Back
Technically, Xabi Alonso is not Enzo Maresca’s successor at Chelsea. The Spaniard replaced Liam Rosenior after he was sacked in April.
However, with Rosenior in France and Maresca at Chelsea’s Premier League rivals Manchester City, comparing Alonso with the latter has been much more interesting.
Unlike Rosenior, Maresca also had some success during his time at Stamford Bridge. Therefore, it only makes sense that Maresca is the sort of benchmark for Alonso.
So, how do the two compare then? What are supporters’ thoughts? Are Chelsea’s current issues under Alonso temporary, or should fans be worried? These are questions all worth discussing.
TalkingPoints
Did Chelsea make the right decision not signing Folarin Balogun? 🤔
They opted for Danny Welbeck instead…
Ten games is not the largest sample size, but it is certainly big enough to tell you some things. For example, a team’s strengths, weaknesses and how they play. It is also enough to provide numbers that can be compared.
Alonso has now managed 10 games in the Premier League as Chelsea manager, earning two fewer points than Maresca did by this stage of his first season in the Stamford Bridge dugout.
| Manager’s performance after first 10 Chelsea league games | Wins | Losses | Draws | League position | Points | Goals | Goals conceded | Clean sheets |
| Xabi Alonso | 5 | 4 | 1 | 4 | 16 | 19 | 16 | 2 |
| Enzo Maresca | 5 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 18 | 20 | 12 | 2 |
As you can see from the table above, there is not actually much separating Alonso and Maresca after their first 10 league games in charge of Chelsea.
Offensively, goals scored are almost identical, while defensively, Alonso’s Chelsea have been marginally worse. Yes, they have conceded four more goals, but the number of clean sheets is the same. Ultimately, both of these Chelsea sides are quite leaky.
Despite a two-point difference, there are Chelsea fans on TalkingPoints who are starting to side with Maresca as this debate involving the City manager and Alonso continues.
Featured comment
philchristie1955
Was not a fan of Maresca but totally underwhelmed with Xabi so far. I accept losing Pedro has been a significant loss but he has not found a viable solution yet which has cost us points
Join the conversation →
It may surprise some, and not just because Alonso’s Chelsea have produced similar results and numbers to Maresca’s. We cannot forget that Maresca left in such ugly fashion, and that did not go down well with supporters.
After holding discussions with City midseason, Maresca practically quit his job at Chelsea before eventually joining City in the summer. Yet the Italian seems to be missed.
Featured comment
kilham.max
Maresca for me. Xabi showed early promise but has struggled without Pedro leading the line.
Join the conversation →
Yes, Joao Pedro’s injury has hit Alonso hard, so there is some sympathy there. He has missed Chelsea’s last three top-flight fixtures, with Chelsea losing two of them. However, the Blues’ style and set-up have done no favours in helping Alonso’s relationship with supporters, while some of his substitutions have also been very frustrating.
With Pedro being injured, perhaps some of Chelsea’s problems right now are only temporary. Once Pedro is back, Alonso will no longer have to use a false 9.
However, that change is unlikely to do much about Chelsea’s lack of control in games, which has probably stemmed from Alonso this season. With Pedro in the side, Chelsea still had just 26% of possession in their 4-3 win over Brighton & Hove Albion, for example.
Of late, Alonso has been using a 4-2-3-1 formation, but he preferred a 3-4-2-1 set-up near the beginning of the campaign. In a 3-4-2-1, it can be more difficult to keep hold of the ball at times, and we saw that in Chelsea’s 2-0 loss to Tottenham Hotspur as Sandro Tonali, Mateus Fernandes and James Maddison overrun Moises Caicedo and Jordan Henderson.
In-game, Chelsea’s shape was fluid, even looking like a 4-2-3-1 at times, but regardless, they were dominated. Spurs saw 69% of the ball despite being the away side.
It was boring at times, but in contrast, Maresca’s team were always the more dominant outfit, with his back four happy to pass the ball across their defensive line in a horseshoe shape to retain possession.
Clearly, there are deeper issues that stretch beyond Pedro being injured. Chelsea’s midfield balance, overall shape and number of goals conceded seem to be more long-term issues that need addressing.
Chelsea’s ultimate objective is to finish in the top four and qualify for the Champions League. Sitting just two points behind fourth-placed Liverpool, that is well within reach. It must also be mentioned that fifth place could be enough for Champions League qualification once again.
With that in mind, as of now, we do not need to conclude that Alonso was not the right appointment. He is almost matching Maresca, who went on to be quite successful at Chelsea.
It has only been 10 games, and Alonso arguably has a better squad as well. Emiliano Martinez is an upgrade on Robert Sanchez, while Pedro and Rogers are far more consistent than Nicolas Jackson and Jadon Sancho, who Maresca utilised in his first season in west London.
The potential is definitely there for Alonso to do well. Of course, he will need to find a more settled team before he can deliver success, or there will never be a real foundation for him to build on.
According to Match XI, Alonso has made 24 changes to his starting XI this season. Only Roberto De Zerbi has made more with 28 at Spurs.
But to answer the question again, given where Chelsea are right now and the lack of top managers available at the time, Alonso was the right appointment for the Blues.