argentina, who face France this weekend, are third in the southern standings on 11 points, two clear of Australia who will meet Wales in Cardiff.
Scotland beat Argentina 47-38 in Cordoba in their Nations Championship opener in July and pipped the Aussies 15-12 at Murrayfield on Sunday so would face either with a degree of confidence. Townsend would not be drawn on who he would rather meet and sees the Twickenham game as useful preparation for next year’s Rugby World Cup.
“Whoever, it doesn't really matter,” said the coach. “Argentina and Australia, if it's one of those, there are two teams that we've competed with for that number six place in the world rankings for a while now.
“They're both quality teams. I think going into a Finals Weekend in a neutral venue, there will be a shift to think this could be a World Cup game. It's a neutral venue, it's the last one of four [autumn] games. That brings its own excitement and I suppose focuses on what is going to happen in 12 months' time [at the World Cup].”
Of course, there is a scenario where Scotland could finish fifth which would likely mean another match against Japan, but this time at Twickenham. Wales are currently fifth but only by dint of their inferior points difference. Steve Tandy’s team are on -28, 20 points worse than the Scots. Wales play Australia in Cardiff on Saturday.
A double-header against Japan is probably not what Townsend is anticipating but he is looking forward to locking horns with Jones again this weekend.
“I saw him a couple of weeks ago,” said Townsend. “We had a coach catch-up down in London. He's always good company.”
Townsend and Jones crossed swords five times when the Australian was England coach and Townsend came out on top, winning three, drawing one and losing only once.
He rates Japan as “a dangerous team” despite their weekend result but is likely to freshen up his Scotland squad for this weekend. The six-day turnaround from the Australia match is an added pressure and Townsend is also likely to be without the injured Sione Tuipulotu and Scott Cummings. Max Williamson impressed when he came on for Cummings against the Wallabies and could start.
Jamie Dobie is likely to be at scrum-half, with Ben White nursing a knee issue. Josh McKay, now eligible on residency grounds, is in line for a debut and there could be a first start for Ollie Leatherbarrow who came off the bench against Australia.
In the front row, Townsend said D’arcy Rae was now fully fit and was probably ahead of the uncapped Edinburgh tighthead Ollie Blyth-Lafferty in the pecking order.