flag
back Back
All Blacks team: Winners and losers as ‘lucky’ players have point to prove while Dave Rennie makes ‘odd call’
Beauden Barrett, Anton Lienert-Brown and Leicester Fainga'anuku (inset) in action for the All Blacks against Wales.
Beauden Barrett, Anton Lienert-Brown and Leicester Fainga'anuku in action for the All Blacks against Wales.

Following the announcement of the All Blacks team to face England in the Nations Championship clash on Saturday, here are our winners and losers from Dave Rennie’s selections.

Winners

Beauden Barrett

Congratulations to the legendary All Black, who will take to the field for a staggering 150th time in Test match rugby. On the basis of last weekend’s Wales performance, Barrett is lucky to be involved, but he proved against the Wallabies and Scotland that he can still be a quality operator at the highest level and will need to show that at Twickenham.

Anton Lienert-Brown

Another player that is possibly fortunate to be selected this weekend. Of course, had Quinn Tupaea been fit, Lienert-Brown would not have started, but the first choice centre’s injury has enabled the 31-year-old to shift from 12 to 13, where he will partner Jordie Barrett.

In fairness to Lienert-Brown, he was one of the All Blacks’ better backs against Wales, especially defensively, but he has still not wholly convinced onlookers that he has what it takes at Test level now that he is the wrong side of 30.

Josh Moorby

The Hurricanes star has enjoyed a good first foray into Test rugby, establishing himself in this New Zealand set-up since making his debut earlier this year. However, after an excellent southern leg of the Nations Championship, it has been a mixed bag from the wing since.

There has been the good (second Wallabies Test), the bad (Springboks series) and the downright ugly (Wales), but he has got the nod alongside Beauden Barrett and the returning Will Jordan in the back three.

Richie Mo’unga

Some might put Mo’unga in the ‘loser’ category having seen him lose his place in the XV but, on the basis of his performance in Cardiff, it is remarkable that he has made the 23 at all. The 32-year-old had a torrid time at the Principality Stadium, so it is a surprise to see him remain involved.

It does obviously get them extra playmaking options with Rennie evidently deciding that he wants a creative presence at full-back, rather than moving someone like Jordan to 15 should either Damian McKenzie or Beauden Barrett get injured.

Leicester Fainga’anuku

Played his first Test as a loose forward last Saturday but it was perhaps not the best game to judge him, so he gets another opportunity on this weekend. In the same fixture last year, Fainga’anuku started on the wing and scored a try, but it will be a surprise if he features among the backline in the 2026 clash.

Having a hybrid like Fainga’anuku available enables a coach to drop a back from their bench, like the Springboks and, to some extent, England have done, but New Zealand have gone the opposite way by still leaving out a forward in order to select the Crusaders star. It is a bit of an odd call in truth with the Pom Squad in opposition.

Other embarrassed All Blacks

Rennie has effectively reverted back to the side that defeated Scotland – Tupaea’s enforced absence the exception – so the likes of the Barrett brothers, Beauden and Scott, Fletcher Newell, Wallace Sititi and Peter Lakai were never going to be dropped, but some of those individuals need big shifts to reward the head coach’s loyalty.

While Wales deserved immense praise after their historic victory, from an All Blacks perspective, it was a mortifying loss. After making plenty of unwanted history under Ian Foster and Scott Robertson, fans hoped the same would not happen with Rennie at the helm, but it has and they need to avoid a repeat in their final two Tests of the year.

Losers

Xavier Numia

Once again the loosehead didn’t do enough in the eyes of the All Blacks head coach to usurp George Bower in the pecking order. You certainly couldn’t accuse Numia of being lazy during his time on the field against Wales, with the prop carrying plenty of times, but if anything he tried to do too much and that resulted in the visitors becoming too predictable.

Josh Lord

There is no doubt that Rennie likes the lock with the Chiefs star featuring in seven of their 11 Tests so far this year, starting five, but he has slipped behind Fabian Holland in the pecking order and, with the tourists opting for no second-row cover on the bench, Lord has been left twiddling his thumbs on the sidelines.

The 25-year-old was certainly not worse than his team-mates in Cardiff, but there was perhaps a lack of physicality against a Welsh side who were effective in contact, and it is something they will require in spades at Twickenham.

Kyle Preston

It is tight for that reserve scrum-half role but it is Cortez Ratima who has the edge at the moment and, on the basis of last week, we tend to agree. Despite criticism, Ratima was actually solid and did his job well, while Preston struggled when he came on.

Rennie felt they were too one-dimensional in the second period and the replacement half-back was partly at fault for that as he failed to organise his pack well enough and play with enough variety to stretch that impressive Welsh defence.

Timoci Tavatavanawai

After a bench role against Scotland, he has suddenly disappeared again. It is understandable why Lienert-Brown gets the starting role at 13 but to receive no game time over these two weeks is slightly bizarre.

Particularly when it comes to the bench, it is slightly lightweight from 19 onwards and Tavatavanawai would have given them real power in the second half. With Fainga’anuku able to cover wing and centre, surely you don’t need Rieko Ioane among the replacements.

We would argue it would be better with the 6-2 and be without both Ioane and Tavatavanawai but, now that he has gone 5-3 (or 4-4 if you include Fainga’anuku as a back), the latter is unlucky to miss out.

Josh Jacomb

As suggested earlier, Rennie had the option to not go with a reserve fly-half given that both Beauden Barrett and McKenzie are in the starting XV, but he is desperate to keep that playmaking axis at 10 and 15, which means Mo’unga is there as cover.

However, it is a conservative move from the head coach, who has refused to give Jacomb a Test opportunity so far this year. The 25-year-old was very impressive during the tour games in South Africa and many would argue he deserves a chance in a matchday squad, especially given Mo’unga’s struggles in Cardiff.

Fehi Fineanganofo

With Jordan back from his hamstring injury, it was effectively between Moorby and Fineanganofo for a starting spot, but the latter did not really take his opportunity in the XV despite getting over for a try. He struggled defensively and, in a team which suffered a poor loss, he was among those to pay the price for that abject result.

You may like

Justin Marshall fumes with message to ‘arrogant’ All Blacks: ‘Do you know what you’ve done to the...

planetrugby.com 13 hours ago

Sir Steve Hansen sees ‘massive difference’ from Scott Robertson regime after providing ‘100 per c...

planetrugby.com 1 hour ago

All Blacks team to play England: Will Jordan returns in predicted XV as Rennie rings changes

ruck.co.uk 2 days ago

Why Damian McKenzie has become a vital cog in the All Blacks' attack

rugbypass.com 2 hours ago

Springboks coach confirms he’s leaving Rassie Erasmus to join All Blacks

ruck.co.uk 1 hour ago

All Blacks great Beauden Barrett on cusp of previously untouched milestone

rugbypass.com 1 day ago