Back
Chelsea supporters are far from happy with Xabi Alonso right now, and you cannot blame them.
He has overseen yet another humiliating defeat after Saturday’s 4-1 loss to Leeds United at Stamford Bridge. Last month, Chelsea also lost at home to fierce rivals Tottenham Hotspur.
Chelsea fans are now starting to turn on Alonso. During the Leeds game, the Stamford Bridge faithful, in effect, told the Spaniard that he is clueless.
At this point, Alonso may be contemplating making one big tactical change, which may not go down well with some Chelsea supporters.
TalkingPoints
🚨 Not a SINGLE one of Xabi Alonso’s substitutions has registered a goal or assist this season! 😡 With his in-game decisions under the spotlight, how much faith to you still have in the manager?
At the beginning of the season, Chelsea were lining up in a back three/five. A lot of Chelsea fans were not on board with it, as it did not allow room for Estevao Willian.
Alonso’s 3-4-2-1 formation meant there was only space for three attackers, Cole Palmer, Morgan Rogers and Joao Pedro, who were all in undroppable form at the time.
Eventually, Alonso switched to a back four and Chelsea picked up some good results in that shape, beating Everton 2-0 away, for example. For Estevao’s biggest backers, this was the way forward. Chelsea were picking up points and the Brazilian was starting to receive more opportunities.
However, following Saturday’s disaster, one Chelsea supporter on TalkingPoints has suggested that the team were playing better in a back three and have the players for that system, including new signings Pep Chavarria and Marco Palestra.
Featured comment
peterpickering58
@caleb.sage we bought two good full backs that can play back five
Join the conversation →
How valid is any call for Chelsea to return to a back three? Valid, but how have Chelsea fared in each set-up, and why did Alonso alter things in the first place? These questions are worth exploring.
Breaking things down, then, Chelsea have used a back three on six occasions in the Premier League this season, according to Transfermarkt. They won three of those games and lost the other three, giving them a win rate of 50%.
In a back four, which they used against Leeds on Saturday, that win rate drops by 10%. Of course, 11 games in, we do not have the largest sample, but the number of goals Chelsea have conceded in each set-up paints an interesting picture.
| Chelsea’s formations this season | Games | Wins | Losses | Draws | Win rate | Goals | Goals per game | Goals conceded | Goals conceded per game |
| Back three | 6 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 50% | 13 | 2.17 | 13 | 2.17 |
| Back four | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 40% | 7 | 1.4 | 7 | 1.4 |
Looking at the above, reverting back to a back three will not be an instant fix. Chelsea have conceded more goals on average in a back three than a back four.
With that being said, they have scored at a higher rate and have a better win ratio in their 3-4-2-1 formation. Why did Alonso change things? It was his preferred formation at Bayer Leverkusen, and he clearly wanted to use it at Chelsea after employing the system in pre-season and at the beginning of the campaign.
Again, Alonso came under pressure from supporters and the media to give Estevao more opportunities, which was not possible in his 3-4-2-1 formation, while injuries have made it difficult to use a back three at times.
For example, Chelsea are currently without Maxence Lacroix, who was playing as the middle centre-back in Alonso’s back three.
It is true, Chelsea have conceded more goals in a back three. But off the ball, when that three becomes a five with the wing-backs helping out to defend, teams do tend to be more solid and compact compared to if they were in a back four. Chelsea’s problem is the quality of centre-backs they have occupying those three roles.
If the Blues had three world-class centre-backs, there is not a chance they would be conceding more goals in a back five than a back four.
Ultimately, it is a system that Alonso should probably go back to. It is what he believes in, and Chelsea actually attack better in it; the numbers prove it. With better quality in the centre of defence, that goals conceded per game number will drop down.
Levi Colwill and Wesley Fofana have not been in form this season. If they are the core of your central defence, you are going to concede goals in any system.
Chelsea should buy another centre-half or two, which should help Alonso to implement his ideology a bit better. Chelsea have been linked with Alessandro Bastoni recently, and building a three-man defence around someone like him while unleashing a three-man attack of Palmer, Pedro and Rogers could take the club far.
It will upset some Chelsea fans, as it would reduce Estevao’s minutes. But the overall signs look better when Chelsea are in a back three, they just need more quality there.