Back
Following the sixth and final round of Nations Championship pool matches, here is our Team of the Week.
As ever, a big afternoon against the Springboks or the All Blacks counts for a good deal more than a haul against a side that’s been on the wrong end of it all month, and England’s record win at Allianz Stadium earns them five places, which is as heavy as we were prepared to go.
As for New Zealand, after a hiding like that, nobody in black got within a sniff of the side. Without further ado, here’s our Team of the Week.
15 George Furbank (England): Back from a groin problem, Furbank played as though he’d spent the time off studying the New Zealand back three, putting away a 50:22 in the eighth minute and bursting down the middle to start Jack van Poortvliet’s try, and with him running second playmaker off Fin Smith, England always had two men making decisions at pace, which the All Blacks couldn’t live with. Hugo Keenan was dominant under the high ball against the Springboks and Ollie Smith ran in two against Japan, but on our opposition rule this was Furbank’s shirt by the eighth minute.
14 Robert Baloucoune (Ireland): Owned the sky in Dublin. South Africa kept kicking it towards Baloucoune all afternoon, which was rather like bowling half-volleys on leg stump to Viv Richards, and he took just about everything they sent up, turning one of the Springboks’ great weapons into a liability, and scored twice for good measure. Darcy Graham‘s hat-trick against Japan took his own Scotland record to 41 Test tries and Max Jorgensen‘s three line breaks and a try went a long way to beating Wales, but neither of them spent the afternoon catching bombs from the Springboks.
13 Kalvin Gourgues (France): From header to headliner. A week after assisting a try against the Springboks with his forehead, Gourgues showed Fabien Galthié that his hands work as well, running 96 metres, more than anyone on the field, with three clean breaks, two tries and all five conversions for 20 points and the player of the match award. The first came off a Matthieu Jalibert double pump and the second was a 45-metre sprint down the left touchline, and the 13 shirt for the final is surely his. Henry Slade ran him closest, with an early try and the break-and-kick that set up van Poortvliet, but nobody in the round came near Gourgues’ numbers.
12 Josua Tuisova (Fiji): An openside in a 12 shirt. Fiji missed 54 tackles in Udine, which in most Tests is a resignation letter, and still came from 13-7 down at the break to win their first Nations Championship match, largely because Tuisova, who has the dimensions and lifting power of a Chinook, kept relieving Italy of the ball; he won four turnovers, made 17 tackles and two dominant hits, and Fiji won the turnover count 15 to five. Seb Atkinson ran him desperately close after his try against the All Blacks and Yoram Moefana‘s lines against Argentina were excellent, whilst Len Ikitau‘s try after 24 phases put Australia ahead for good in Cardiff.
11 Mack Hansen (Ireland): Canberra’s finest Irishman. Hansen gave Ireland a different dimension in attack and his timing was spot on, the pass that sent Baloucoune over for his second try coming straight off his hands in the win over the world champions. On the eye test the Electric Scooter, Louis Bielle-Biarrey, might just have shaded it, carrying 14 times, more than anyone on the field, putting Gourgues away with a long pass and finishing Antoine Dupont’s flick over the back of a scrum, but he also threw one straight to Pablo Matera for an Argentina try, which is generous even by French standards, and Hansen did his work against the Springboks.
10 Fin Smith (England): Conductor first, kicker second. Smith ran the whole show at Allianz Stadium, 22 passes and a kick through behind a flat New Zealand line that Henry Slade scored from inside four minutes, and the licence he has now to run on and make decisions at pace is what’s changed in England’s attack. The goal-kicking was a different matter, with a couple of conversions that troubled the pigeons more than the posts, but Matthieu Jalibert, rusty after two months out, and Sam Prendergast, who looks every inch a Test fly-half, couldn’t match his control, and Carter Gordon‘s try-saving tackle on Louis Rees-Zammit deserves a mention too.
9 Antoine Dupont (France): Beach rugby at Test pace. Dupont threw 59 passes, set up two tries and produced the moment of the round at 77 minutes, a flick kick over the back of a scrum for Bielle-Biarrey that most scrum-halves wouldn’t attempt on the beach at Biarritz, and he was the conduit for everything France did well, even if a couple of needless penalties will have had Galthié chewing his pen. Jamison Gibson-Park ran him very close, keeping it tidy against a Springbok side that treats an opposition ruck the way the seagulls on Tenby Beach treat a bag of chips, and Jack van Poortvliet controlled England’s game with 17 kicks for 354 metres and a try.
8 Ben Earl (England): Gas, gas and more gas. Earl carried 32 times for 146 metres, the most carries by an England forward in a Test, scored a try and stayed at number eight even when Greg Fisilau, a specialist number eight, came on, because nobody else in the squad has his engine, and the All Blacks spent the afternoon trying to tackle him and mostly finding fresh air. A word for Grégory Alldritt, whose carry off the bench made Tyler Duguid’s try, and for Dan Sheehan, a hooker playing number eight against the Springboks with real class until a needless late croc roll sent him to the bin. Earl is our Player of the Round, by a distance.
7 Carlo Tizzano (Australia): Wales’ first-half nemesis. Wales had most of the ball and the territory in the first half and came away with seven points, largely because Tizzano kept getting over the ball like a man guarding the last sunlounger in Benidorm; he led the first-half tackle count, made try-saving stops and won a pilfer penalty before Fraser McReight replaced him with 20 minutes left, and the Wallabies’ first win in five owes him plenty. Josh van der Flier played with real energy against the Springboks and Charles Ollivon‘s 11 tackles helped turn France’s night, while Peter Lakai, with 18 tackles and two turnovers, was the one All Black anywhere near, but a 25-point hiding rules him out.
6 Ollie Chessum (England): Lock, flanker, take your pick. Chessum wore six, dropped into the second-row in defence and swapped back out to the wide channels when England had the ball, and he was outstanding in both jobs, England’s go-to target at the tail of the lineout, a try to his name and his best England performance yet. Ryan Baird‘s set-piece work strengthened Ireland’s lineout against the Springboks and Rob Valetini looked close to his best in Cardiff, while Liam McConnell‘s hat-trick and player of the match award against Japan were richly deserved, but that came against a side England had put to the sword a week earlier.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
5 Maro Itoje (England): Captain and chief nause. Itoje was relentless up front and effective at the lineout, smashing bodies and never letting New Zealand settle, and if his hit on Tupou Vaa’i in the second half was a rugby incident, as Nic Berry ruled, it’s one Vaa’i will still be feeling when the two sides meet again next Saturday. Josh Canham stole a lineout before half-time and did the dirty work for Australia, Florian Verhaeghe was excellent at the set-piece against Argentina, and Isoa Nasilasila made 19 tackles in Fiji’s win, whilst Jonny Gray‘s big paw on a Japanese throw set up one of Darcy Graham’s three.
4 Joe McCarthy (Ireland): A colossus in Dublin. McCarthy put in big hits from start to finish, won a couple of breakdown turnovers against the Springbok pack and gave Ireland the edge in the collisions, so much so that when the Bomb Squad came on to blow the doors off, they found McCarthy standing in the doorway. Tom Hooper reached double figures for carries in Cardiff and Alex Coles did the gritty work that put England on the front foot, while Tadhg Beirne bounced back nicely from a quieter afternoon against Fiji with plenty of impact at the set-piece.
3 Taniela Tupou (Australia): The Tongan Thor returns. In his first Test start for 76 days Tupou scored off Tom Wright’s short ball, made important plays in attack and defence and won a pilfer penalty, which is a bit like watching a fridge-freezer pick a lock, and he’ll want back the couple of scrum penalties he gave away. Wilco Louw edged his scrum battle and was solid in defence for the Springboks, Allan Alaalatoa was the pick of Australia’s forwards off the bench, and Will Stuart was part of an England bench that changed the second half.
2 Rónan Kelleher (Ireland): Bullseye in Dublin. Kelleher’s throwing was arrow-straight all afternoon and his all-round game was excellent, in a front-row that spent much of the match under the cosh at scrum time against South Africa. Malcolm Marx was outstanding in defeat, Dewi Lake scored twice for Wales and Tevita Ikanivere did the same in Fiji’s win, while Brandon Paenga-Amosa hit every lineout target and scored before half-time in Cardiff, but got pinged for dissent, which for a hooker is a bit like being penalised for breathing.
1 Ox Nché (South Africa): Furlong’s long afternoon. The only Springbok in our side, Nché went toe-to-toe with Tadhg Furlong and won the battle on balance, with Ireland’s front-row on the back foot for long spells, even if the Springbok scrum was never completely dominant. Ellis Genge ran him desperately close off England’s bench, folding New Zealand in half like a deckchair with two enormous carries that set up Seb Atkinson’s try at 63 minutes, and Angus Bell was reliable off Australia’s bench in Cardiff.