flag
back Back
‘That back four gets you relegated’ warns former Man Utd star as defensive crisis leaves Michael Carrick on the brink

Michael Carrick understands 'frustrations and disappointment' of Man Utd supporters

FORMER Manchester United star Phil Neville has warned that some of the current defenders would get the club relegated.

Neville, who was speaking on a panel with his brother Gary, didn’t hold back in his assessment of some of United’s defensive players.

Premier League - Manchester United v Aston Villa
Phil Neville was particularly critical of some United defenders following yesterday’s performance
Manchester United v Aston Villa, Premier League, Football, Old Trafford, Manchester, UK - 08 Nov 2026
Neville reckons they could get Michael Carrick or any manager the sack

Neville said: “Mazraoui, Heaven, Yoro, and Dalot. That back four gets you relegated. That back four gets you the sack as a manager.”

And that was the Man United back four in yesterday’s second half against Aston Villa.

Harry Maguire was hooked and replaced by Ayden Heaven at half-time after Villa stormed into a 2-0 lead after just FOUR minutes.

United were level by the break, but the second period felt like Groundhog day.

Neville’s relegation back four conceded two more after just eight minutes in the second half as Villa restored their lead.

The fourth was one to forget for Yoro, who did his best to head past Senne Lammens before Leon Goretzka tapped in.

Neville’s point was supported by the fact that United became the worst defensive side in Europe last night as they conceded their 30th goal of the season.

United forward Matheus Cunha also didn’t hold back on the defenders, despite his petulant sending off against Roma last week.

Infographic detailing Manchester United's defensive statistics, listing players Diogo Dalot, Harry Maguire, Lisandro Martinez, Leny Yoro, Ayden Heaven, Luke Shaw, and Noussair Mazraoui alongside their games played, minutes played, goals conceded, goals conceded per 90, and clean sheets.

He said: “We did it again where we had to play like Manchester United and go forward. We showed courage, but we only do this after we concede goals.

“We can’t do that, we can’t concede goals like this. We need to play like Man Utd and go forward and create chances, play with more courage.

“If we had shown that character and courage before, then we will win more games. I don’t know why we are making it hard for ourselves.”

Despite his criticism Cunha did have a point – scoring doesn’t seem to be a problem for the Red Devils.

They pegged Villa’s two-goal lead back for the second time as stoppage time goals from Patrick Dorgu and Joshua Zirkzee saved Carrick’s skin.

Former United player Paul Parker also left a scathing review of United’s defenders, speaking exclusively to Betarades, he said: “Let’s put it this way. Frank Lampard’s managing Coventry. He wouldn’t want that back four.

“He wouldn’t want the full-backs because his full-backs are better. They’re tuned to the top division of football in general. Athletic, get up and down, defend.”

“Man Utd’s backline has been poor. They are poor. They definitely wouldn’t get to a top six side. Not one of those defenders would.”

Everton v Manchester United - Premier League 2026/27, Liverpool, United Kingdom - 06 Sep 2026
Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez also haven’t dodged criticism this season

You may like

Emery post-match crash out proved he would be disastrous Manchester United appointment

football365.com 2 hours ago

Micah Richards puts Kobbie Mainoo in seven-player Man Utd tier

unitedinfocus.com 1 hour ago

Man Utd plan stunning move for Bayern Munich coach after Carrick sack decision is made

football365.com 3 hours ago

What Man Utd did after Villa draw is ‘painful’ and causes ‘emotional damage’

unitedinfocus.com 4 hours ago

Goalkeeper displayed highest IQ ever to let indirect free-kick go straight in

sportbible.com 1 hour ago

Arsenal flying start after 10 games ranks among best ever in Premier League history

football365.com 1 hour ago

‘Bring him back’ – Man Utd fans call for cult hero’s return as ‘assistant manager or on the board...

The Sun 5 hours ago

Matheus Cunha says Man Utd ‘don’t deserve’ fan support in rallying cry to teammates

unitedinfocus.com 2 hours ago