Back
The Premier League have explained the VAR decision that disallowed Erling Haaland’s 25th-minute equaliser, although fans remain confused as to why the goal wasn’t given in Manchester City’s 1-1 draw with Fulham at the Etihad Stadium.
Man City were unable to rectify their poor run of form in Saturday’s game against Fulham as Rodrigo Muniz’s goal saw the Citizens go without a win in the Premier League for the fourth game running.
Muniz put his side ahead in the 16th minute through the visitors’ first shot on target as Fulham broke down the right flank through former Man City man Oscar Bobb.
Bobb cut inside before laying it to the Muniz, who controlled before sending a beautiful whipped effort into the top right corner.
Fulham went into the break with the advantage for the first time ever away from home against Man City, but the hosts managed to get the game back square in the 58th minute as Elliot Anderson hammered a low volley under the goalkeeper from just outside the area.
Anderson’s goal just before the hour mark proved to be the final contribution to the scoresheet at the Etihad, but plenty of talking points have come from the game despite the low scoreline, including Haaland’s disallowed goal in the first half and Man City’s subpar performance once again.
Going into the interval, TNT Sports commentator and former Chelsea star Joe Cole said: “Fulham have played into pockets and broken off with the runners.
“City need some fight and spirit into this game. I’m sure they’ll be some harsh words at half time and some changes.”
Man City did get the goal that eventually got them a point, but the Citizens will likely feel hard done by after Haaland’s first-half goal was disallowed for a foul on goalkeeper Bernd Leno.
A well-weighted cross, which was sent in by Iliman Ndiaye from the right flank, found the run of Haaland at the back post, but the Norwegian didn’t strike the ball cleanly, rather bundling it goalwards, which Leno was initially able to keep out before seemingly dropping the ball, which allowed the City talisman to push it home.
Referee Tom Bramall hesitated for around 10 seconds before disallowing the goal, much to the frustration of the Man City players.
Although the wrong decision was eventually made, the time between Haaland actually putting the ball over the line to the referee resuming play was very quick, prompting widespread criticism of the officiating.
Former Premier League referee, Mike Dean, speaking on the Soccer Saturday panel, said: “I think the keeper is going backwards and kind of pushes the ball, so the ball goes away from his hands.
“Haaland has every right to go for the ball, and for me, I think it’s a goal.
“The referee doesn’t give the goal straight away, you can see him talk to his assistant referee and say I’m going to give a foul on-field, and he then gives it about 5-10 seconds after. He’s gone with the on-field decision, and I’d like to know why.
“An extra 10 seconds would have done no harm. We’ve looked at it two or three times, and initially I thought it was a foul, but then I saw it more, and we’ve probably changed our mind.”
Former Man City goalkeeper and four-time Premier League Golden Glove winner Joe Hart was similarly perplexed by the decision. He said: “It was obviously an interesting one with Bernd Leno.
“I think the rules say that he’s got his hands, his fingertips on the ball. I had to think about why on earth that came in because I was always under the impression you had to have control of the ball but I think it’s there to protect the goalkeeper, not from that circumstance, but just in general, to stop people flying in.”
Yet the official statement from the Premier League Match Centre on X has done little to shed light on the situation.
It reads: “The referee’s call of free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR – with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball.
“VAR: ‘The ball is in control between both hands and then is played out of that possession by the attacker, and then into the back of the net’.”
This would help if it were actually true. Plenty of social media users and Man City fans have argued that Leno was not in control of the ball and had actually dropped it when Haaland knocked it into the Fulham goal.
But the goal was disallowed, and another 72 minutes of football was played where Man City were unable to come up with the winner, so it’s fair to say Fulham were more than deserving of their first point against the banana-brandishing blues in over 15 years.