flag
back Back
Grading Xabi Alonso on different areas of Chelsea management from his first ten games

Ten games is a small sample size, but does Xabi Alonso's early grading suggest Chelsea made the right appointment?

Sunderland v Chelsea FC - Premier League 2026/27 | NurPhoto/GettyImages

Xabi Alonso has enjoyed a mixed start to life as Chelsea manager, with around three months in charge giving us plenty to assess.

Overall, the experience has been a mixed one for Chelsea supporters, with some impressive results accompanied by the occasional mediocre performance. There have been plenty of positives, but also areas where the Spaniard still has work to do.

Now feels like the perfect time to assess his opening months at Stamford Bridge, looking at everything from his results and tactical approach to his man-management and decision-making.

For this review, we're going back to the good old GCSE grading system (for our UK readers), using letter grades from A* at the top all the way down to F at the bottom.

Tactics - C

The tactics have been a mixed bag, with the results against Everton and Manchester United standing out as examples of Alonso getting things right. However, the defeats to Tottenham, Sunderland and Brentford are equally difficult to ignore.

Those losses were arguably more down to individual performances than the tactics themselves, but one recurring issue has emerged from the recent switch to a back four: Chelsea have regularly been set up without a recognised striker. The team has looked adventurous going forward, but without a natural focal point for the ball to stick to, opposition defenders have enjoyed relatively comfortable evenings.

Hopefully, once the January transfer window has passed, we will begin to see more of the squad Alonso wants to build and the tactical identity he is keen to establish at Stamford Bridge. Chelsea need to emerge from the January blues with a clearer idea of where this project is heading.

In-game management - D

One of the biggest frustrations among Chelsea fans is that Alonso often leaves his changes too late. Bringing on Estevao and Danny Welbeck with only minutes remaining in certain games, while sometimes opting for a defensive substitution first when chasing a result or struggling for momentum, raises questions about his decision-making. It suggests either a reluctance to make proactive changes or a lack of trust in the flair and experience available on the bench.

Press conferences - A

If you are wanting to give the opposition an advantage, the pre match press conference is certainly the first battle. Alonso keeps his cards and the player's availability close to his chest. 

Boring for a journalist, and potentially for a fan, but he remains in control and does not get too emotive with his answers. Stays calm and in control with an authoritative tone to anything coming his way. Big positive for the club.

Transfers - B

The summer arrivals may not all have been Alonso's doing, but I would imagine he had some influence over several of them. The signing that appears to have been most closely associated with the manager is Pep Chavarria, who has looked an exciting left-back, offering plenty of energy and quality up and down the flank. If he can continue to improve defensively, Marc Cucurella's departure may not be felt quite as big.

Jordan Henderson and Morgan Rogers arrived at the opposite end of the financial scale, but both have proved important additions and settled into the team well. The same can be said of Maxence Lacroix, who has also made a positive impression.

The outgoings, however, still leave something to be desired. Raising funds through the departures of Liam Delap, an unhappy Enzo Fernandez and Nicolas Jackson has been a mixed bag, particularly with Jackson showing his value whenever Chelsea have been short of options up front.

Player management - C

This has been a tricky one to judge, as there are mixed feelings about Alonso's man-management. On one hand, he has shown faith in players who desperately needed it, but on the other, some of his decisions have been difficult to understand.

Josh Acheampong and Romeo Lavia are good examples of players who have benefited from that trust, with regular opportunities in their natural positions helping their form improve.

Then there is Estevao, who has struggled for minutes and dropped despite an excellent performance in his first start, while Danny Welbeck may feel he has yet to earn Alonso's trust. Levi Colwill and Jorrel Hato have also had difficult experiences, being hooked at half-time after mistakes and subsequently facing public criticism.

C feels like a fair assessment.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

You may like

Jorginho says Chelsea had an ‘incredible’ manager who was so underrated

thechelseachronicle.com 1 day ago

Xabi Alonso's January transfer plan dealt cruel blow as Chelsea 'barred' from signing £30m maestro

sportsmole.co.uk 13 hours ago

Under-17 World Cup: Five African wonderkids to watch, including Man United and Chelsea prospects

sportsmole.co.uk 8 hours ago

Juventus beat Chelsea to €40m star as Romano confirms transfer decision

footballtransfers.com 12 hours ago

Chelsea fined £150,000 by FA for anti-Catholic and anti-Irish chants as statement issued

Mirror 2 hours ago

“We can see a better Levi” – Alonso admits to talks with defender who doesn’t feel “strong and po...

talkchelsea.net 5 hours ago

Former Sunderland defender praises key figure for impact in Chelsea win

sunderlandecho.com 2 hours ago

Chelsea leading the race to sign £100m-rated Premier League star

eplindex.com 9 hours ago

Chelsea news: Caicedo possible injury, international break good and bad, and more

theprideoflondon.com 16 hours ago