flag
back Back
Yankees Trade Bust Frankie Montas Gets Surprise Return Update

The New York Yankees have already begun addressing their roster this offseason, with the pitching staff at the top of the list.

The team brought back closer David Bednar on a qualifying offer, while left-hander Tim Hill has also agreed to return on a one-year contract. However, questions remain about how the club will address its pitching depth, as well as other areas of the roster, as the offseason progresses.

Though the team’s frontline appears to be in good shape, with Cam Schittler, Max Fried and Gerrit Cole set to return, it now seems the team could look to bring back a disappointing former contributor who is targeting a return to the big leagues.

“A whopping two dozen or so teams attended (Frankie) Montas’ throwing session Tuesday in Arizona, and many left the showcase buzzing about the right-handed pitcher’s ability to land a major-league deal,” Will Sammon and Dennis Lin reported for The Athletic. “Multiple general managers and high-ranking officials showed up to see Montas, who hasn’t pitched in a major-league game since August 2025.”

Former New York Yankees Bust Frankie Montas Targets Return

The Yankees acquired Montas from the Oakland Athletics at the 2022 trade deadline alongside reliever Lou Trivino. New York surrendered four prospects in the transaction, including JP Sears, Ken Waldichuk, Luis Medina and Cooper Bowman.

Montas struggled almost immediately after arriving in New York. He finished the 2022 season with a 6.35 ERA across eight starts, and right shoulder surgery limited him to just one major-league appearance in 2023. He recorded a 6.34 ERA across his brief Yankees tenure.

The right-hander subsequently moved on to the Cincinnati Reds and Milwaukee Brewers before signing with the New York Mets ahead of the 2025 campaign.

Former New York Yankees Pitcher Frankie Montas’ $34 Million Contract Preceded Injury Setback

Montas’ subsequent contract with the Mets represented another significant opportunity, but his time in Queens also failed to produce the expected results.

“The Mets guaranteed him $34MM (plus an opt-out clause) after that pedestrian ’24 season,” Anthony Franco wrote for MLB Trade Rumors. “They released him last winter, but only because he’d already been ruled out for 2026 and there was no point in having him burn a 40-man roster spot during the offseason.”

Montas underwent Tommy John surgery in September 2025 and subsequently missed the entire 2026 campaign. But his recent showcase suggests that teams have not entirely written off the possibility of a return.

At 33, Montas still has an opportunity to secure another major-league contract, particularly if teams believe his throwing session demonstrated that he can contribute again. For the Yankees, his latest development is another reminder of a trade that never delivered the rotation impact they envisioned, though perhaps they could consider a reunion.

You may like

David Bednar accepts Yankees’ $23 million qualifying offer in first major offseason domino

nypost.com 4 days ago