Back
When most fans/analysts look at how successful teams are on 4th down, they look at conversion percentage. While conversion is certainly valuable in an overall assessment, the volume of 4th-down attempts can skew those numbers. For example, is a team that converts its only 4th-down attempt a better 4th-down team than the team that converts 8 of its 10 tries?
That's why I also like to incorporate other ways to measure success, and one of the most common is EPA. In the chart below, you can see the season totals for EPA gain on 4th-down attempts.
While this chart alone isn't enough to find a definitive answer, it is notable that all 11 teams ranked in the Top 10 in 4th-down conversion rate are also in the Top 14 in EPA gained.
For example, the Lions are No. 7 in conversion rate (70.59%) but No. 1 in EPA gained because Dan Campbell goes for it on 4th down so often (6th most in the NFL). Other teams that are also aggressive because they're successful include the Saints, Packers, and Cowboys.
Now, compare them to the Lions' most recent opponent, the New England Patriots, who rank 4th in EPA gained and 4th in conversion rate, but 20th in 4th-down attempts. You can also see this more measured, yet successful approach in teams like the Bills and Rams.
Lastly, teams like the Broncos, Bengals, Giants, and 49ers rank in the bottom 10 in 4th-down attempts, yet still top 10 in conversion rate and top 14 in EPA gained, suggesting they play more conservatively on 4th down but make their attempts count.