Back
Charlie Methven made an interesting point during his recent appearances on Celtic podcasts. He suggested that perhaps the most important signing Celtic could make would not be a player at all, but a technical director.
You know, somebody capable of taking responsibility for the entire football operation and bringing some order to what increasingly looks like a shambles.
I’ve been making this argument for years.
Most notably, I made it in July 2024, when I wrote about the need for a complete separation between Celtic’s football department and the corporate side of the club. I made it again before last year’s AGM, when I argued that the board should be responsible for running the business while football people should be responsible for running the football.
And I haven’t changed my mind about that.
If anything, what we’ve witnessed since has convinced me that the need for reform is considerably more urgent than I thought. Because the fundamental problem at Celtic isn’t simply that we don’t have a technical director. It’s that we don’t have the structure which would allow a proper technical director to do his job.
You can appoint the most impressive football executive in Europe, hand him a magnificent title, give him a nice office overlooking Celtic Park and announce to the world that you’ve modernised your football department.
But if that individual is still required to seek approval from people who know considerably less about football than he does, what have you actually achieved? You’ve created another layer of bureaucracy. You’ve given the existing system a fresh coat of paint without changing anything that really matters.
What Celtic need is a football department with a clearly defined budget, a clearly defined strategy and genuine authority to make decisions within those parameters. The board should establish the financial framework and hold the department accountable for delivering results. Beyond that, it should leave the football decisions to the football people.
Recruitment, scouting, coaching appointments, player development, succession planning and the academy should all form part of one coherent operation. The people running that operation should know what they’re trying to achieve and have the freedom to achieve it.
And this is where Anthony Joseph’s recent comments become especially interesting.
Joseph has been discussing the state of Celtic’s football operation, including the absence of senior personnel in recruitment and other important areas.
His description of how transfers are currently handled, with Michael Nicholson involved in negotiations and Dermot Desmond sometimes required to approve deals, hardly inspires confidence that we have a modern, streamlined decision-making process.
But Joseph also reminded supporters of something which I think deserves considerably more attention. We had a man who wanted to change all of this five years ago.
His name was Dom McKay.
When McKay arrived at Celtic in 2021, he appeared to represent a genuine break from the past. He spoke about modernisation, fresh thinking and bringing the club’s structures into line with the way successful modern football organisations operated.
One of the ideas being explored was the appointment of a sporting director. Fergal Harkin, who was then working within Manchester City’s football operation, was among the candidates considered.
And then, almost as quickly as McKay had arrived, he was gone.
His departure after just 72 days as chief executive was one of the strangest episodes in Celtic’s recent history. The official explanation was personal reasons, and we should be clear that nobody has established a definitive alternative explanation.
But Joseph has now suggested that McKay may simply have been trying to change too much, too quickly, for a board which doesn’t particularly like change.
Now, that is an extraordinary suggestion, and it deserves to be considered seriously.
Because if McKay’s ambitions for the football department brought him into conflict with an organisation reluctant to surrender control, it raises an obvious question about what Celtic really wanted when they appointed him.
Did they want somebody who would modernise the club? Or did they want somebody who would occupy the chief executive’s office while leaving the existing power structure comfortably intact? And why didn’t they know what he was planning before they gave him the job? The whole thing stinks and it always has.
I don’t know precisely what happened behind those closed doors. But I do know that McKay left, the proposed sporting director structure never materialised, and five years later we’re still discussing the need for the very changes he was apparently interested in making.
That’s a pretty damning sequence of events, whichever way you look at it.
And here’s what I find particularly frustrating.
These are not revolutionary ideas. We’re not talking about some experimental arrangement dreamed up by a management consultant who has never watched a football match. We’re talking about established principles of how modern football clubs operate.
You employ specialists. You give them responsibility. You establish a strategy which survives changes of manager. You plan recruitment several windows ahead rather than desperately scrambling around in the final days of each one.
You don’t build an entire football operation around whichever manager happens to occupy the dugout, because managers come and go.
The club’s long-term football strategy should remain.
Look at what we’ve experienced over the past couple of seasons. Different managers, different philosophies, inconsistent recruitment and an alarming absence of continuity. We seem to be permanently rebuilding something without ever establishing what the finished product is supposed to look like.
And when things go wrong, responsibility becomes almost impossible to establish. Who owns the recruitment strategy? Who decides what kind of players Celtic should be signing? Who is accountable when positions remain unfilled, when unsuitable players arrive or when expensive signings fail to fit the system?
The answers should be obvious. At Celtic, they often aren’t.
This is why Methven’s argument has teeth. But as I’ve said, I would go further than simply calling for the appointment of a technical director.
Before Celtic appoint anybody, they have to decide whether they’re genuinely willing to transfer authority to the football department. That decision is more important than the identity of the person who eventually takes the job.
And once they’ve made it, they have to recruit somebody with the experience, contacts, intelligence and strength of personality to build an organisation rather than simply manage the existing mess. Because getting the structure right and getting the appointment right are equally important. One without the other is a recipe for failure.
Which brings me back to Dom McKay.
We will never know whether his proposed reforms would have succeeded. We cannot say that appointing Fergal Harkin would automatically have transformed Celtic or prevented the problems we’re experiencing today.
But we can say that Celtic had an opportunity to pursue this model in 2021, when the case for modernisation was already obvious. Failing to do it has cost us five years. Instead, that opportunity disappeared, and the club has spent every minute of that time demonstrating why the reform was necessary in the first place.
The people running Celtic might want to reflect on that.
Because what Methven is advocating, what Joseph is describing and what some of us have been arguing for years is not an attack on the club for the sake of it. It’s a way of ensuring that Celtic’s resources are properly used to build a successful football team.
And if the people in charge cannot bring themselves to surrender control over decisions they are manifestly unqualified to make, then no technical director, however talented, is going to save us. We don’t just need a new person.
We need a new system. And perhaps the most depressing thing of all is that we had somebody who wanted to move us towards one five years ago.
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News