Back
There is a young Scottish talent making headlines during this international break, and this is a name that should be attracting particular attention at Celtic Park.
Lucas Clearie has showcased his goalscoring prowess by finding the net for Scotland Under-19s for the second time during the international break.
He scored against Kazakhstan before adding another from the penalty spot against Belgium. Two goals, growing attention and, perhaps most importantly, another reminder that Celtic might have a very interesting prospect developing right under their noses.
Now, I have a question for the people making decisions at Celtic Park: how much more does this young man have to do before somebody decides that he deserves a proper opportunity with the first team?
I am not suggesting that scoring goals at Under-19 level automatically makes somebody ready to walk into the Celtic starting eleven.
Football is considerably more complicated than that. There is a substantial difference between performing against your age-group opponents and dealing with the physicality, intensity and expectations of senior football.
I understand that perfectly well. However, there is also a difference between protecting a young footballer and keeping him so far away from meaningful first-team opportunities that his development eventually becomes somebody else’s business.
And that is precisely what I want Celtic to avoid.
Clearie is attracting increasing media attention, and his performances for Scotland are giving people another reason to look at his potential.
When a young footballer repeatedly demonstrates that he knows where the goal is, possesses confidence and can deliver on the international stage, the sensible response is to start examining what he might offer at a higher level.
Not to ignore him. Not to wait until everybody else has discovered him. And certainly not to allow another club to decide that he is worth investing in before Celtic have properly assessed their own youngster.
Celtic must be proactive rather than reactive.
Let me make one thing clear: I am not demanding that Martin O’Neill suddenly throw Clearie into a pressure-cooker situation and expect him to rescue Celtic’s season. That would be neither fair nor particularly intelligent. Young players need opportunities, but they also need sensible management, protection and a development pathway.
And to be fair, Celtic have already taken an encouraging first step. Clearie trained with the senior squad before the Europa League trip to Benfica in October and was included in the matchday squad for that game.
That was a positive development, and one I was delighted to see. But now I would like Celtic to build on it.
Let him continue training alongside the senior players. Let him experience the standards expected at Celtic and understand the movement, intensity and demands of senior football. And when circumstances allow, give him opportunities to get onto the pitch.
Perhaps he will surprise us. Perhaps he will need another six months of development. Perhaps he will require a loan spell before he can genuinely challenge for a place. We cannot know until somebody gives him the opportunity to show what he can do.
But we should at least find out.
And there is another consideration that Celtic cannot afford to overlook: the English clubs.
We have seen this story before.
Scottish youngsters attract attention, develop their reputations and suddenly become interesting propositions for clubs south of the border. Some of those clubs have considerably greater financial resources and are perfectly capable of offering young players opportunities, facilities and contracts that make their proposals difficult to ignore.
I would rather Celtic were having that conversation with Clearie as a genuine first-team prospect than reading about another promising youngster being snapped up by an English club. We have to act, in short, before they do.
Of course, I am not suggesting that every English club is waiting outside Lennoxtown with a chequebook. However, the reality of modern football is that talent attracts attention, and Celtic should understand that better than most.
We cannot keep talking about developing young Scottish footballers while failing to create convincing opportunities for them within our own first team. There is something fundamentally wrong with that approach.
Celtic should be a club where young Scottish footballers dream of making their breakthrough. Paradise should be the place where talented youngsters see a realistic pathway from the academy to the first team, not simply a stepping stone towards somebody else’s project.
And this brings me to a wider issue.
We often talk about Celtic needing fresh blood, energy and competition within the squad. We complain about recruitment, question the quality of certain performances and demand better options in particular positions. Yet how often do we properly examine the talent already developing within our own academy?
I want Celtic to be ambitious in the transfer market, absolutely. But ambition should not mean automatically looking elsewhere whenever we need another option. Sometimes the answer might already be wearing the green and white of Celtic’s youth teams.
Clearie’s latest international achievement should therefore be treated as another opportunity to assess his progress. His two goals for Scotland Under-19s are encouraging, and the growing attention surrounding him makes it even more important that Celtic have a clear development plan.
I would love to see O’Neill take another look at this youngster and give him the chance to demonstrate his potential among the senior players.
We do not need to promise him the world. We do not need to manufacture expectations or turn him into the next superstar before he has even made his first-team breakthrough.
We simply need to keep opening the door.
Because the worst possible scenario would be watching Lucas Clearie flourish somewhere else and then hearing Celtic supporters asking why we never gave him a proper opportunity.
My verdict? Get him involved, Celtic.
Give Lucas Clearie further first-team opportunities, assess his development and show him that Paradise can be his home for the foreseeable future.
We have enough examples of promising youngsters attracting attention elsewhere. We should be learning from those experiences rather than repeating them.
The boy is scoring goals, Scotland are taking notice, and the media are beginning to look in his direction.
Celtic, are you paying attention?
Choose The CelticBlog as a Preferred Source on Google News