Back
Comparisons between Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady often come down to championships, longevity, and what each quarterback has accomplished under pressure. Mahomes is still building his career, while Brady spent two decades setting records and winning titles.
But a former Patriots teammate of Brady believes there is one physical part of the game where Mahomes has an advantage, even if matching Brady’s career remains a much bigger challenge.
Three-time Super Bowl champion Willie McGinest discussed the comparison during an appearance on “All The Smoke Unplugged” with Matt Barnes.
Barnes asked McGinest what he had noticed about Mahomes that Brady might not do as well, given his experience playing alongside the former Patriots quarterback.
McGinest pointed to Mahomes’ throwing ability, particularly his arm strength and natural talent. He also suggested Brady would likely agree with that assessment.
“Well, I mean, his arm, the way he throws the ball, his arm strength and his arm talent, I would say, is probably better. And Tom would probably tell you the same thing,” McGinest said.
However, McGinest was careful not to reduce the comparison to physical ability. Having shared a locker room with Brady in New England, he described a competitive side of the quarterback that went well beyond his public image.
“And Tom, like his mentality, he’s a [Expletive] dog. And that dog comes out. He’s politically correct, you know, when he’s doing the interviews and all that other [Expletive], but Tom’s a killer,” McGinest said.
He also recalled Brady’s willingness to make personal sacrifices to maintain his level of play. “And Tom will tell you, ‘I sacrifice parts of my life so I can play this way.’ And that’s some deep [Expletive] if a player tells you that.”
McGinest acknowledged that Mahomes is on a Hall of Fame path, but said Brady’s career remains difficult to match.
Brady won seven Super Bowls, including one with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and reached the championship game 10 times. He also maintained that level of success across two decades.
“Tom got seven chips and won with another team and was in a Super Bowl every two years. For two decades, you know what I mean? So that’s hard footsteps to follow in,” McGinest said.
Meanwhile, Mahomes, who ranks 5th on PFN’s NFL QB Impact metric, has continued to build his case in Kansas City. Through nine games in the 2026 season, he has guided the Chiefs to a 7-2 record, throwing for 2,385 yards, 19 touchdowns and four interceptions.
His 106.7 passer rating also marks a strong response after Kansas City finished 6-11 and missed the playoffs in 2025.
The Chiefs have won two straight games after a midseason dip, with Mahomes throwing ten touchdowns and no interceptions across his previous three outings. His latest performance came against Atlanta, where he passed for 348 yards and five touchdowns in a 35-13 win.
McGinest’s comparison leaves room for both quarterbacks’ strengths. Mahomes may have the advantage in arm talent, but Brady’s championship record, longevity, and competitive drive remain the standard he must chase.