Back
Lewis Hamilton’s Las Vegas Grand Prix recovery was dramatically derailed by a contentious 10-second penalty that has reignited fierce debate over FIA stewarding consistency in Formula 1. The seven-time champion, who started 11th after a challenging qualifying session, found himself embroiled in a heated battle for seventh place on Lap 13 with McLaren’s Lando Norris through the tight Turn 7–8 chicane. Hamilton’s decision to cut the corner by running off the track earned him a penalty for gaining a lasting advantage, a sanction that sparked immediate frustration on the Ferrari radio channel.
Transform your passion into a work of art. Inspired by racing. Crafted for your wall – STUDIOSBRICKS
In an unaired team radio transmission, Hamilton questioned the stewards’ decision and the apparent disparity in penalty severity compared to other recent rulings. “Isn’t that interesting? One race where someone won’t have it, and they’ll be mitigating circumstances; they give them five seconds, they give me 10 for avoiding an incident,” Hamilton expressed sharply to his race engineer. His pointed reference to a “five seconds” penalty alludes directly to a controversial stewarding call just weeks earlier at the Mexico City Grand Prix involving his Ferrari teammate, Charles Leclerc.
At the Mexico City race on November 1, Leclerc executed an off-track pass on Hamilton at Turn 4 on the opening lap, an infraction that traditionally carries a 10-second penalty. However, the stewards halved the sanction to five seconds, explicitly citing mitigating circumstances. The official decision stated: “The baseline penalty guideline is 10 seconds; however, in mitigation is the fact that car 44 was also off track on the inside of car 16 and this occurred early in the first lap.” This ruling sparked widespread paddock debate, with Hamilton himself vocal during the race, disputing that the reduced penalty failed to adequately offset the advantage gained by Leclerc.
Max Verstappen, the eventual winner at Mexico, also weighed in post-race, remarking, “Normally, that penalty is 10 seconds, and now suddenly it’s five,” highlighting the inconsistency perceived by leading drivers. The crux of the issue lies in the stewards’ contextual application of rules: greater leniency is typically granted for incidents occurring in the crowded chaos of the opening lap, whereas mid-race infractions like Hamilton’s are met with the full 10-second penalty.
Hamilton’s candid radio remarks at Las Vegas underscore ongoing driver frustrations surrounding the unpredictable and flexible enforcement of track limits and penalties. This inconsistency threatens to undermine the integrity of race adjudication—an issue the FIA plans to address by introducing full-time Formula 1 stewards starting in 2027, aiming to deliver more uniform and transparent decisions.
Hamilton’s penalty not only compromised his race strategy but also threw a spotlight on an unresolved controversy that continues to divide opinion among teams, drivers, and officials alike. His outspoken challenge to the stewards’ judgment sends a clear message: the sport’s regulatory framework demands greater clarity and fairness before it can claim to be truly consistent.