flag
back Back
Robbie Keane is not going to be Celtic boss no matter who promotes the idea.

Robbie Keane. Again. He made his choice. Celtic fans have made ours.

SPIRIT_OF_86_01501

Here we go again. Another day, another story pushing Robbie Keane as a potential Celtic manager. Apparently, no matter how many times this particular name is thrown into the conversation, some people are determined to convince us that he would be a wonderful appointment for the Celtic dugout.

The media can keep recycling the story, the pundits can keep discussing the possibility, and those who fancy the idea can keep telling us how brilliant it would be. But I have a rather inconvenient message for them: Robbie Keane is not going to be the next Celtic manager.

And I am not saying this because I have some personal dislike of the man or because I am incapable of recognising his footballing achievements.

I am saying it because there is always something rather important missing from this entire conversation: the Celtic support.

You cannot appoint a manager at Celtic Park simply because somebody in a boardroom thinks his name looks attractive on a piece of paper. You cannot ignore the feelings, values and expectations of supporters and expect everybody to fall into line because the club has announced an appointment. We have been through enough of that nonsense already.

Robbie Keane made his choices.

He chose to work at two clubs where sections of the support have been associated with some of the ugliest forms of racism in European football. He was perfectly entitled to make those professional decisions, just as Celtic supporters are entitled to judge them and decide whether they are comfortable with him representing our club.

And I would suggest that plenty of Celtic supporters have already made up their minds.

Celtic is not just another football club.

It is a club with a particular history, identity and set of values. Our history matters. Our relationship with our supporters matters. The people who fill Paradise every week are not simply customers expected to applaud whatever decision the hierarchy happens to make.

There are appointments that require more than a CV, impressive managerial statistics and flattering newspaper headlines. They require an understanding of what Celtic represents and, perhaps more importantly, what the Celtic support will and will not accept.

I struggle to see how Robbie Keane could walk into Celtic Park and expect the wholehearted backing that any Celtic manager desperately needs. And without that backing, what exactly would be the point?

Imagine the board presenting this appointment as some sort of masterstroke. Imagine the carefully prepared statements, the photographs, the smiling faces and the obligatory references to ambition, progress and a bright new chapter.

Wonderful. Another presentation. Another collection of impressive words.

But what happens when the manager walks out at Paradise and discovers that a significant section of the support has absolutely no enthusiasm for his appointment? Does anyone seriously believe that would be a good starting point?

I certainly do not.

And this brings me to the bigger question. Why are we spending so much time discussing Robbie Keane in the first place?

Is this really the best Celtic can come up with? Is this the level of ambition we should be discussing when the club needs to get its next managerial appointment absolutely right?

I would much rather see Celtic identify a genuine footballing project, establish what kind of football we want to play, decide what qualities our next manager must possess and then find someone who fits those requirements.

It should not be a case of finding a familiar name, attaching him to Celtic and hoping the supporters will eventually warm to the idea. We have seen enough managerial confusion to last us a lifetime.

Celtic needs a manager with a clear footballing philosophy, the ability to develop players, the personality to handle enormous expectations and the courage to make difficult decisions. Someone who understands that managing Celtic is not simply another job on a professional CV. It is a responsibility that comes with enormous pressure, history and expectations.

And yes, the support must be considered before any appointment is made. Not afterwards, when the damage has already been done.

I am particularly tired of the suggestion that supporters should simply accept whoever the club decides to appoint. That is not how Celtic works, or at least it should not be.

The supporters have every right to express their opinions, question decisions and challenge the direction of the club. We are not obliged to surrender our judgement because somebody has decided that a particular managerial candidate would make an attractive headline.

So, my message to the Celtic hierarchy is straightforward: open your eyes. Robbie Keane is not your real target.

Stop wasting time entertaining a managerial possibility that is unlikely to unite the support. Stop confusing a recognisable footballing name with the right appointment. And, above all, stop treating the Celtic support as though we are an inconvenience to be managed rather than the very people who make this football club what it is.

Celtic needs to look forward, not reach for another headline-friendly solution. We need ambition, proper planning and a manager who can bring the club together rather than create another unnecessary divide.

The next appointment matters enormously. Get it right, and we can start building something worthwhile. Get it wrong, and we will be having yet another conversation about the people running Celtic rather than the football being played on the pitch.

And I, for one, have absolutely no intention of pretending that Robbie Keane is the answer just because another newspaper has decided to put his name into the managerial hat.

There must be better candidates out there. Surely, Celtic can do better than this.

Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News

You may like

UEFA facing £3.7bn row as 138 clubs launch explosive complaint over power of Europe’s elite

talksport.com 1 day ago

Former Celtic Target and Rangers Flop in Job Race

celtsarehere.com 1 hour ago

Chelsea face unexpected BlueCo disruption: Major shake-up could change everything

footballtransfers.com 1 day ago