flag
back Back
Celtic penalty outrage exposes Derek McInnes double standards – where’s the anger now?
Celtic penalty outrage exposes Derek McInnes double standards – where’s the anger now?

Isn’t it remarkable how quickly the outrage disappears when a controversial refereeing decision benefits the Ibrox club rather than Celtic?

Derek McInnes certainly has some explaining to do.

Not so long ago, the former Hearts manager was furious over Celtic’s controversial penalty against Motherwell. His reaction was strong enough to attract the attention of the Scottish FA.

Yet when Rangers benefited from a disputed spot-kick against St Mirren, the tone was considerably more measured.

Funny how that works.

Celtic penalties provoke fury

McInnes was among those who questioned the decision to award Celtic a penalty against Motherwell.

His criticism went beyond ordinary post-match frustration, eventually resulting in disciplinary consequences from the SFA.

Nobody is suggesting managers should remain silent when they believe officials have made mistakes.

Quite the opposite.

But surely the same standards should apply regardless of which club benefits?

That’s where this becomes interesting.

When Celtic receive a contentious decision, the reaction can become a national talking point. Former players, pundits and opposition managers queue up to question the officials.

Yet similar controversy involving Rangers rarely seems to generate the same level of sustained outrage from the same voices.

Where was that anger when Rangers benefited?

The disputed Rangers penalty against St Mirren provided another opportunity to examine the consistency of those complaints.

McInnes’s response was noticeably different from the anger surrounding the Celtic incident.

He was prepared to accept the assessment of his staff and the match officials rather than launch another furious public attack.

Now, there’s nothing wrong with respecting an official’s decision.

In fact, that should be encouraged.

But why does that measured approach appear so difficult when Celtic are involved?

That’s the question worth asking.

The issue isn’t whether either penalty was ultimately correct. Reasonable people can disagree about individual refereeing decisions.

The issue is consistency.

One rule for Celtic, another for Rangers?

Scottish football has developed an exhausting habit of treating every controversial Celtic decision as evidence of something sinister.

Meanwhile, when the Ibrox club benefits, the conversation often becomes considerably more forgiving.

We hear about difficult decisions, marginal calls and referees having only seconds to react.

Where is that understanding when Celtic are on the receiving end of the criticism?

McInnes is entitled to his opinions. He’s entitled to challenge referees, too.

However, supporters are equally entitled to examine whether those opinions remain consistent.

You cannot demand accountability in one situation and appear satisfied with a similar controversy in another without inviting scrutiny.

And that’s precisely why these contrasting reactions deserve attention.

Celtic supporters aren’t asking for special treatment.

They’re asking for the same standards to be applied to everyone.

If a decision deserves outrage when Celtic benefit, it deserves the same scrutiny when Rangers benefit.

Anything less looks suspiciously like selective indignation.

Key takeaways

  • Derek McInnes strongly criticised Celtic’s controversial Motherwell penalty.
  • His response to a disputed Rangers penalty against St Mirren was more measured.
  • Different reactions to refereeing controversy deserve examination.
  • Celtic should face the same standards as every other Scottish club.

Further reading

You may like

Rangers may explore Jens Hjerto-Dahl loan in January amid struggles at Hull City

rangersnews.uk 1 day ago

Armstrong on Rangers transfer links and McInnes admiration

www-tmp.thenational.scot 1 day ago

Why Kevin Kelsy is not starting for Rangers vs Motherwell

rangersnews.uk 19 hours ago

Sutton goads Rangers with title dare and warns of 'serious questions'

www-tmp.thenational.scot 22 hours ago

I love being a Rangers leader and my trophy lifting experience can help Ibrox young team become w...

Daily Record 1 day ago

Ryan Naderi makes ‘ugly’ joke live on air as Rangers clinch late win vs Motherwell

rangersnews.uk 16 hours ago

Fresh John Souttar blow makes Rangers blunder look more foolish than ever

rangersnews.uk 2 hours ago