Back
Elerewe, who has played every game for The Imps this term, was also involved in a penalty claim after Kieffer Moore went down having had his shirt pulled by the defender.
But Shaw believes all of his team were too lax in possession in the build-up to Thomason's goal.
He said: "The feeling leading up to the goal was that we got a bit too comfortable with the ball.
"A few passes went a little bit off script and we were perhaps irresponsible at times.
“But the people, the players and the group involved will learn really quickly that you can’t indulge anyone at any moment at this level and we got punished."
Shaw also felt Lincoln were more than a match for Wrexham on Saturday afternoon, with the ex-Chester captain insisting his side will only learn from a fourth straight defeat.
“It’s a very disappointing outcome.
“I thought we went toe to-toe with Wrexham on the whole.
“The result has been decided by an error, but it will be a big learn for us as a group.
"We were trying to force the game, trying to find a way to win it and unfortunately we’ve come away with zero points."