flag
back Back
Keith Hackett reacts to footage of Swansea vs West Brom incident that baffled fans inside the stadium
James Morrison giving out instructions in the rain
James MorrisonImago

Isaac Price's failed Panenka penalty wasn't the only baffling aspect of West Brom's penalty against Swansea on Saturday.

Albion lost their lead twice at the Swansea.com Stadium as they dropped two vital points in the race for promotion to the Premier League.

Price scored early to put the Baggies ahead and could have made it 3-1 to the Black Country club shortly before half-time when he botched a penalty, allowing Lawrence Vigouroux to make a simple save.

However, the way the penalty was won seemed to confuse those inside the stadium in South Wales.

Express & Star journalist Lewis Cox called the penalty a "bizarre one", while WalesOnline's match report dubbed it as a "soft decision".

Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett, however, thought that referee Thomas Kirk was spot on with his call.

What happened for West Brom's penalty?

Looking back at the incident, it's hard to see why there was any doubt about why the penalty was given.

As Albion floated a free-kick into the box, Josh Tymon clearly wrestles Jayson Molumby down to the ground inside the penalty area.

Replays clearly show Tymon behind Molumby, with both arms around the Ireland international's waist, before he goes down and instantly appeals to Kirk for the penalty.

Keith Hackett's reaction to the incident

Speaking to West Brom News, after seeing the replay on Saturday, former PGMOL general manager and FIFA-listed referee Hackett said: "Not for the first time I am offering praise to Referee Thomas Kirk.

"He is spot on in law and more of his colleagues should follow suit.

"Well done to him."

Hackett has long called for referees to clamp down on players wrestling one another at set-pieces.

In 2024, after growing frustrated with the antics of Arsenal defenders, he told Football Insider:  “The referee failed to grip, as a lot of referees are doing, grappling, almost rugby-style play in the penalty area."

You may like

Liverpool vs Man United LIVE - team news, TV channel, kick-off time, score and commentary stream

Liverpool Echo 13 minutes ago

Newcastle United player ratings as 8/10 ‘does a job’ on Bruno Guimaraes in 2-2 draw with Arsenal

shieldsgazette.com 7 hours ago

Mikel Arteta confirms major Arsenal injury blow after Newcastle United clash

eplindex.com 2 hours ago

Rio Ferdinand Named 3 Liverpool Players He 'Hated' on the Pitch

givemesport.com 3 hours ago

Lamine Yamal strikes post from spot with Barcelona 2-0 down

besoccer.com 27 minutes ago

A standout on the ProTour, but not yet on television: Is the Premier League too soon for Wessel N...

dartsnews.com 6 hours ago

'I played for Liverpool and Man Utd — Trey Nyoni will not be fazed by Anfield showdown'

liverpool.com 6 hours ago

Rangers gem Calum Adamson gets red card after on-pitch row with teammate

rangersnews.uk 27 minutes ago

We live in shadow of Premier League stadium – huge redevelopment is a nightmare with homes shakin...

The Sun 4 hours ago

WATCH: ‘Foolish’ verdict as Lewis Cox summarises chaotic West Brom draw

birminghamworld.uk 6 hours ago