flag
back Back
Adrian Lewis says darts was stronger ten years ago than today’s generation including Littler and Humphries – but do the numbers back him up?
Adrian Lewis & Luke Littler

Adrian Lewis has struck a nerve with his comments about the standard at the top of darts today. The two-time world champion said to Online Darts the competition was considerably stronger 15 years ago than it is now. That is a bold claim in the era of Luke Littler and Luke Humphries, but the numbers make the debate more interesting than you might expect.

A comparison between today’s world top 10 and the rankings in 2015 reveals a striking difference in the number of major titles won. Yet that gap tells only part of the story. How much does an impressive trophy cabinet really say about the standard of a generation? And is Lewis, who has not competed on the professional circuit for more than three years, really in a position to judge?

Lewis’s generation: an exceptional collection of world-class players

To understand Lewis’s comments, we need to look back to the period from around 2008 to 2016. It was an era when the PDC had a particularly strong group of top players.

At the top, of course, was Phil Taylor. The English record-breaking world champion set the standard in darts for years and even won world titles in 2010 and 2013. Then there was Michael van Gerwen, who made his breakthrough in 2012 and went on to dominate the sport for years.

But there were plenty of other players behind them who were exceptionally difficult to beat at their best. They included Lewis himself, Gary Anderson, James Wade, Raymond van Barneveld, Simon Whitlock, Terry Jenkins, Wes Newton, Robert Thornton and, later, Peter Wright.

What made that generation so special was not just the number of top players. It was also how many could regularly average over 100 on the big stage.

Adrian Lewis won two world titles

A great example is the legendary semi-final between Phil Taylor and Adrian Lewis at the 2013 Grand Slam of Darts. Both players averaged over 109 and together hit an incredible 32 maximums in just 25 legs. Taylor eventually won 16-9, but Lewis also produced an outstanding performance. It was a showcase of what two of the world’s best could deliver at their peak.

The depth of competition was remarkable, too. A player ranked in the top 10 during that period could win a major on a good day. Beating Taylor and Van Gerwen alone was not enough. You also had to be at your best against Anderson, Lewis, Wade or Van Barneveld.

On that point, Lewis certainly has a case. His generation featured an impressive collection of players with experience, titles and exceptionally high potential.

Littler and Humphries: a higher standard at the very top?

Still, the picture becomes much more complicated when we look at the standard of the very best players.

If one player can challenge Lewis’s claim, it is Luke Littler. The young Englishman has reached a level rarely seen before in a remarkably short time. His scoring power, his consistent presence at major tournaments and, above all, his ability to keep producing high averages under pressure make him a special talent.

Luke Humphries belongs in that conversation, too. In recent years, “Cool Hand Luke” has shown that he is not just a player who occasionally produces a standout performance. He can consistently perform at an exceptionally high level.

Perhaps the difference from the past is that fewer players today can match the absolute world-class standard at any given moment. But that does not mean Littler and Humphries are inferior to their predecessors.

Quite the opposite. At such a young age, Littler has already built an impressive collection of major titles. His ability to win matches with averages above 105 is exceptional. He also seems barely affected by the pressure of major finals.

It is therefore very difficult to argue that the very best players today are weaker than they were 10 or 15 years ago. Taylor and Van Gerwen were phenomenal, but Littler has the potential to join their ranks.

The current top 10 and the top 10 in 2015

Position Top 10 in 2026 Top 10 in 2015
1 Luke Littler Michael van Gerwen
2 Luke Humphries Gary Anderson
3 Gian van Veen Phil Taylor
4 Gerwyn Price Peter Wright
5 Jonny Clayton Adrian Lewis
6 Ross Smith Robert Thornton
7 James Wade James Wade
8 Josh Rock Michael Smith
9 Stephen Bunting Ian White
10 Danny Noppert Simon Whitlock

The depth of today’s field

Lewis may have a stronger case when we look at the depth of the top ten.

The current world rankings are, of course, packed with excellent players. Humphries, Gian van Veen, Gerwyn Price, Jonny Clayton, Ross Smith, James Wade, Josh Rock, Stephen Bunting and Danny Noppert are all capable of winning major tournaments.

Still, there is a difference between a player who can win a major and one who remains a constant threat to the very best in the world over several years.

One striking example is that James Wade (7th) and Gary Anderson (16th) remain high in the world rankings despite their age. That speaks to their exceptional quality, but also raises questions about the challenge posed by the younger generation.

According to the world rankings at the start of November 2026, Littler is also top with more than £3 million, while Humphries and Van Veen each have around £1 million. The gap to the rest is considerable.

That does not automatically mean the current top ten is weaker. Littler’s dominance is clearly a major factor. But it does suggest that the gap between the world number one and the rest is particularly wide at present.

We must also take into account that the PDC is far bigger now than it was ten or fifteen years ago. There are more international players and more tournaments. That makes it difficult to compare the depth of the field directly with that of the past.

Phil Taylor & Adrian Lewis won the World Cup of Darts together four times

A big gap in major titles, with some important context

At first glance, the difference in major titles between the current world top ten and the top ten in 2015 looks enormous. The current top ten have won 51 major titles between them, while the top ten from eleven years ago had no fewer than 163 majors to their names. That is a huge gap, though it needs some context.

One key reason for the difference is Phil Taylor’s place in the 2015 top ten. The darts legend won an incredible 79 major titles during his career. Although he was still among the very best in the world at the time, he was in the latter stages of his career. His vast trophy collection therefore has a major impact on the total for that era’s top ten.

At first glance, the figures seem to support Adrian Lewis’s argument. By the count used here, the current world top ten have won 51 major titles between them. At the same stage of their careers, the ten best players of 2015 had already collected 108 major titles.

Yet the gap is less convincing than it appears. Phil Taylor alone accounted for 77 of those 108 titles. Without the 16-time world champion, the other nine players from 2015 had won just 31 between them. That shows how one exceptional player can skew the comparison.

The number of major titles does not, then, prove that the competition was stronger fifteen years ago. What is more, the current generation, including players such as Luke Littler and Gian van Veen, has had far fewer years on average to win major honours.

There are undoubtedly still opportunities for other players in the current top ten to add to their records. Their current major-title tally may not reflect the full potential of this generation. In mid-November 2015, for example, Michael van Gerwen had won “only” eleven major titles.

The current top ten have an average age of 34.90, compared with 39.70 in 2015. The presence of several young talents means today’s leading players are considerably younger than their counterparts eleven years ago.

Still, it is important to distinguish proven success from playing level. The number of major titles won mainly reflects what players have achieved over their careers, not necessarily how good they were at a particular moment. A player who has spent years among the world’s elite has also had more time to collect titles than a young talent who has only been competing for a few seasons.

Major-title comparison: current top ten versus 2015

Position 2026 top ten (age) Majors as of 18.11.2026 2015 top ten (age at the time) Majors (career total) Majors as of 18.11.2015
1 Luke Littler (19) 14 Michael van Gerwen (26) 48 13
2 Luke Humphries (31) 9 Gary Anderson (44) 8 3
3 Gian van Veen (24) 1 Phil Taylor (55) 79 77
4 Gerwyn Price (41) 7 Peter Wright (45) 8 0
5 Jonny Clayton (52) 4 Adrian Lewis (30) 4 4
6 Ross Smith (37) 3 Robert Thornton (48) 2 2
7 James Wade (43) 11 James Wade (32) 11 8
8 Josh Rock (25) 0 Michael Smith (25) 2 0
9 Stephen Bunting (41) 1 Ian White (45) 0 0
10 Danny Noppert (36) 1 Simon Whitlock (47) 1 1

Are averages a reliable measure, then?

One of the biggest problems with this debate is that we are trying to compare different generations using match averages.

It is tempting to claim that players in the past scored above 100 less often, and that the standard was therefore automatically lower. But match averages do not tell the whole story.

Equipment, conditions, training methods and professional support have all changed, too. Today’s players have far more ways to analyse and improve their game.

As the table below shows, Phil Taylor and Michael van Gerwen were slightly ahead of Luke Littler and Luke Humphries in 2015. Beyond that, the differences are negligible.

Top 10 highest averages of 2015 compared with 2026

Position 2015 top 10 (season average) 2026 top 10 (season average)
1 Phil Taylor – 102.20 Luke Littler – 100.93
2 Michael van Gerwen – 101.41 Luke Humphries – 99.73
3 Gary Anderson – 99.73 Gerwyn Price – 98.75
4 Dave Chisnall – 98.37 Gary Anderson – 97.70
5 Raymond van Barneveld – 97.10 Chris Dobey – 97.46
6 James Wade – 96.90 Wessel Nijman – 97.31
7 Adrian Lewis – 96.61 Ross Smith – 96.08
8 Kim Huybrechts – 95.25 Rob Cross – 96.06
9 Stephen Bunting – 93.66 Michael van Gerwen – 96.03
10 Peter Wright – 93.44 Kevin Doets – 96.02

Would Lewis still have a point if he returned?

Perhaps the most striking thing about Lewis’s comments is that he is not only criticising the current generation, but also believes he could still rank among the world’s best players.

He pointed, among other things, to his recent exhibition match against Gary Anderson, in which he averaged more than 112. His results in other exhibition matches also appear to have convinced him that he is far from finished.

There is no doubt that Lewis still has exceptional ability. At his best, he was one of the most complete players in the world. His scoring power, natural talent and ability to hit big finishes made him a formidable opponent for years. It could even be argued that the 41-year-old Englishman has so far achieved too little in his career, despite winning two world titles, one UK Open title and one European Championship.

But there is a big difference between an exhibition match and a full season on the PDC Tour.

On the ProTour, you have to perform week after week. You play several matches in a day, travel constantly and need to deliver results even on off days. That is a very different challenge from a one-off match at the oche, without the pressure of ranking points.

Lewis has not competed on the professional circuit since April 2023. His last ranking title came even earlier, in July 2022. A comeback would undoubtedly be interesting, but that does not prove he would immediately rejoin the absolute world elite.

Conclusion: Lewis has a point, but may be underestimating the current generation

Is Adrian Lewis right? Partly. When we look at the depth of the top 10, there is certainly something to his argument. Lewis’s generation included a remarkably strong group of established names. Phil Taylor, Michael van Gerwen, Gary Anderson, Raymond van Barneveld, James Wade and Adrian Lewis could all perform at the highest level. Many other players were also extremely difficult to beat on their best days.

But claiming that today’s very best players are weaker goes too far. Luke Littler and Luke Humphries have shown they can play at a level that matches the greatest generations in the sport’s history. Littler, in particular, has the potential to become one of the greatest darts players of all time.

Where Lewis does raise an important point is the immense workload facing today’s professionals. The crowded calendar, sponsor commitments and exhibition matches demand a great deal from players. In time, that could affect their performances.

You may like

Luke Littler set for extended break: Why the world champion won’t return to the PDC stage until 2...

dartsnews.com 1 day ago

‘Real Reason’ For Luke Littler’s Shock Grand Slam of Darts Exit Revealed

givemesport.com 7 hours ago

Ricky Evans and the other darts stars who have one more chance to qualify for the World Championship

sportbible.com 5 hours ago

Luke Humphries shocked by Tom Sykes in last-leg thriller at Grand Slam of Darts a day after Luke ...

skysports.com 1 day ago

Grand Slam of Darts champion will pocket huge 25% prize pot increase amid shock Luke Littler and ...

sportbible.com 15 minutes ago

How Man Utd icon Paul Scholes was secretly behind Luke Littler’s stunning triple-bullseye finish ...

The Sun 3 days ago

Sky Sports forced to apologise as Michael van Gerwen swears live on TV after missing bullseye

The Sun 2 days ago

"You'll have to find out..” – Luke Littler had already predicted his bizarre 150 finish with thre...

dartsnews.com 3 days ago

Luke Humphries' concern over Grand Slam backed up as Nathan Aspinall becomes final player into la...

sportbible.com 2 days ago

All-time darts rich-list top ten revealed with £5million golden boy Luke Littler only SIXTH and P...

The Sun 2 days ago