Back
Celtic Supporters Limited’s David Low has explained why the shareholder organisation is backing the re-election of five Celtic directors despite raising serious concerns about how the club is being run.
However, the organisation will withhold support from Dermot Desmond and James Mark Keane, citing concerns about their positions on key board committees.
For more, catch up on the latest Celtic news.
The decision to back five of the seven directors has prompted questions from some Celtic supporters online, who believe the group should be opposing more of the current board.
Speaking on the Celtic World Order podcast, Low explained why CSL has chosen this approach.
Low argued that voting against every director would achieve little because of Celtic’s existing shareholding structure.
He said: “Whether shareholders vote for or against a director, or whether they abstain, guess what? It’s going to change diddly squat.”
The shareholder group believes changes to Celtic’s governance will take time and cannot be achieved simply by voting against individual directors at the AGM.
Its decision means Nicholson, Wilson, Rose, McKay and Brown will receive CSL’s backing for another year.
However, that support comes with expectations.
CSL wants Celtic to publish a three-to-five-year plan, make the Nomination and Remuneration Committees independent, and ensure shareholders can ask questions at future AGMs.
The group has withheld support from Desmond because he chairs the Nomination Committee and sits on the Remuneration Committee while being Celtic’s largest shareholder.
It has also withheld support from Keane over his membership of the Remuneration Committee and an unanswered question about his nomination.
Low said CSL is concentrating on governance issues it believes could have a greater impact than voting against individual directors.
He referred to questions involving the Takeover Panel and arrangements surrounding Desmond’s increased shareholding in 2005.
The organisation is seeking clarification on those arrangements, which Low believes are more important than the immediate outcome of director re-election votes.
Addressing criticism of CSL’s approach, Low said: “We’re not going to compromise that at all, even whether the world and his wife thinks it’s wrong.”
He also disputed suggestions that opposition to CSL’s voting recommendations was widespread, saying most of the feedback received by the organisation had been supportive.
He described the current leadership as a dysfunctional board and raised concerns about how responsibilities are divided between individual directors.
Low also questioned whether the roles outlined in Celtic’s annual report reflect how decisions are made behind the scenes.
CSL will vote against proposed changes to Celtic’s Articles of Association at the separate General Meeting, while supporting calls for a published long-term plan and a review of security operations at Celtic Park.
Shareholders appointing CSL as their proxy can still instruct the organisation to vote differently on individual resolutions.
The General Meeting and AGM are scheduled for Tuesday, 1 December, at Celtic Park.