Back
While Bruno Guimaraes was never likely to elicit the same response as Alexander Isak from the Newcastle United faithful at St James’ Park upon his return, it was of little surprise to see the Brazilian booed. The way in which he reacted also says a lot about what was a messy situation.
Guimaraes is one of the greatest players in Newcastle United history and captained the team to their first trophy in over 70 years. That is worthy of respect and so was his desire to leave the club in pursuit of a new challenge.
Those who suggest that Newcastle fans booed Guimaraes for simply leaving have it wrong, however, and the look on his face as they came out in full force upon his substitution 70 minutes into the enthralling 2-2 draw with Arsenal sums up the situation rather well.
TalkingPoints
Newcastle fight back to draw 2-2 with Arsenal 💪 What stood out for you?!
What a game, by the way 🔥
There was an angry if not somewhat bemused look on his face when he made his way off the pitch he once dominated weekly in place of Myles Lewis-Skelly. That was obvious on the TV cameras, but was also noted upon by Jordan Cronin of Newcastle World, while Keith Downie of Sky Sports claimed Guimaraes looked “upset” when doing a post-match lap of the pitch.
Perhaps the Brazilian expected it but there did appear to be a justifiable sense of glee after he was taken off by Mikel Arteta, having put in a relatively underwhelming performance.
It was also notable that big tackles from Sean Steur and Lewis Miley on Guimaraes generated huge noises from the crowd, a set of supporters who idolised him only a few months ago.
It’s impossible to speak for every supporter, of course. There may well have been a pantomime element to it all, booed with a tongue-in-cheek rather than with any vitriol.
Featured comment
freddie
You can say all you want Bruno, you still jumped shipped when things are looking bad. One of the best players in a while, this feels fake just like Isak
Join the conversation →
Still, Guimaraes did invoke the ire of fans at times over the course of the summer. The way in which his move to Arsenal was played out in the media was hugely frustrating, with so many suggestions of ghost bids done through intermediaries.
Guimaraes was proud to be Newcastle United captain yet jumped ship at the first real sign of trouble. Though understandable given how short a player’s career is, it doesn’t mean fans have to like it.
Guimaraes’ messy exit from Newcastle left at least some confusion in its wake. Wanting to join the Premier League champions was obvious but the fact there were so many media reports of there being no club-to-club contact for so long left things up in the air. He then joined the club’s pre-season tour of La Manga, only to leave shortly after.
It happened over the course of weeks and months, yet never seemed as dramatic as the Isak saga. Really, it was quite an underwhelming end to a story that burned so bright.
The midfielder did a lot for the club and was under no obligation to stay for the rest of his life but fans are within their rights to be angry. The idea that he might have been confused is so worth thinking about, considering all he did for the club.
Whereas Isak appeared to ignore the boos, Guimaraes did at least show some emotion, which would at least suggest – and perhaps this is a generous reading – he does genuinely care about the club and his legacy on Tyneside.
There was never any right or wrong answer when it came to the question of booing Guimaraes. Anger, a slight sense of confusion and a respect for his legacy are all perfectly reasonable.