Back
The Celtic AGM is fast approaching, and once again, Dermot Desmond won’t be present, but in truth, it would be more of a surprise if he turned up for once.
While quite a proportion of the Celtic Park fanbase have been against the board and Dermot Desmond for a while, you sense that anger and frustration have grown over the chaotic past 12 months.
TalkingPoints
Now that all of Celtic’s signings have had time to settle, what do you make of the summer business looking back?
Who has impressed and who has fell short of expectations?
Methven is famous or infamous for appearing in the Sunderland Til I Die Netflix documentary in 2018, where things didn’t go as planned for the English businessman, as the now-Premier League side were relegated to England’s third tier.
But Methven has been vocal about the goings-on at Celtic, and how he feels that Desmond has managed to exploit a ‘loophole’, regarding his shares at the club.
When a single shareholder takes a stake in a company above 30 per cent, which is the case for Desmond, they must launch an offer for all the shares in the company.
Methven believes Desmond has used the ‘whitewash’ loophole to avoid going down that road, but continues to have a significant influence on the club.
“Extremely unusual,” said Methven about how Celtic are currently structured and run. “It’s very, very unusual in any quoted company to have a 35% shareholder.
“That’s just seriously unusual. Effectively, what happens in the quoted company world is that when you get above 29%, you have to make an automatic offer to other shareholders to take out the business as a whole.
“The reason for that is that they worked out many, many decades ago that if you have a single minority shareholder who is above a certain level, that person, effectively, will end up having an undue influence over the running of that organisation, because they are such a significant block, that the executives will naturally orient themselves towards that person’s interests and will not necessarily be able to take account of all the shareholders’ interests, which is what a quoted company is meant to be.
“Now, there is a loophole, which very rarely gets exploited and very rarely gets used. But it must have happened in this case. It’s what’s called a ‘whitewash.’
“Where, basically, there is a discussion that happens between that shareholder and the Takeover Panel, the conversation normally goes around, ‘Oh, it looks like I am going to go over 30%. I didn’t really mean to go over 30%, but there has been a rights issue. Other people have diluted, and I have ended up above 30%. I don’t really want to launch a full takeover. Would you mind accepting me from that rule?’
“The answer to that, always in a whitewash, is ‘Yes, okay. I don’t want to see you anywhere near the f___ing running of that club or that business. You keep your nose clean; we are letting you off the rule here. We are giving you a favour, so you have to be squeaky clean on this.'”
You have to truly laugh at what happened at last year’s AGM, how it was cancelled, but most importantly, the comedy act of Ross Desmond – Dermot’s son.
If anything like that is tried again, then expect more ugly scenes, but hopefully, this time, it can be completed so that voices can be heard.
Martin O’Neill was present for last year’s AGM because it happened during his first spell, before he returned in January following the sacking of Wilfried Nancy.
While the Celtic supporters don’t want this to be the case, given how this club is being run and the continued absence of Dermot Desmond from these AGMs, you just sense that the relationship between fans and the board will remain broken.