Back
Every player is awarded a mark from 1-10.
A virtual spectator other than the odd clearance until dying minutes.
Untroubled 6
Did little wrong as but not as offensively-minded as the concussed Matty Cash. Tied up late on which almost cost his side.
Conservative 6
Started in his preferred centre-back position in place of the injured Victor Lindelof. One excellent late tackle to deny visitors.
Composed 7
Stepped up to carry ball jnto midfield when given the chance and did well overall.
Untroubled 6
Effectively played as a left-winger with Sunderland sitting so deep. Worked hard to try to provide some spark.
Attacking 7
A day when very little came off for the Brazilian. Sliced excellent late chance well wide.
Frustrated 5
Germany international is always tidy but perhaps needed a little too much time on the ball and could have looked for more progressive passes.
Safe 6
Took the armband from the start and patrolled the middle of the park effectively if unspectacularly.
Steady 6
Surprise starter after missing Switzerland games during international break. A long-range shot in the first half troubled the keeper, but he was not at his best. Subbed on the hour.
Hooked 5
Villa's most effective attacking presence in the first half and almost forced a goal with excellent pressure late in first period. Taken off on the hour.
Busy 6
Almost forced a chance early on with nice turn and run but failed to find a teammate when he should have done. Subbed off.
Quiet 5
John McGinn (Manzambi, 60) 7, Ibrahim Mbaye (Buendia, 60) 5, Ross Barkley (Goretzka, 73) 5, Brian Madjo (Jackson, 73) 4. Not used: Bizot, Cisse, Gomes, Hemmings, Mings.