Back
PAT CUMMINS thought he had put Sandpapergate to bed with his 68-minute, ask-any-question-you-like media conference.
How wrong he was.
Cameron Bancroft’s intervention with his 4,000-word article for his local newspaper is crushing for Cummins.
So much so that his position as captain might even be untenable. Will Australia have a new captain come next summer’s Ashes?
Cummins’ vigorous knockback of Usman Khawaja’s claim in his autobiography that the whole team knew about sandpaper is now clouded by doubt.
Bancroft even says he was prompted to give his side of the story because Cummins’ comments last week made him “feel angry, betrayed and alone.”
Most of Australia want to believe their clean-cut captain Cummins, a handsome, eco-warrior who is credited with transforming the culture of the Aussie team.
He was even filmed having an animated conversation with his English wife, Becky, which Cummins explained was her urging him to rebuff Khawaja’s comments.
Now he is confronted by more than a fired-up missus.
Cummins will note one sentence in Bancroft’s long piece, which says: “I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.”
Maybe that could give him an escape route.
But it is the detail provided by Bancroft that is so compelling.
Take this extract, for example, when discussing the atmosphere during the tea interval on day two in Port Elizabeth. Yes, Port Elizabeth, the Test match before the sandpaper story exploded in Cape Town.
Bancroft wrote: “A conversation developed in the changing rooms about getting the ball to reverse swing. I remember bowling coach David Saker being involved.
“Coach Darren Lehmann was also present. Other players were moving in and out.
“The need to get the ball moving through the air was openly acknowledged and the more vanilla methods like shining the ball normally and using saliva weren’t cutting it.”
Bancroft then explained what happened next: “We were under pressure. It was in that environment that David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball.
“Dave explained he could not personally carry out the task because of the attention the television cameras were paying him throughout the series.
“I don’t believe Dave was acting purely for himself. I understood his suggestion as an attempt to help the team regain control of the match. That doesn’t excuse his involvement or mine.
“But I think it matters that the conversation took place within a wider team environment where we were collectively desperate to make something happen.
“I recall people in the room agreeing with the proposal. Captain Steve Smith came into the conversation and, as I remember it, made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself.
“I was asked whether I could carry out the task. I felt uncomfortable and compromised. I knew it was wrong. I knew that using sandpaper was not simply pushing the boundaries of the laws of cricket. It was cheating.
“I remember being warned to be careful and others suggesting they would not do it if they were in my position.
“But I also saw an opportunity to contribute. I was a youngster playing in his seventh Test match. If you asked me to run through a brick wall at that time I would have.”
That doesn’t sound like it is made up or that Bancroft’s memory is playing tricks. It is seared into his brain.
Let’s be honest, Bancroft, Warner and Smith are not the sort of characters who attract sympathy from England fans.
Bancroft once helped concoct a story about being headbutted by Jonny Bairstow.
Warner has been a foul-mouthed bully on the field and Smith has inflicted untold pain with his sheer weight of runs and eccentric method.
Their part in the scandal – and their subsequent punishments – showed they were prepared to cheat with little regard for the integrity and honesty of cricket.
But what has emerged over the last couple of weeks sheds a different light.
Khawaja’s autobiography set a hare running with no sign of it stopping. Khawaja says the whole team knew.
The implication is clear – the bowlers and others have been lying for eight years. And Bancroft, Warner and Smith copped the flak for everybody else.
Ironically, Cricket Australia (CA) yesterday announced a confidential platform for players to tell their version of events.
Former Aussie batsman David Boon, the interim chair of CA, explained: “For almost a decade, the fallout from these events has remained part of the conversation around Australian cricket.
“It has been a difficult chapter for many people and, increasingly, the ongoing debate has become a distraction for our game.
“We believe it is time for a circuit breaker.”
They hoped the forum would end the war that is ripping cricket apart Down Under.
That hope lasted just a few hours until Bancroft went public with his truth, insisting, in his own capital letters: “WE ALL KNEW.”
Cummins’ management issued a statement in response to Bancroft’s claims: “Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through, there’s nothing in the statement that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference.”
White-ball captain Mitch Marsh dodged his press conference following England’s victory in the series decider and Lehmann left his radio commentary gig early.